Member Since: 12/24/2010
Posts: 37,039
|
Team Cheryl
Taylor Swift
Cheryl:
The fiercest of them all 
Nicole:
Fierce…not really. I like it but it’s more teenagey girl sort of thing.
Miley:
best choice possible. Enough said 
Madonna:
I like it and It's really her fiercest album cover. 
Lea:
Oh, honey... Speak Now was an obvious choice, or even Red... Fearless is cute and the cover slays, but it's not fierce in the slightest. A shame
Sky:
She looks like a lion. A soft feminine mystique lion.
Team Miley
Beyonce
Cheryl:
I love it, she doesn't has an ugly belly.
Nicole:
It’s fierce-ish. I can definitely see where it’s going but it does ultimately feel barren. Colour scheme nice but nothing really packs a punch. Tobe honest, just ordinary really.
Miley:
Not a bad cover, but I Am...Sasha Fierce was a much better choice. Even though Beyoncé looks fierce in this cover, she also looks like an escort that decided to enlist in the military while getting eyeliner advice from Avril Lavigne.
Madonna:
Dangerously in Love... 
Lea:
Not sure about this one. I guess it's a decent choice. I think she some better choices, though..
Sky:
I like the other 4 cover more, but this in many ways is a stronger cover. The other is more ooh baby sexy and this is more of a statement. The face just seems unresolved to me. Just rambling, I think I would have given her self titled a 10. It would have been a huge mistake to submit it here, but it's really a 10.
Christina Aguilera
Cheryl:
Oh My Gawd.
Nicole:
Yeah…it’s not HORRIBLE, and not the worst in the round…but those lips and just overall messiness of the cover.
Miley:
Our plan was to send in something different, but honestly, it just wasn't executed right. It looked like a good idea at the time, but it just seemed to fall flat once all the other entries were posted. I just don't see us outplacing Brit, Katy, GaGa or even Bey this round 
Madonna:
Stripped >>> 
Lea:
I know Xtina isn't one to really be fierce on her album covers, but I don't understand this choice out of all of them. I guess there's a little bit of fierceness hidden in there, but the little robotic concept doesn't show that.
Sky:
I like Bionic. If the album was better and a commercial success this would be a strong iconic image.
Team Nicole
Britney Spears
Cheryl:
Her Greatest Hits would have slayed me, why Britney?
Nicole:
We know it was going to be a hard round. Good luck Britney!
Miley:
I think you could have sent in In The Zone. Britney looked fierce and hot on that cover. As for this one, it's also a good pick. Her image here is like a physical description of "I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman" since she has the innocent face going on but her top is exposed and we can almost see her boobs. I hate the yellow coloring though so you lost points for that. But otherwise it's a good choice.
Madonna:
Mmm. It isn't a bad entry but I'm not impressed. GH: My Prerogative and Blackout >>> 
Lea:
It's cute, raw and innocent. Not exactly fierce. She has a few better options in there
Sky:
Britney and a nice cover.  Perfect for it's time and as a representation of it.
Shakira
Cheryl:
The picture is fantastic but the font, girl.
Nicole:
I don’t understand why people are voting this off. There are much worse covers first of all. But, she does fierce ok in this album cover. Hair and pose is on point and the tattoo is good. Not perfection at all but one of the better ones in the rounds in my honest opinion. I hope this isn’t a bandwagon
Miley:
Not a bad cover, but you should have chosen the Oral Fixation one. Shakira being naked covered by a tree gives me Eve tease so that would have been iconic to send in. The cover you sent in is as ok, but it's about as average as the majority of Britney Spears single covers.
Madonna:
Live from paris and Loba >>>>>  but this is definitely fierce. 
Lea:
I guess this fits. Not as much as some of the others in this round, but it's sexy, sultry and gives a good amount of life.
Sky:
She looks like a lion. A timid lion with bad font choices but a nice heart.
Team Madonna
Lady Gaga
Cheryl:
ddddddd a Mess.
Nicole:
Slightly biased but love it. This is how minimalism is done correctly….especially with the black and white , the font and overall cohesion and cleanliness.
Miley:
Easily her best cover. She looks like **** on BTW and Artpop so between The Fame and The Fame Monster, I think you chose a good cover.
Madonna:
Thanks for not sending the awful BTW album cover.
Lea:
Hit the nail right on the head. Not even being biased, but this WAS the perfect choice.
Sky:
http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=77074 hihi
Team Lea
Girls Aloud
Cheryl:
Girls Aloud aren't famous for their covers, their single and album covers are the pits.
Nicole:
Love their outfits but they’re so damn small the actual girls and it feels like quite a minimalistic cover. The score is mainly from their dresses and because most of them (aka not Sarah) are posing fiercely.
Miley:
I don't get it. I don't feel any life coming from this cover. The colors are kind of distracting and they look like statues instead of women here. This cover just feels very forced, dead, two-faced, robotic, emotionless, void, ghastly and absent-minded.
Madonna:
They all look amazing. 
Lea:
Yasss! I'm not even a fan of the group but this cover definitely strikes my senses. They're all nice, proper and posed and the colors are very beautiful. Even the text is all nice and sleek. It just works all the way through.
Sky:
Ten out of what? 50? They feel so little. Like they only take up 10% of the image.
Team Sky
Katy Perry
Cheryl:
Slay us Katheryn
Nicole:
I’ve always never liked this cover. Just the candy floss clouds I liked, otherwise I find it very oddly created. Fierce it isn’t and aesthetically it just isn’t my cup of tea.
Miley:
Flawless choice. you really couldn't have chosen anything better so great pick 
Madonna:
Iconic 
Lea:
Well, Katy only has four album covers and doesn't really show a fierceness quality in them, so you were limited a little bit. I think you picked the best out of what you could work with. 7/10
Sky:
It's a great album cover. I rarely give Katy credit but this is really good.
Kylie Minogue
Cheryl:
Everything is fantastic.
Nicole:
Well hello there! Surprise surprise. This actually looks really good. The pose and artwork behind it is pretty well executed. Her leg looks a little weird hence the deduction but honestly, very good entry.
Miley:
SLAY bitch Kylie betta werq that body!
Madonna:
Fever this slays tho. 
Lea:
Sure.
Sky:
If a major pop girl released this would by iconic. 
|
|
|
|
Who's responsible for this 
ff I started on my scores a few days ago but then stopped in the middle for some reason. Sending in a few!
