Alicia won because of course Urban AC plays her material like it's brand new, so I expected her to win vs Bey. I kinda expected Justin to win vs Usher, and I expected Kelly to win vs Pink. It's all very interesting.
What's even more interesting is the 80's legends Madonna, Whitney, Mike and Prince haven't been punched out yet. I had no idea Urban AC, AC, and Oldies were such a huge factor for them.