[jayyyxtee]

lol at Ryan crying

[Kworb]

Originally posted by NX127

@kworb How much has Indiallah sold in France and worldwide?

300k in France and 400k worldwide

[Duca]

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=631010

every time someone discusses Beyoncé's album or single sales the Hive talks about her fame

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by Duca

US

not bad, his album only has 2 good songs

[NX127]

Originally posted by Guero

Indila still looks like Drake with a wig on.

he wishes.

Indila is easily the most global-looking one out there

[B-Luke]

G I R L must've sold like 1.5m WW no? Less than ARTPOP and with a massive lead single.

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Legend X

[jayyyxtee]

Does ATRL consider BEYONCE a flop

[rihannafan]

Originally posted by Guero

Indila still looks like Drake with a wig on.

go away

[Duca]

Originally posted by B-Luke

G I R L must've sold like 1.5m WW no? Less than ARTPOP and with a massive lead single.

1.4 million after Happy and all that promo

his US sales are pitiful for an album with such a massive promo campaign

[GreasyBruce]

Originally posted by Duca

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=631010

every time someone discusses Beyoncé's album or single sales the Hive talks about her fame

They drag her unknowingly with those comments. All those people knowing who she is and choosing not to buy her album or singles.

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by jayyyxtee

Does ATRL consider BEYONCE a flop

The album didn't flop, anyone who says that is clearly lying

[rihannafan]

Originally posted by jayyyxtee

Does ATRL consider BEYONCE a flop

Yes, it is well established that it is a flop. I kept telling her stans that it was a flop from the beginning but no one believed me. All the singles flopped WW and most of them in the US. The album didn't sell much after its first few weeks and promo doesn't seem to do anything for it. My US/WW sales ratios are never wrong.

[Duca]

At No. 2 on the latest Billboard 200 is Pharrell's "G I R L," which rebounds back to its peak, rising seven slots with 29,000 (+18%). During the tracking week, Pharrell performed on ABC's "Good Morning America" (April 7) and was profiled on CBS' "Sunday Morning" (April 13). "G I R L" also benefits from Pharrell's performance on NBC's "Saturday Night Live." "G I R L" debuted at No. 2 on the chart dated March 22. However, the album also logs the smallest weekly sum for the No. 2-selling album on the Billboard 200 in the SoundScan era.

his promo around the album release was just

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by GreasyBruce

They drag her unknowingly with those comments. All those people knowing who she is and choosing not to buy her album or singles.

They buy tickets to her tour tho

[NX127]

Originally posted by jayyyxtee

Does ATRL consider BEYONCE a flop

well, less successful than 4 at least

may have sold 3-400k more, but "4" had better international sales, sold much more singles, had much better consistency

[Badger]

Urgh

[rihannafan]

If you have to sell your tour dates as charity events to sell out stadiums, then you're probably not a touring act, you're just desperate.

[Kworb]

Originally posted by jayyyxtee

Does ATRL consider BEYONCE a flop

Musically it's considered a flop, none of the music did anything, none of the music convinced people to spend their money.

But as a product it did well, she used her name and the power of social media to sell a lot of copies of something that has no real value. So in that sense it wasn't a flop.

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by Lipton

All will come to the light, even MrPeanut.

I actually low key use perfume now