[Beautiful Sinner]

Originally posted by Vin

Nah, she's having a lot of trouble trying
to last as long Britney Spears, let alone Madonna...



...Vin

!

[Benzene]

Originally posted by toyboy

it's not about the chart position itself, but when i say LADY GAGA to someone - they say poker face, bad romance, paparazzi, etc.

but i never heard THE EDGE OF GLORY or JUDAS or MARRY THE NIGHT

I guarantee you that history will remember The Edge of Glory as one of her signature songs. I GUARANTEE it.

As for the question, I don't know. It's not easy to last that long, so it's hard for me to say yes. But she's cultivated a very dedicated fanbase in an exceptionally short period of time, so who knows?

[Haunted.]

idk. Probably not.

[Devon]

Usually when people say Gaga, they say Poker Face, Just Dance, or very rarely Bad Romance.

The general public was here for The Fame. Although her fanbase is huge now, she has an even larger amount of casual fans during 2009. Sadly, she's alienated them, and all she has is her die hard fans.

[EyesOpen]

Impossible

[toyboy]

Originally posted by Rivington Reject

I see your point, but I think the general public will at least remember The Edge of Glory. It got a lot of airplay during the summer of 2011. Definitely not Judas or MTN, but TEOG. Actually, Yoü and I did good in the US.

teog is my favorite from the album!

[toyboy]

Originally posted by LadyGagaStan93

The edge of glory is pretty big over here and same with You and I they're both used widely on singing competitions as well. Just because your neck of the woods (your friends or people you seem to talk to) don't name the current or last single doesn't mean she's much. I do agree that this era her impact song wise was weaker than past eras but culturally she's still leading and far ahead than most like to think on here.

excuse me?
you also have to see it outside of your "ladygagastan" world! it's not just about what her fans think about her, it's about what the world and industry thinks about her!

[Aden]

Originally posted by Devon

Usually when people say Gaga, they say Poker Face, Just Dance, or very rarely Bad Romance.

The general public was here for The Fame. Although her fanbase is huge now, she has an even larger amount of casual fans during 2009. Sadly, she's alienated them, and all she has is her die hard fans.

Yes but A LOT of die hard fans.

I have faith in Gaga. She's smart and if she wants a long career, she'll find a way to bring back the public's interest in her next album.

[Sye]

Originally posted by Beautiful Sinner

!

Do you do anything else besides quote what other people have said? Get your own opinion; it makes discussions a little more interesting.

[Devon]

^ I hope so!

[zach]

Hard to say.

She surely hasn't showed enough versatility as Madonna had in her early years. If she plays her cards right, she could.

Didn't Gaga say that she will eventually stop and raise a family?

[ClashAndBurn]

Originally posted by toyboy

it's not about the chart position itself, but when i say LADY GAGA to someone - they say poker face, bad romance, paparazzi, etc.

but i never heard THE EDGE OF GLORY or JUDAS or MARRY THE NIGHT

Like somebody else said, the record was for the fans. People on here like to take the album of the decade promise out of context, but it was only intended for the fans to enjoy, and she even knew that generally, the public would not be here for it.

Which, I will say, is not really a smart choice for ensuring career longevity, given that ALL of her contemporaries are putting out music that is intended for the public, and it shows, because records like California Gurls and We Found Love were devoured like cotton candy. And a lot of people jumped off the bandwagon because they felt uncomfortable sticking with someone who was focusing on one side her fan base, the gay men, while completely blowing all the rest of them off (seemingly, because that may not really be the case, it's just how everyone is perceiving her behavior).

[LadyGagaStan93]

Originally posted by toyboy

excuse me?
you also have to see it outside of your "ladygagastan" world! it's not just about what her fans think about her, it's about what the world and industry thinks about her!

And now you know the world

[Praise Mariallah]

So, this is the thread that has SYG acting up

[toyboy]

Originally posted by LadyGagaStan93

And now you know the world

no but many people told me that!
and it's not like people love gaga like they did before born this way!

[LadyGagaStan93]

Originally posted by toyboy

no but many people told me that!
and it's not like people love gaga like they did before born this way!

C'mon now. I didn't mean to insult the people that you talked to. What i'm trying to say is that it's an exaggeration to say that those you've talked to are a sure statement of her overall success. The same could be said for me though too. I didn't mean any harm by what I was saying

[toyboy]

Originally posted by LadyGagaStan93

C'mon now. I didn't mean to insult the people that you talked to. What i'm trying to say is that it's an exaggeration to say that those you've talked to are a sure statement of her overall success. The same could be said for me though too. I didn't mean any harm by what I was saying

it's ok
they are not people who just think about success, they think about music they like and artists they love, which isn't the thing with gaga right now. and the music industry isn't that here for her anymore

[chilicheese01]

Originally posted by Mons†erMuscle™

Too true! The numbers don't lie!

It's hard to tell from this point. Gaga still has a long way to go and I don't think anybody can really know right now.

Although Gaga already has one Album of the Decade under her belt.

[LP54]

I doubt it.

It has nothing to do with her but the people today. It seems like everyones attention spans have gotten shorter. They get bored of artist really quick now and there is little to no loyalty. Older people seem to be more loyal and hold on to artist which makes most of Madonnas fans. Younger crowds tend to look for the next cool thing. Eventually they will be bored of her strangeness and look elsewhere. She will though have those core fans so we will see.

[Lil Misty]

Uhhhhh idk...I voted for no