[Baha]

lmao the expose

[The Best One Yet]

I always thought this was going to flop

And i think it won't be Top 10, i hope i'm wrong

[Rei]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

? I was the ONLY one who was positive about this single from the start

You all have short memories!

I'm not here often but I was never negative about Birthday.

So suddenly everyone was always positive and never doubted this would go at least top 15

[Ferst]

Originally posted by Kayzan

Originally posted by Kayzan

wait

Publish Ha.

[ethan]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

this important single is flopping

Originally posted by johnsuxx

This is flopping already? It's time for #TeamThisIsHowWeDo to shine.

Originally posted by johnsuxx

Is this still flopping?

Originally posted by johnsuxx

Birthday on the charts

Originally posted by johnsuxx

So cover ur eyes
I have a surprise
It's the bottom half of the hot 100

Originally posted by johnsuxx

Maybe this will teach Katy to stop snorting lines and start working again

Originally posted by johnsuxx

[Birthday is an important single] because it ended her career

I think most of us have had doubting thoughts bb

[Samuel]

Originally posted by ethan

I think most of us have had doubting thoughts bb

John Sux being brutally EXPOSED like this Poor it!

[Reaper]

Originally posted by ethan

I think most of us have had doubting thoughts bb

Mess

[Kayzan]

OMG I read almost everything. We were celebrating when Birthday finally entered the top 50.

It was so hard.

But now...

[Baha]

Originally posted by Kayzan

OMG I read everything. We were celebrating when Birthday finally entered the top 50.

It was so hard.

But now...

Top 50? People were celebrating here when it reached top 500. lmao.

[Emcee]

Based on weak callout scores, I am hoping that they make a big push this coming week to maximize the chart position.

She could get a second wind but I'm thinking the next Billboard issue (released a week from Wednesday) will be her peak.

Cash Cash remix release could be the wild card.

[MoodyBumps]

Originally posted by Samuel

John Sux being brutally EXPOSED like this Poor it!

I think it was just her overdone sarcasm that it made appear she doubted it

[h.u.r.r.i.c.a.n.e]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

take a xanax pumpkin i never doubted this single!

i remember you crying to me over skype about how katy was over at 4am and i had to calm you down!

wait

[johnsuxx]

Originally posted by ethan

I think most of us have had doubting thoughts bb

? why are you photoshopping all of these posts

[OriginalQueen]

I knew from the start that Birthday would be a hit.

[Ferst]

Originally posted by OriginalQueen

I knew from the start that Birthday would be a hit.

Originally posted by OriginalQueen

Welp this song will most likely be another "flop"
Sigh Katy's HITs streak is slowly ending.
It's her fault for making such a bad video (well that is my opinion at least)
I expected something sexy - that would actually fit the lyrics.
I do hope the song takes off though - cause it's one of my faves of PRISM, but it doesn't look all too good ATM.

Oh well at least there's still Legendary Lovers left!

Sure you did.

[Emcee]

Originally posted by Ferst

Sure you did.

Expose her!

[Reaper]

Originally posted by Ferst

Sure you did.

These people I've always believed in Birthday

[ethan]

Everyone getting exposed

I actually did always know that Birthday was going to smash!

[Baha]

I think the only one who truly never doubted this song is the user with "gouldie" in his avatar. Don't remember his name. He has always been positive

[Emcee]

I just left the thread because of all the negativity. But I never doubted it.