I love these threads, they get the gays all riled up.
Celine's D5 is way better btw. That one's obvious.
Not anymore, they used B'day era footage, from the I am... era on up Bey would slice her throat. And poor Christina, thinking if she holds the note long it will hide the flaws.
And the interesting thing is, girls like Mariah have a hard time belting because it always turns into a whistle. Mariahs belting register is pure and full, but the register is forced and scratchy above E-flat.
Not anymore, they used B'day era footage, from the I am... era on up Bey would slice her throat. And poor Christina, thinking if she holds the note long it will hide the flaws.
Have you noticed that Christina tends to use the same trick with every belt? At least Beyoncé has some variation when she belts.
Whistle register isn't really that rare for girls, they almost always do when they get surprise, what they just lacked was that control to do it at the right moment... and even some experienced singers messes up using that register... Plus WR is something that should be avoided if you feel like you can't do it even though you have done it a lot of times...
I'm not really fond of belting although i'm capable myself, but among the girls listed, Kelly Clarkson has the best belting voice but back in the day, whitney was the beast...
This is not obliged to turn into a star war, you should respect each other opinion, give yours and move on. I think that's the only way the thread will survive.
there is nothing jennifer can do Erykah cant do except that erykha can belt higher and has a better control over her belting oh and amber riley from glee can belt as high as jennifer so where does that leave her again