[Mr. Fahrenheit]

Originally posted by madonnas

You put Bedtime Stories on the same tier as HC and MDNA though.

Bedtime Stories is top tier, tier 2 on a bad day.

I just think some of it's MOR, and I don't like all of the Hippity-Hoppity thing she was going for.

I think Denis Rodman was having an affect.

[alkralkra]

The Queen of Pop

Favorite Song: Borderline, Into the Groove, Get Together
Least favorite song: Girl Gone Wild
Favorite non single: Till Death Do Us Part, Where Life Begins, Where's the Party
Favorite song lyrically: Don't Tell Me, Till Death Do Us Part etc
Favorite song vocally: Ray of Light? Great vocal performance though I don't love the song itself
Least favorite song lyrically: American Life
Least favorite song vocally: Girl Gone Wild
Most underrated single: Singles from her debut
Most underrated non-single: Idk
Most overrated song: Hung Up, Ray of Light, Frozen etc
Favorite album: Her debut
Least favorite album: American Life
Most underrated album: Bedtime Stories
Most overrated album: RAY OF LIGHT

[madonnas]

Favorite Song: Rude Boy
Least favorite song: What's My Name?
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Wait Your Turn
Favorite song lyrically: Stupid In Love
Favorite song vocally: Rude Boy
Least favorite song lyrically: What's My Name?
Least favorite song vocally: What's My Name?
Most underrated song: Stupid In Love
Most overrated song: What's My Name?
Favorite album: Rated R
Least favorite album: LOUD
Most underrated album: Talk that Talk
Most overrated album: LOUD

[alkralkra]

You really HATE What's My Name don't you.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by alkralkra

You really HATE What's My Name don't you.

Something about it just sets me off and angers me inside.

[bobbymfw]

Lady Gaga

Favorite Song: "The Edge of Glory"
Least favorite song: "Speechless"
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): "I Like it Rough"
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): "Poker Face"
Favorite song lyrically: "Paparazzi" and the bridge in "Dance in the Dark"
Favorite song vocally: "Alejandro"
Least favorite song lyrically: "Americano"
Least favorite song vocally: "Americano"
Most underrated song: "Alejandro"
Most overrated song: "Bad Romance"
Favorite album: The Fame
Least favorite album: Born This Way
Most underrated album: The Fame
Most overrated album: The Fame Monster

Beyonce

Favorite Song: "Disappear" and "Check On It"
Least favorite song: "Run the World (Girls)"
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): "Disappear"
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): "Irreplaceable"
Favorite song lyrically: "Disappear"
Favorite song vocally: "Irreplaceable," "Halo," "I Miss You"
Least favorite song lyrically: "Diva"
Least favorite song vocally: "Run the World (Girls)"
Most underrated song: "Me, Myself, and I" or "Work It Out"
Most overrated song: "Single Ladies"
Favorite album: B'Day
Least favorite album: I am...Sasha Fierce
Most underrated album: B'Day
Most overrated album: 4

Britney Spears

Favorite Song: "Unusual You"
Least favorite song: "From the Bottom of My Broken Heart" and "Shadow"
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): "Unusual You"
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): "I'm a Slave 4 U"
Favorite song lyrically: "Unusual You"
Favorite song vocally: "Unusual You"
Least favorite song lyrically: "Touch of My Hand"
Least favorite song vocally: "3"
Most underrated song: "My Baby"
Most overrated song: "Inside Out"
Favorite album: In the Zone
Least favorite album: Oops!...I Did it Again
Most underrated album: Circus
Most overrated album: Blackout

Madonna

Favorite Song: "Mer Girl" and "Secret Garden"
Least favorite song: "Girl Gone Wild"
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): "Mer Girl" and "Secret Garden"
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): "Open Your Heart"
Favorite song lyrically: "Words"
Favorite song vocally: "The Power of Goodbye"
Least favorite song lyrically: "4 Minutes"
Least favorite song vocally: "Girl Gone Wild"
Most underrated song: "I'll Remember" and "What It Feels Like for a Girl"
Most overrated song: "Hung Up"
Favorite album: Erotica and Ray of Light
Least favorite album: MDNA
Most underrated album: Erotica
Most overrated album: Like a Prayer

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Favorite Song: Firebomb or Skin.
Least favorite song: Stupid in Love.
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): --
Favorite song lyrically: Cold Case Love.
Favorite song vocally: ... Only Girl, California King Bed.
Least favorite song lyrically: Rude Boy,
Least favorite song vocally: um... G4L.
Most underrated song: Cold Case Love, Firebomb.
Most overrated song: Umbrella, We Found Love.
Favorite album: Rated R or Loud.
Least favorite album: Good Girl.
Most underrated album: Talk that Talk.
Most overrated album: Good Girl.

[OnikaSlays]

Favorite Song: We Found Love
Least favorite song: Red Lipstick
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Watch N Learn
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): Cake
Favorite song lyrically: Firebomb
Favorite song vocally: California King Bed
Least favorite song lyrically: Red Lipstick
Least favorite song vocally: ?
Most underrated song: Watch N Learn
Most overrated song: Umbrella
Favorite album: Loud
Least favorite album: Rated R
Most underrated album: Talk That Talk
Most overrated album: Loud

[alkralkra]

Good sis RihRih

Favorite Song: Fire Bomb
Least favorite song: S&M
Favorite single: Umbrella
Favorite song lyrically: G4L
Favorite song vocally: Rude Boy
Least favorite song lyrically: S&M
Least favorite song vocally: Drunk on Love
Most underrated song: Idk
Most overrated song: S&M
Favorite album: GGGB/RR
Least favorite album: TTT
Most underrated album: none
Most overrated album: RR

[MsCherry]

Favorite Song: Good girl gone bad/LTWYL pt 2/We found love
Least favorite song Rude boy
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single) We found love
Favorite song lyrically Good girl gone bad
Favorite song vocally LTWYL pt 2
Least favorite song lyrically Rude boy
Least favorite song vocally Cheers
Most underrated song LTWYL pt 2
Most overrated song Rude boy
Favorite album GGGB
Least favorite album A girl like me
Most underrated album Loud
Most overrated album Rated R

[PeterTheMonster]

Rihanna

Favorite Song: Umbrella
Least favorite song: Cockiness
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Watch N' Learn
Favorite song lyrically: Firebomb
Favorite song vocally: California King Bed
Least favorite song lyrically: Half of TTT
Least favorite song vocally: Cockiness
Most underrated song: Watch N Learn
Most overrated song: WE FOUND LOVE
Favorite album: Rated R
Least favorite album: Talk That Talk
Most underrated album: Good Girl Gone Bad (?)
Most overrated album: Loud

[Sloth]

Favorite Song: Disturbia
Least favorite song: That La, La, La
Favorite non single: Cold Case Love
Favorite single: Rude Boy
Favorite song lyrically: Russian Roulette
Favorite song vocally: Te Amo
Least favorite song lyrically: We Found Love
Least favorite song vocally: What's My Name?
Most underrated song: Stupid In Love
Most overrated song: We Found Love
Favorite album: GGGB
Least favorite album: A Girl Like Me/Music of the Sun
Most underrated album: RR
Most overrated album: LOUD

[Kang.]

Originally posted by Ainsworth

But....

It's like... her 10th best, but it IS a good album. It doesn't deserve all the hate it gets.

For Rih:

Favorite Song: We Found Love/Umbrella
Least favorite song: Birthday Cake Remix
Favorite non single: Fire Bomb
Favorite song lyrically: Fire Bomb
Favorite song vocally: We Found Love
Least favorite song lyrically: Birthday Cake (Remix)
Least favorite song vocally: One of the MOTS songs
Most underrated song: Skin
Most overrated song: Birthday Cake Remix
Favorite album: Good Girl Gone Bad
Least favorite album: Music of the Sun
Most underrated album: Loud
Most overrated album: None (maybe Rated R by a teensy bit )

[waryofothers]

Favorite Song: Rude Boy
Least favorite song: Meh.
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Raining Men
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single): Rude Boy
Favorite song lyrically: Take a Bow
Favorite song vocally: Complicated
Least favorite song lyrically:
Least favorite song vocally:
Most underrated song: Unfaithful
Most overrated song: Umbrella
Favorite album: Rated R/Loud
Least favorite album: Music of the Sun
Most underrated album: Good Girl Gone Bad
Most overrated album: Loud

[madonnas]

Favorite Song: ET
Least favorite song: The One that Got Away
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): What am I Living For
Favorite song lyrically: ET
Favorite song vocally: ET
Least favorite song lyrically: The One that Got Away
Least favorite song vocally: Firework
Most underrated song: ET
Most overrated song: Firework
Favorite album: Teenage Dream
Least favorite album: One of the Boys
Most underrated album: Teenage Dream
Most overrated album: One of the Boys

[alkralkra]

Favorite Song: Waking Up in Vegas
Least favorite song: Circle the Drain, Peacock, I don't even remember all the crap on OOTB, etc
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Hummingbird Heartbeat
Favorite song lyrically: Teenage Dream?
Favorite song vocally: none
Least favorite song lyrically: Circle the Drain, Who Am I Living For, Peacock, songs with extra corny lyrics on OOTB
Least favorite song vocally: I Kissed a Girl
Most underrated song: Hummingbird Heartbeat, I know it's a fan fave but I can't think of one
Most overrated song: ET
Favorite album: none
Least favorite album: One of the Boys
Most underrated album: none
Most overrated album: One of the Boys

[TrashyNavy]

doing Katy
Favorite Song: Last Friday Night
Least favorite song: If You Can Afford Me
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Circle The Drain
Favorite song lyrically: Dressin' Up
Favorite song vocally: Firework
Least favorite song lyrically: The One That Got Away
Least favorite song vocally: Wide Awake
Most underrated song: Circle The Drain
Most overrated song: Teenage Dream
Favorite album: Teenage Dream
Least favorite album: One Of The Boys
Most underrated album: none
Most overrated album: none

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Favorite Song: Teenage Dream, Wide Awake.
Least favorite song: Lost.
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single): Mannequin.
Favorite song lyrically: Wide Awake, Teenage Dream, Mannequin.
Favorite song vocally: Not Like The Movies, Thinking of You.
Least favorite song lyrically: Pearl.
Least favorite song vocally: Pearl.
Most underrated song: Not Like The Movies.
Most overrated song: Part of Me.
Favorite album: Both.
Least favorite album: --
Most underrated album: One of the Boys.
Most overrated album: Teenage Dream.

[Lucas32]

Favorite Song: Fingerprints
Least favorite song: I kissed a girl
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single) Fingerprints
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single) Waking up in Vegas
Favorite song lyrically Fingerprints
Favorite song vocally One of the boys
Least favorite song lyrically Peacock
Least favorite song vocally Peacock
Most underrated song Fingerpints
Most overrated song E.T.
Favorite album OOFB
Least favorite album Teenage Dream
Most underrated album OOTB
Most overrated album TD

[Blueberry Mary]

Favorite Song: Hot N Cold
Least favorite song : Pearl
Favorite non single (if favorite song is a single) : Hummingbird Heartbeat
Favorite single (if favorite song is not a single) : Pearl
Favorite song lyrically : Thinking Of You
Favorite song vocally : Teenage Dream
Least favorite song lyrically : Peacock
Least favorite song vocally : Who Am I Living For
Most underrated song : Thinking Of You
Most overrated song : ET
Favorite album : Teenage Dream
Least favorite album : One Of The Boys
Most underrated album : One Of The Boys
Most overrated album : Teenage Dream