Mariano ALWAYS brings up those Gaga IFPI receipts in every thread as if singles stop selling after them sorry if there are great catalog sellers like Katy and Rihanna!
You are proving my point.
The singles don't stop selling AFTER they have peaked and Lady Gaga's singles have sold THE MOST during their CHART RUNS.
Telephone sold less in every single country than Scream & Shout, sans Japan, and S&S is only at 8.5M. Its total in Japan doesn't even push it up to 8.5M
We did the breakdowns in the Telephone vs. S&S thread where the Monsters, namely Mariano, were peddling this notion that Telephone sold 10M WW. You have a search feature if you'd like to find it (I'm on mobile).
WHO is buying these extra millions of copies after they fell from the charts though, your just speculating but its a fact that she isn't a good, hell she isn't even an average catalogue seller once her songs died in the chart
Applause
Do What U Want
Bad Romance
Poker Face
Born This Way
Just Dance
once you hide small countries that sell 2 or 3 copies a year she has ZERO songs charting in any relevant place EVEN with her new songs if Applause has dropped out of the itunes chart, sure as hell a song from 2008 did YEARS ago
WHERE Gaga's songs are charting NOW is irrelevant, because those songs topped 10M long time ago
Ew at the same losers always coming into every single Katy related thread and making it about their washed up fave when it has nothing to do with her at all.
Telephone sold less in every single country than Scream & Shout, sans Japan, and S&S is only at 8.5M. Its total in Japan doesn't even push it up to 8.5M
We did the breakdowns in the Telephone vs. S&S thread where the Monsters, namely Mariano, were peddling this notion that Telephone sold 10M WW. You have a search feature if you'd like to find it (I'm on mobile).
I am not arguing about Telephone as it's the only one that seems far fetched, BUT
PF, JD and BR sold nearly 10M in 12 MONTHS To question that, it's just STUPID.
BTW sold 8.2M in 10 months WW and AFTER THAT it sold 1M in USA and JAPAN alone.
Stay
#123 Netherlands
#161 New Zealand
#173 Switzerland
#182 Ireland
#197 Australia
Diamonds
#99 Turkey
#113 Ireland
#152 France
#153 Philippines
#162 Russia
#162 Switzerland
#177 Brazil
#184 Spain
Where Have You Been
#144 Turkey
Man Down
#114 Turkey
THIS is catalogue selling these songs + others will hang around these positions for YEARS and YEARS and pop into the top 200 of other countries all the time
(this is hiding small countries, with small countries added almost every one of her singles is charting some where)
Ew at the same losers always coming into every single Katy related thread and making it about their washed up fave when it has nothing to do with her at all.
There are no reliable ww receipts except estimations, mine are quite humble considering their ww longevity, peaks, sales in the USA, Canada, USA, Australia etc. I have no reason to lie. I always claim Katy sells more in the USA than outside of it, which is natural and true to all the others except Rihanna.
If this was official, I'd certainly congratulate Katy, but you're making an entire thread and a big to-do about this based on your personal estimations?
Telephone sold less in every single country than Scream & Shout, sans Japan, and S&S is only at 8.5M. Its total in Japan doesn't even push it up to 8.5M
We did the breakdowns in the Telephone vs. S&S thread where the Monsters, namely Mariano, were peddling this notion that Telephone sold 10M WW. You have a search feature if you'd like to find it (I'm on mobile).
I was actually talking about receipts to back up OP's claim
I like how when the Kats can't provide receipts they just go to insulting us/Gaga. Mariano's receipts might not be all there, but at least he provided some
sorry if there are great catalog sellers like Katy and Rihanna!
