[B-Luke]

Originally posted by Dämon

As a featured artist? Congrats

Just proving that Rihanna is flopping w/ her solo material.
The new Legend X, but without the talent and the acclaim.

Grammys: Rihanna - 8
Legend X - 5

Metacritic score average: Rihanna - 69
Legend X - 58

Even if she was destined to dwindle into the infamous rent-an-artist territory (which she isn't) she will have that over her.

[Artemisia]

Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

this is very fomo'd

[2014]

Does Rihanna have a more generic song than This Is What You Came For?

Even Right Now is less generic

[collin]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

this is very fomo'd

Those are both solid 9s.

[B-Luke]

Pray You Catch Me - 8/10
Hold Up - 7/10
Don't Hurt Yourself - 5/10
Sorry - 0/10
6 Inch - 8/10
Daddy Lessons - 5/10
Love Drought - 9/10
Sandcastles - 2/10
Forward: 10/10
Freedom - 4/10
All Night - 7/10
Formation - 8/10

Overall: 6.1/10

[collin]

Originally posted by 2014

Does Rihanna have a more generic song than This Is What You Came For?

Even Right Now is less generic

It's a Calvin Harris song.

And no... Right Now is not less generic.

[rihannafan]

Originally posted by Lucas32

Final Lemonade ratings:


Forward: 10/10
Daddy lessons: 9.5/10
Don't hurt yoursefl: 9.5/10
6 inch: 8/10
Freedom: 7/10
Pray you catch me: 7/10
All night: 4/10
Love drought: 3/10
Hold up: 3/10
Sandcastles: 2.5/10
Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

Overall: 5.5/10 (I'd round it up to a 6 with the movie)

We gave it the same score

[Artemisia]

Pray You Catch Me - 9/10
Hold Up - 9/10
Don't Hurt Yourself - 7/10
Sorry - 9/10
6 Inch - 9/10
Daddy Lessons - 7/10
Love Drought - 8.5/10
Sandcastles - 5/10
Forward: doesn't feel right to rate this, it's far too short
Freedom - 8/10
All Night - 8.5/10
Formation - 9.5/10

[2014]

Originally posted by collin

It's a Calvin Harris song.

And no... Right Now is not less generic.

Funny how it was Rihanna's song when it hit #1 on iTunes (for 1 hour)

[TeemoR]

Originally posted by Lucas32

Final Lemonade ratings:


Forward: 10/10
Daddy lessons: 9.5/10
Don't hurt yoursefl: 9.5/10
6 inch: 8/10
Freedom: 7/10
Pray you catch me: 7/10
All night: 4/10
Love drought: 3/10
Hold up: 3/10
Sandcastles: 2.5/10
Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

Overall: 5.5/10 (I'd round it up to a 6 with the movie)

These are wrong they are all 10, listen to the album again.

[rihannafan]

Woo my review of the album is so iconic But not as iconic as the HM review.

[Brunette Ambition]

Forward: 1/10
Daddy lessons: 2/10
Don't hurt yoursefl: 8/10
6 inch: 10/10
Freedom: 3/10
Pray you catch me: 9/10
All night: 10/10
Love drought: 10/10
Hold up: 10/10
Sandcastles: 2/10
Sorry: 10/10
Formation: 10/10

7.1/10

mhhh

[manwhore]

Originally posted by Pop pop123

Beast sounds very much like Knee omg. I've never really seen her interviews.

Kinda air headed...not sure what's going on.

Knee is this sweet dumb southern girl. Is beast from the same area?

Houston is close to Louisiana so roughly from that swamp area so yeah...blame it on the humidity.

[Lucas32]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

this is very fomo'd

Sorry is all around tragic and only got a 1 for some alright lyrics(Tonight I regret the night I put the ring on).
The melody is awful.Same with Formation.
Some good lyrics(the one about the afro hair of Blue Ivy) but the melody after the opening is so bad.
Also if anything is fomo'd it's the "I slay " line.

Originally posted by rihannafan

We gave it the same score

Objective truths

[Kh-Loud]

I can't wait to buy the physical copy of the most critically acclaimed album of the decade next week

[2014]

Pray You Catch me is so overated . It's a 6/10. Every other song is at least a 8.

[NX127]

Has Formation been having red updates consecutively for .. 2 days now?

[Sinvius]

Originally posted by Lucas32

Final Lemonade ratings:


Forward: 10/10
Daddy lessons: 9.5/10
Don't hurt yoursefl: 9.5/10
6 inch: 8/10
Freedom: 7/10
Pray you catch me: 7/10
All night: 4/10
Love drought: 3/10
Hold up: 3/10
Sandcastles: 2.5/10
Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

Overall: 5.5/10 (I'd round it up to a 6 with the movie)

Everything you say from this point is not valid.

[TheVoiceXtina]

Originally posted by Lucas32

Final Lemonade ratings:


Forward: 10/10
Daddy lessons: 9.5/10
Don't hurt yoursefl: 9.5/10
6 inch: 8/10
Freedom: 7/10
Pray you catch me: 7/10
All night: 4/10
Love drought: 3/10
Hold up: 3/10
Sandcastles: 2.5/10
Sorry: 1/10
Formation: 1/10

Overall: 5.5/10 (I'd round it up to a 6 with the movie)

best song doesnt feat Beyonce

[B-Luke]

Glad I'm not the only one that hates Sorry. God what a dreadful song.