| |
Tournament: Survivor: ATRL Edition! [Season 2]
Member Since: 11/27/2011
Posts: 12,312
|
So, results soon?
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
God Dylan get your life together!!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
It takes time 
I don't update like music world.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/25/2012
Posts: 4,449
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
It takes time
I don't update like music world. |
Your MW shade recently
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
oh **** at these rates.
were going to get hate.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/10/2011
Posts: 14,321
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DripDrip
God Dylan get your life together!!
|
It's not his fault, we judges are a little bit busy with final exams and other things, I sent my rates just a few minutes ago.
Oh, and btw, in this round I gave my lowest score to date.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/27/2011
Posts: 12,312
|
I'm nervous. Will Team #RhiPukaPuka get first place or be in bottom?
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/27/2011
Posts: 12,312
|
What schools do you guys go to? Y'all can't be that busy. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/25/2012
Posts: 4,449
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
oh **** at these rates.
were going to get hate.
|
If American Life gets a bad score...
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MWB
What schools do you guys go to? Y'all can't be that busy.
|
I sent to the judges at this time last night. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/22/2012
Posts: 10,005
|
oh god i hope four didnt give me a lowest score
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/27/2011
Posts: 12,312
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
I sent to the judges at this time last night. |
Oh, well take yo time little one
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/25/2012
Posts: 4,449
|
Why don't more people use this smiley 
So flawless
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
Super Smash Bros. gets intense like I got hit in the face intense
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Hello Castaways! It's the time to reveal your scores for the 10th Round of the game. The results and scoring will work exactly the same as previous rounds.
Let's get started...
Puka Puka
1. TheSeenScene - Britney Spears - Don't Keep Me Waiting
Quote:
Dillon - 3.5 - This is defninitely one of the weakest on Femme Fatale and probably her more recent discography. I just don't find anything wrong with the track. It's a filler track (actually a bonus track) so I really can't find anything that makes it a song that should have never been touched in the first place. Honestly, Scream and Shout would have been a good entry from Britney but it's brand new so  sorry scene.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 8.5. “I don’t think DKMW is a bad song itself, but its probably the worst on Femme Fatale so I have to agree with you Seen.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - TheSeenScene - 3 - I don't see anything wrong with this song, nor does it seem to be a universally hated track. if anything I think people are probably not even aware of its existence since it's only a bonus track. it's experimental for Britney because it's more rock-ish, but it actually worked.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 6 - I understand why would you think this is her worst song, is not your typical dance-pop Britney song, it has a more organic sound, and it definitely doesn't really fits on Femme Fatale, but for me it's not her worst, it's really refreshing hearing this side of her, I only have a few songs from Femme Fatale on my iPod and this is one of them. I think you should have submitted something from her first two cds, or maybe Big Fat Bass/Scream and Shout since I think Will.I.Am production's are a mess.
|
2. MWB - Jennifer Lopez - Good Hit
Quote:
|
Dillon - 8 - It's one of J.Lo's weaker songs especially off that album. The synths go way too hard on this song and even though I personally like it, I can acknowledge that it's not a musical masterpiece...at all. Pretty good MWB.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 6.5. “I’m one of the few non-JLO stans who enjoyed Love? to its maximum, so I know for sure Good Hit was not the worse song in the album. It’s actually an average song, but it’s hearable, if you get what I mean.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - MWB - 10 - good Lord, what is this. I don't know what made me cringe more, the lyrics, the synths or the autotune. it sounds like a robot is singing, not J.Lo. horrible song so good choice.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 8.5 - I was really surprised when you said you chose this as your entry because I like this song, but after hearing it again with a more critical ear I think it's safe to say it really is one of Jlo's worst, very basic compared to other songs by her, the auto tune makes her voice sound very robotic and weird, but even tho this song is a mess, it is still catchy.
|
3. AdamAL4 - will.i.am. feat. Mick Jagger & Wolfgang Partner - Go Home
Quote:
|
Dillon - 10 - You took the smartest route this round going with an artist who's not respected to begin with. This song is even worse than T.H.E. and that was bad. Mick Jagger being on this song adds more to the mess that it was to begin with. Will can never be on a song by himself because no one will be here for it (see Scream and Shout). Very good Adam.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 9. “Adam you actually played it smart by choosing an artist like will.i.am who the GP is usually not here for (except for S&S which is obviously Britney’s hype that got its success), and although the original T.H.E. is a good song, and this remix is hideous and Will truly showcases his horrible skills as a rapper, and the beat is horrible and Mick’s voice is a disaster even though he’s a rock legend. Flawless entry.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - AdamAL4 - 6 - yeah, it's not a good song, but I wouldn't say is a disaster. it's listenable and I bet a lot of people would dance to it in a club, including myself. I know will.i.am gets a lot of hate but that doesn't mean each of his productions/songs are automatically bad. I think he has worse material than this.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 10 - I just can't with Mick Jagger being in this song, Will.i.Am solo productions have been a disappointing compared to his work with the BEP, and this song is the proof. It seems like he's just throwing some random beats and adding cheap effects and high profile recording artists to the song just to get a hit song, very generic and boring.
|
Salani
1. iLukey - Ke$ha - Dinosaur
Quote:
|
Dillon - 8 - One of the weaker songs off Animal but Boots and Boys is definitely the weakest off the album. The lyrics to this song are so cringe worthy even though I've played this song to death as it relates to me but we won't get into that Decent entry. More than decent actually.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 9. “I must agree, one of Ke$has weakest songs from Animal, never really got into it.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - iLukey - 10 - this is such an annoying song. the spelling out in the chorus and just the lyrics in general are just, ughhh. cringe. musically, it doesn't have much to offer, either. total misstep.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 8 - I literally LOL'ed when I saw you submitted this as your entry, it IS definitely Kesha's worst song, but it's so funny even tho the lyrics are cringe worthy and it sounds like an 80s theme song from Cartoon Network.
|
2. Adr - Beyonce - Video Phone
Quote:
Dillon - 6.5 - It's boring. It's nothing horrible. Defintely not Beyonce's best. But overall, this was not exactly the direction we were going for this round...or at least I was going for. sorry Adr 
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 6. “I’m not really sure Video Phone is that bad to be considered the worst song in IASF. The remix with Gaga even brought this to single status and I actually enjoyed bopping to it.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - Adr - 9 - I was expecting a counterpart to Telephone but it comes nowhere close to that. the music is boring and repetitive, making the song sound bland. then there's the moans and the content of the lyrics which is not even sexy, it just feels smutty for me. Beyoncé's way too classy for such a song.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 10 - The fact that Beyoncé made a Remix of the song with Gaga speaks volume of how confident was the label with this being a single, they probably thought this was going to smash because of the collaboration with Gaga + the release of Telephone, but they thought wrong because even tho the song is catchy, it is Beyoncé's worst song to date, it's so flat, so lifeless, plus the instrumental it's all over the place.
|
3. Stevie - Lady GaGa - Americano
Quote:
|
Dillon - 9.5 - It's a bit of a grower. I still don't like it but it gets better on the 2nd listen for sure. I think Black Jesus + Amen Fashion would have been your best bet this round Stevie. Still, a nice entry from you. On track with what we were looking for.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 10. “Mariachi Mexican mess. I’m sure like 90% of the GP who bought BTW skips this mess. Excellent job Stevie.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - Stevie - 5 - I had a serious wtf moment when I put this on. as the song progressed, I thought it actually wasn't that bad, though. it sounds like a mess, but it's still catchy somehow and the latin elements paired with the synths end up being a cool combo. of course, her accent and the whole vibe are a little cheesy, yet I wouldn't call this her worst song.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 8 - While the majority of Monsters hate this song, I personally love it (probably because I'm mexican lol) and I found it so unique because Gaga wanted to mix Mariachi with dance-pop, and that's a very bold and challenging thing to do since they are totally opposite genres, but at the end of the day this song turned out to be a little bit messy, and it's definitely one of Gaga's worst.
|
4. iggie45 - Madonna - Spanish Lesson
Quote:
Dillon - 10 - Was Madonna for real with this?  There's really nothing I can say is good about this song which for once is EXACTLY what we wanted. The best entry from a popular artist this round. Great job, iggie.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 9.5. “I’m not an actual fan of this song as I do know Spanish, and the lyrics on it are a complete mess. The song just sounds utterly bad. Great job.“
|
Quote:
|
Anna - iggie45 - 9 - the lyrics are pretty.. basic, not to say dumb, the "if you do your homework" bridge being the worst, just no. that makes the song pretty unbearable. parts of the music are okay, that saves it from being a complete catastrophy but it's still a bad song.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 7.5 - Wow, I kinda surprised you guys don't like when they mix Latin sounds with pop, maybe I like it because I'm used to hear latin songs? Just like Gaga's "Americano", I find this very refreshing and not bad at all, the Spanish in this song is SO bad tho, I guess I will give you a decent score since it is not Madonna's best, but imo it is not her worst song.
|
5. Middle of Selena - Katy Perry - Peacock
Quote:
|
Dillon - 8.5 - Just like Dinosaur, I have played this song to death. I like it but it is by no means a "good" song. It was panned by critics and even though it went Gold....it's just an example of why Katy gets hate. Goood one Dhruv.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 10. “PEACOCK IS AN ATROCITY. Glad Katy was smart enough to not release this. Excellent MoS.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - Middle of Selena - 10 - second-hand embarrassment, so much of it. the music is not even that bad, sure it's nothing ground-breaking but it's alright. doesn't matter though because nothing could save a song with that kind of lyrics. the pits.
|
Quote:
Alexz - 7 - Thank you for dedicating this to me  , but I gotta be honest, I don't think this is Katy's worst song and I'm not being biased, this song is certified Gold on the US even tho is just an album track, and that's huge if you are not Adele or Taylor, awful songs doesn't sell that much, and while some probably think it was tacky she created an innuendo with the word "Peacock", I find it very clever, funny and bold because the song doesn't only talks about showing your "****" to someone, it's also about showing your true colors, your true self to someone, and it's also so catchy and infectious, it kinda is like a funny gay anthem.
|
Fei Long
1. DripDrip - Rihanna feat. Nicki Minaj - Raining Men
Quote:
Dillon - 7 - Same as Vdeo Phone for me. A Nicki and Rihanna collab should have been so much better than this I like it, but its just so disappointing because I remember being so excited about this and then hearing it  It doesn't fit on Loud either, however I don't see anything atrocious about it.
|
Quote:
Ray: 4. “Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo  No DD, not you coming for one of Loud’s main boppin tracks. I still bop to Raining Men on a constant basis. Hook is flawless, verses are on point, Mel & Mus’s production is good enough. I can’t at you sending this. You knowing Nicki’s discography, I knew you could’ve sent something better than this.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - DripDrip - 7 - I'd say it's not a plain bad song but it comes pretty close. it seems kinda random and definitely doesn't fit in with the rest of the album, that siren-like sound in the background gets annoying fast and so does the rest of the song. it's listenable, but a listenable mess.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 9 - The instrumental sounds like a bad Karaoke instrumental, and the lyrics are really bad (tho I like Nicki's rap), Rihanna has definitely better songs than this. I predict great scores are falling like the rain toward you so you you betta not worry, Drip Drip.
|
2. Jack. - Britney Spears - Mmm Papi
Quote:
|
Dillon - 9.5 - Love it to be honest. But it's a total mess. The lyrics Britney pretending she's Mexican Well done Jack! One of the best off this tribe.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 8 “Mmmm Jack. I actually am kinda in doubt of what to do with this cause I don’t know how I really feel. It’s just meh to me, so I guess that’s good enough for a semi good score. “
|
Quote:
|
Anna - Jack. - 10 - one of the songs I always skip on Circus, it makes me cringe too much. her weird vocals, the baby talk and the groaning are awful, not to mention the lyrics. why, Britney?
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 7.5 - I actually find this song very catchy, funny and not bad at all, just like with "Don't Keep me waiting" she tried to experiment with new genres and maybe because the fans are used to Britney's dance pop side this doesn't comes across as very genuine for them, but anyway, I'll still give you a decent score since this is by no means Briney's best song, only bad think about this song imo is the way she says "Papa/Papi",
|
3. SyntaxError - Madonna - American Life
Quote:
Dillon - 10 - It almost ruined her career commercially and critically. BEST ENTRY BY FAR.  Really, one of the best overall entries of the game.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 10. “Hate this song so badly I didn’t even hesistate on giving you a perfect score.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - SyntaxError - 7 - this is difficult because personally, I like this song and don't find it that bad. I know it was controversial and generally viewed as bad, though, and I can see where the critique is coming from. the content seems questionable considering her lifestyle and the rapping is weird, too. either way, it's definitely not among her best work.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 10 - Yep, it's Madonna's worst song, she tried way to hard that it comes across as forced, it's so bland and preachy, the rap is the worst part of it, tho I gotta give her props for trying something new.
|
4. ImARudeBoy - Madonna feat. Nicki Minaj & M.I.A - Give Me All Your Luvin'
Quote:
|
Dillon - 8 - For a lead comeback single, its the biggest disappointment ever. It sounds so immature and I know Madonna think she's 20, but I didn't know she was indeed 7 years old. However, I think M.I.A. and Nicki were good additions to the song and it's not as bad as Girl Gone Wild. Pretty good.
|
Quote:
|
Ray: 8.5. “I actually listened to MDNA on its entirety and it’s a solid effort, just not made for commercial purposes or radio. The one song I can’t stand is B-Day Song with M.I.A and Superstar. GMAYL is definitely bad, and it obviously failed as a lead single. The features kinda save the songs as both MIA and Nicki deliver good verses, but overall it was meant to be a failure with its dated sound and production.”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - ImARudeBoy - 8 - what kind of cheerleading anthem? it's basic and unoriginal, Madonna's voice sounds flat and weak. and what's with those random Nicki and M.I.A. features? not even their presence makes this song better.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 7 - While this song is not Madonna's most strongest work and it is kinda basic compared to other songs on her discography, I find it very cute and I sometimes I bop to it, it's definitely a grower, imo is not Madonna's worst song, but is not her best, kinda like in the middle.
|
5. johnrm - Taylor Swift - Superman
Quote:
|
Dillon - .5 - It's not her strongest track.......but in what world is this a BAD track. I didn't ask for the worst track by your fave (which this would not be the worst song from Taylor). This is really disappointing after you having a perfect 10 twice in this competition. I thought you were going up but you completely crashed like I've never seen. sorry john Also, I told you not to send Taylor in anymore. It shows no diversity in your entries. Disappointing.
|
Quote:
Ray: 2. “I’m not here for you coming at Taylor’s best bonus track EVER. I watched,Superman flyyy awaaaaaaaaaaay.  Big No-No for you John, you seriously are inconsistent!”
|
Quote:
|
Anna - johnrm - 2 - dude, you have to stop always sending in Taylor songs. it worked perfectly with Enchanted, but you should have left it at that and shown some diversity this round. 'cause honestly, even Taylor's weakest tracks are still pretty listenable, they're just extra cheesy and that applies to this song, too. it's a nice melody, nice instrumentation and vocals, only the lyrics are a bit childish or whatever you wanna call it, but it's not really bad or a mess or even anything in that direction.
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 0 - How many Taylor songs have you submitted, John? You are such a stan. Anyway, this song is not bad! You probably don't like it but it is by no means her worst song. the lyrics are cute and the production it's very clean and good. I think you should step up your game from now on (and stop submitting Taylor songs) if you want to stay in this competition because as of yet you are one of the weak Survivors.
|
Score's coming...
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/18/2010
Posts: 10,698
|
John dragged even filthier than last time.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/22/2012
Posts: 25,520
|
I woke up just in time! I did great!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/22/2012
Posts: 25,520
|
Oh, my God! I actually promised that I would come back on top and I did. I'm safe!
|
|
|
|
|
|
