[Stepfon]

Originally posted by Lasers

so whats the deal with Hilary? I know she had a kid and all, but I miss hearing her on the radio or seeing her on tv what's next for her?

After she gets settled into motherhood, she will finish recording the album she started prior to having her son.

[Right Now]

I Can't Wait: #86
Why Not: #44
So Yesterday: #12
Come Clean: #5
Little Voice: Wouldn't Have Charted
Fly: #33
Someone's Watching Over Me: Wouldn't Have Charted
Wake Up: #16
Beat of My Heart: Wouldn't Have Charted
With Love: #10
Stanger: #18
Reach Out: #36

Honestly the Play-N-Skillz remix should have been pushed properly. It was hot and would have smashed Rhythmic & Pop.

Stranger had tons of potential and I still can't at Reach Out not being available as a single till months after the video & Best Of were released.

[Strangergab]

I Can't Wait: Wouldn't Have Charted
Why Not: #42
So Yesterday: #10
Come Clean: #1, Her Best song Im still mad
Little Voice: Wouldn't Have Charted
Fly: #20
Someone's Watching Over Me: #11
Wake Up: #15
Beat of My Heart: #80
With Love: #13
Stanger: #2
Reach Out: #57

[Right Now]

Are we supposed to act as if SWOM was released in the US? If that's the case, my answer for SWOM changes entirely.

[Strangergab]

Originally posted by Right Now

Are we supposed to act as if SWOM was released in the US? If that's the case, my answer for SWOM changes entirely.

Obviously would have to be so, because if FLY would have had that success SWOM would have to have been a official single

[Mr. Duff]

I Can't Wait: #90
Why Not: #40
So Yesterday: #8
Come Clean: #1 - YES!
Little Voice: Wouldn't Have Charted
Fly: #5
Someone's Watching Over Me: #10
Wake Up: #3
Beat of My Heart: #70
With Love: #1
Stanger: #5
Reach Out: #20

[Right Now]

New Revised Chart Positions
(Assuming the AUS-Only singles got a US release too)

I Can't Wait: #86
Why Not: #44
So Yesterday: #12
Come Clean: #5
Little Voice: #38
Fly: #22
Someone's Watching Over Me: #4
Wake Up: #12
Beat of My Heart: #99
With Love: #10
Stanger: #15
Reach Out: #34

I think the release of Little Voice & SWOM would have improved her chart positions in the long run.

[Miguel.]

Originally posted by Katie

I haven't listened to the Christmas album in forever

Call me a flop stan, but I sometimes forget it exists

Lol, you're not the only one.

[Miguel.]

I'm back y'all. Sorry that I have been gone for 2 days. I just needed a break.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by iggie45

I'm back y'all. Sorry that I have been gone for 2 days. I just needed a break.

Glad you are back. ATRL is such a mess right now.

[Right Now]

I've been listening to 'Dignity' (the song) a lot lately. My god it would have made an amazing single.

[ashuduff]

Come Clean wouldn't have made it to #1, please. #8 probably.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by ashuduff

Come Clean wouldn't have made it to #1, please. #8 probably.

It would have been Top 10 though.

[ashuduff]

Originally posted by Stepfon

It would have been Top 10 though.

Yes, and a well-deserved top ten. With Love should have gone top ten as well, and So Yesterday should have been #15ish. Wake Up should have gone to #20.

Those were her only real top twenty worthy hits!

[Stepfon]

What about her albums you all? (Sales, certifications, chart peaks.)
Santa Claus Lane: Gold (For a Christmas album that only had a few promo singles on the Disney Channel, this album is fine in sales. The album peaked at #154, which is fine by me, considering all the factors.)
Metamorphosis: 4x Platinum (It should actually be 4XP already because last time sales were reported by Billboard, in 2007, the album was right at 3.9M, it's #1 peak was PERFECT.)
Hilary Duff: 2x Platinum (Sales around 1.9M in 2007, as reported by Billboard, I would have had Hilary do more promo doing the first week, I was NOT happy about it's #2 peak on the charts.)
Most Wanted: 2x Platinum (Break My Heart should have been released, the album was at 1.4M in 2007, think about what BMH would have done for the album's sales, it's #1 chart position for two weeks was amazing.)
Dignity: Platinum (So many obvious singles choices, I WON'T go there today. I would have been happy with a #2 peak here.)

[Right Now]

Stranger was most definitely top 20 worthy. It just didn't fit with mainstream music at the time AT ALL. lol

[Right Now]

Originally posted by Stepfon

What about her albums you all? (Sales, certifications, chart peaks.)
Santa Claus Lane: Gold (For a Christmas album that only had a few promo singles on the Disney Channel, this album is fine in sales. The album peaked at #154, which is fine by me, considering all the factors.)
Metamorphosis: 4x Platinum (It should actually be 4XP already because last time sales were reported by Billboard, in 2007, the album was right at 3.9M, it's #1 peak was PERFECT.)
Hilary Duff: 2x Platinum (Sales around 1.9M in 2007, as reported by Billboard, I would have had Hilary do more promo doing the first week, I was NOT happy about it's #2 peak on the charts.)
Most Wanted: 2x Platinum (Break My Heart should have been released, the album was at 1.4M in 2007, think about what BMH would have done for the album's sales, it's #1 chart position for two weeks was amazing.)
Dignity: Platinum (So many obvious singles choices, I WON'T go there today. I would have been happy with a #2 peak here.)

The great thing about SCL is that it got a HUGE boost thanks to Metamorphosis and Hilary Duff for the following few years. It even reached #1 on the Comprehensive chart in December 2003 (it wasn't eligible for the Billboard 200) meaning it would have been at least top 50 on the Billboard 200 at the time.

I was pressed about her self-titled album's missing #1. The problem with promo was that she was in the middle of a tour when the album was released and promoting RYV. There was way too much going on at the time.

I was so proud of Metamorphosis and Most Wanted reaching #1, especially Most Wanted. It was a ****IN' GREATEST HITS ALBUM. Smashed like it deserved too.

I'm glad that Billboard reran its charts and Hilary got that #3 with 'Dignity.' None of her studio albums have peaked under that and let's hope she keeps it that way.

[Miguel.]

Originally posted by Stepfon

Glad you are back. ATRL is such a mess right now.

Thanks I've heard. Especially with this merge happening.

[Stepfon]

We got through a page that quick. We need to have these discussions more often.

[Right Now]

What happened to iHeartHilary and misguidedghost though.

I can't when newbies come and go like that.