I feel conflicted about it. The actual G.U.Y. segment was pretty good, with some very nice visuals, reminiscent of the old Gaga. But overall, I feel like it didn't reach its full potential. The ARTPOP and Venus scenes felt unnecessary and incoherent in its transitions and I actually thought Gaga could have done more with the amazing location she chose to shoot in. And I'm tired of saying this, but she seriously needs to hire a professional director, some shots just weren't that great.
It feels like I'm criticizing too much, but that's because I know Gaga is capable of much more.