[tcatron565]

Originally posted by Alexz

But she didn't DEPEND ON Disney like Hilary does/did.

Hilary doesn't depend on Disney. She doing fine without Disney. She hasn't had a single video played on Disney Channel since "Beat of My Heart", and Lizzie McGuire no longer airs on Disney Channel. Yet, Dignity managed to sell enough to get her another top 3 album.

[1-N-Only21]

Originally posted by tcatron565

Hilary doesn't depend on Disney. She doing fine without Disney. She hasn't had a single video played on Disney Channel since "Beat of My Heart", and Lizzie McGuire no longer airs on Disney Channel. Yet, Dignity managed to sell enough to get her another top 3 album.

"Metamorphosis" is her biggest album to date. It was released during the PEAK of "Lizze McGuire".

The show ended..."Dignity" came...

[tcatron565]

Let's get this straight...

Do you Hilary's music on the radio and television? YES
Is she able to sell over 100k per week for an album/single? YES

She is not a flop.

Let's get back on topic. Do you think the version with The Prophet will be better than the live version we've already heard?

[Alexz]

Dignity was a colosal flop.

[1-N-Only21]

Originally posted by tcatron565

Let's get this straight...

Do you Hilary's music on the radio and television? 1/2 Correct.
Is she able to sell over 100k per week for an album/single? NO

Not even 50% on the QUIZ. You have flunked sir. You will need to try again.

[tcatron565]

Originally posted by 1-N-Only21

"Metamorphosis" is her biggest album to date. It was released during the PEAK of "Lizze McGuire".

The show ended..."Dignity" came...

"Dignity" has her highest career peaking song on it.

[Right Now]

Originally posted by Alexz

Dignity was a colosal flop.

Just as Alexz Johnson's new album will be. Although, I do love her.

[1-N-Only21]

tcatron.. TAKE THIS ONE... I'm sure you will pass.

Is Hilary a FLOP?
Are you retarded?

[tcatron565]

Originally posted by 1-N-Only21

Not even 50% on the QUIZ. You have flunked sir. You will need to try again.

She IS played on the radio and she has sold over 100k for an album FOUR TIMES!

[1-N-Only21]

Originally posted by tcatron565

She IS played on the radio and she has sold over 100k for an album FOUR TIMES!

Key Word: HAS.

She doesn't do it now.

[Afterglow]

Originally posted by 1-N-Only21

Key Word: HAS.

She doesn't do it now.

What do you mean?? She sold 140k+ with Dignity first week.

[tcatron565]

Originally posted by 1-N-Only21

tcatron.. TAKE THIS ONE... I'm sure you will pass.

Is Hilary a FLOP?
Are you retarded?

That's it!

http://www.atrl.net/forums/showthrea...=1#post2099425

This 13 year old does not hold back.

[Right Now]

Originally posted by 1-N-Only21

Key Word: HAS.

She doesn't do it now.

Her last album "Dignity" came out in April & debuted with over 140k in it's first week.

She hasn't released an album since then.

[Alexz]

LMAO so now barely selling 100k of an album 1 week and then plummeting out of the Top 10 is a hit? Gotta love this freaks.

[Adrian]

Duff is a sad ***** and a flop. End of story.

[tcatron565]

Because she's hasn't worked on any new material yet. She's been real busy.

[tcatron565]

Someone please lock this thread. It's pointless now. It's worse than the Raven threads.

[Afterglow]

Originally posted by Alexz

LMAO so now barely selling 100k of an album 1 week and then plummeting out of the Top 10 is a hit? Gotta love this freaks.

Barely? over 40,000 above 100K is not BARELY. Poor you.

[Right Now]

Originally posted by Afterglow

Barely? over 40,000 above 100K is not BARELY. Poor you.

I know right? It's sad to see unfortunate people not even knowing how to count. =/

[Afterglow]

Originally posted by Right Now

I know right? It's sad to see unfortunate people not even knowing how to count. =/

Only at ARTL It's pointless to even argue with them! They can't handle the fact that Hilary can still sell without Disney.