Quote:
Originally posted by SupremeGoddess
waiting, words, thief of hearts, in this life, secret garden, why is it so hard, did you do it are all amazing
theres not one bad song on the album.
 |
Did You Do It? remains like a literal hidden gem, I have no clue why it wasn't on the edited version of the album.
Like the album has songs about vagina and getting a money shot/golden shower, but this is what they remove.
Quote:
Originally posted by Subomie
did you do it
 |
....slays.
Quote:
Originally posted by Vilppu
I mean... even Did You Do It? is imo better than Rain 
In all honesty though, all of the Erotica tracks (bar DYDI and Shame) could make the Top 40 and I'd be totally fine. |
Did You Do It? is better than Bad Girl tbh.
Quote:
Originally posted by conatus
!!!
Did You Do It? is honestly great but I had to tug it a bit because it's not M, so...
|
So you gave it a well deserved 10 instead of an 11. Fair enough.
Quote:
Originally posted by Eeveelution
Rain is pretty bad tbh.
But it is definitely NOT worse than Did You Do It. Let's not get ahead of ourselves!
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Vilppu
Did You Do It? at least has the gorgeous Waiting sample.
|
Waiting is so blessed to be saved by being engrained in the memories of REAL fans who acknowledge Did You Do It?
Quote:
Originally posted by HausOfCarlos
Yeah, Did you do it? and Waiting are part of the 4 10s I gave Erotica so far.
|
When I hear this......
Quote:
Originally posted by tylerlscwv
I know, it is gonna be such a fun rate.
DYDI isn't doing as bad as I thought it would tbh. Considering Madge is barely on it, it is doing alright actually.
|
I was sending nudes for a bit.
Quote:
Originally posted by HonourableVomit
Ever since she first got the itch with the iconic Shoo-Bee-Doo
Jimmy Jimmy
Act of Contrition (or Love Song?)
Did You Do It?
Nobody's Perfect
I'm So Stupid
I Love New York
Incredible
B'Day Song
S.E.X.
|
Neither Did You Do It? or S.E.X. are troll songs.
Quote:
Originally posted by JakeKills
Did You Do It kinda serving Partition teas.
Not really sad this isn't on my Erotica dl.
|
I weep for your taste.
Quote:
Originally posted by tylerlscwv
LLM, I swear if you ever sent rates in I'd half expect them to be an 11 for DYDI and 1s for everything else just to make a point.
|
You're right, everything is basically a 1 in comparison anyways.
Quote:
Originally posted by enxe
Did You Do It kinda slays, but I know ya'll will do it wrong |
There's hope for this world.
Quote:
Originally posted by mrmikefern
I agree. It does slay. But it's not a Madonna song. It's basically just a remix included on tracklist. Mariah 1995-2005 album teas.  I'd be more accepting of DYDI had Waiting been released as a single and DYDI was the B-side. |
Insider tea, if you were all pissed the non-single Candy Shop was on the setlist, the 2016 show will have Did You Do It? replacing Holy Water.
Quote:
Originally posted by tylerlscwv
This. It is hard for me to justify giving it anything better than a 5 just because it really isn't a Madonna song. I think it was a creative inclusion to Erotica and I enjoy it in the context of them album. But I would never play it if I was in the mood to just put Madonna on shuffle.
|
Well at least it wasn't a zero, and at least you're acknowledging it.
Quote:
Originally posted by Lifeline
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Superiore
The worst song on the album  |
My new favorite post of the thread tbh.
Tea
