Quote:
Originally posted by Monroe
I can't handle the Gaga fans inventing categories which have nothing to do with talent in order to make Gaga look better by comparison to Beyonce. It's obvious Gaga can't take on Beyonce in the singing and dancing department (two huge categories in regard to pure natural talent) and rather then just admit that it seems like they have to add irrelevant categories to try to make them equal or to try to spin it in Gaga's favor. The mature thing to do would be simply to admit that Gaga is short in those two categories. These two are clearly the top performers out right now, but I think it's fair to acknowledge that Beyonce is better. Give her, her due. She's been at it for years she deserves to be the top right now. Gaga just came out.
I'm not listing personality, utilization of social media, or acting because that is not musically relevant. I'm also not listing musical preferences (albums or singles) either because that isn't about natural talent. I also don't see what music videos have to do with talent unless you are talking about film direction, which isn't a musical talent regardless. Neither Gaga nor Beyonce seem to be great producers to me any way, if we take what has been given recently. Although I would give the edge to Beyonce simply because she has produced more.
* Musicality: Lady Gaga
* Dancing: Beyonce'
* Performing: Beyoncé
* Songwriting: Lady Gaga
* Vocals: Beyoncé
Beyonce is the more talented individual by FAR, but I like Gaga's music more. There is a difference between the two posters.
|
When and where exactly did Gaga stans "invent" these extra categories? As far as I can tell, they've been used in all these comparison polls up to this point (including those which didn't involve Gaga), and it wasn't Gaga stans who were the first to be using them in this thread, so come off it.
"The mature thing to do..." LOL. Give me a ****ing break. The significant majority of Gaga fans here voted for Beyonce as the better performer in that particular direct poll against Gaga, but this is a different question than simply asking about performing talent alone.
Im not here for this vague "musical creation process" being what overrides Beyonce's actual natural talent.
