"Hero" has been SO overdone, I really don't want to hear it again tonight. I'm hoping for Christina, even the Whitney song would do.
The melancolic vibe actually really works for this. I'm surprised, I never like listening to this even when Mariah sings it, although that part was really unnecessary .
i'm really starting to hate simon and l.a reid..it's like they care more about winning than actually critiquing the contestants..put the dam egos aside...ur playing with a person's life...can't u save the dumb comments till after the show..believe it or not..america is very fickle..say 1 bad thing about a contestant and they don't vote for them lol
Oh Simon. I think he decides what he's going to say even before the show starts. Well yeah it wasn't karaoke but it wasn't original or "bloody fantastic" either.
I agree 100% with Paula here. Oh and also, I think that was Melanie's worst performance since the live shows started.
.
Best performance of the night, by default.
