I don't know whether y'all are listening to a different song but to me Soap is on par with Carousel as the best Melanie song ever - I am absolutely in love with it. The chorus, the breakdown... It's all completely perfect.
Melanie song rates
1. Carousel = Soap
2. Bittersweet Tragedy = Dollhouse
3. Pity Party = Dead to Me
Melanie Martinez "Cry Baby" [Official Album Tracklist]
1 Cry Baby
2 Dollhouse
3 Sippy Cup
4 Carousel
5 Alphabet Boy
6 Soap
7 Training Wheels
8 Pity Party
9 Tag, You're It
10 Milk And Cookies
11 Pacify Her
12 Mrs. Potato Head
13 Mad Hatter