[Bie]

Originally posted by idkher

But no one is copying those videos or performances whereas actual up and coming artists are literally carbon copies of Mariah and try to sound exactly like her. Mariah's influence on vocals and music >>>>>>>>> Britney's slightly iconic VMA moments and video outfits

I already said that Mariah is vocally more impactful than Britney in one of my posts above. Please stop copying me. Britney something new to the table

Taylor's bad blood video is influenced by Britney's toxic. Lana said toxic video influenced her. Toxic diamond suits from toxic video is influencing this generation. Britney's oops influenced Ariana's problem and break free video. And there's more. Saying Britney videos/performances have no impacts is ridiculous.

[idkher]

Originally posted by Nano

Asia isn't the only part of the world Since when is the US excluded when talking about what's the most global And you're seriously deflating BOMT's numbers.

I'm using the Mediatraffic numbers. If we want to use official numbers then Music Box is at 32m copies It only gets worse for Britney

And where exactly does Britney excel where Mariah doesn't? I think Britney may be ahead in the UK by 1 or 2 million single sales and that's literally the only place. Mariah obviously destroys her in North America, Asia, Oceania, Africa... it might be close in Europe and South America but I'm sure Mariah still comes out on top there

[MadOnHer]

Madonna, then Janet are the 2 most influential in terms of creativity, envelope-pushing, visuals and performance.

Either Mariah or Whitney would be number 3, as their only real influence has been vocally.

[slw84]

Just to show them some love

Mandy moore, Michelle branch and Willa ford?

When WILL YOUR FAVES?

[Thisisit]

Madonna, Aretha, then one of the following Whitney/Mariah/Cher/Barbra/Diana

You all do way too much, no one remembers Janet.

[slw84]

Originally posted by MadOnHer

Madonna, then Janet are the 2 most influential in terms of creativity, envelope-pushing, visuals and performance.

Either Mariah or Whitney would be number 3, as their only real influence has been vocally.

The lies you are bringing to the table

mariah's influence on

remixes
rent a rappers
hip hop pop collaborations

Which is why I would say
Madonna
Mariah
Janet
Whitney
Britney

as top 5

[slw84]

Originally posted by Thisisit

Madonna, Aretha, then one of the following Whitney/Mariah/Cher/Barbra/Diana

You all do way too much, no one remembers Janet.

Aretha for R&b not pop

Barba erm...I see it in her influence on Celine but...she's a legend and icon but influence over so many artists...I don't see it.

Cher...I wanted to add her because of her influence on Madonna but I need more than reinventions and longevity.

Diana...not on pop but she's a legend.

[K@rm@]

lol at people saying Britney when she was directly influence by Janet Jackson Dancing, tours, Music videos.

It would be

Madonna, Janet, and either Whitney/Mariah.

[ultraviolento]

Originally posted by slw84

Aretha for R&b not pop

Barba erm...I see it in her influence on Celine but...she's a legend and icon but influence over so many artists...I don't see it.

Cher...I wanted to add her because of her influence on Madonna but I need more than reinventions and longevity.

Diana...not on pop but she's a legend.

Mariah is also R&B so why not Aretha (the most influential/respected female vocalist ever)? lol

[dabunique]

i luv how my bitch is da common denominator lol

Madonna above all lol
Miss Jackson
MiMi
Nippie

In dat order

I luv Whitney so much but honestly she was all voice, unlike MiMi who wrote and produced her own **** jus like my bitch

trust youngins, get into songwriting and producing, is where the money is and that way you have more control


while my bitch and janet don't have the vocal abilities of the others, they make it up in other things that surpass the other ones

[dabunique]

oh and shame on anybody tryin to discredit the impact Janet has had


da nerve of sum of u

[superben]

Madonna
Judy Garland
Diana Ross

[Materialboy215]

Originally posted by Domination

Madonna, Whitney, Britney. Depending on how Gaga's next few album cycles go, I could see her overthrowing Britney easily.

The student could never overthrow the teacher I mean come on lol

[slw84]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

Mariah is also R&B so why not Aretha (the most influential/respected female vocalist ever)? lol

Mariah's massive success came from middle of the road pop with a tinge of r&b it wasn't until later in her career where she took on more r&b and hip hop.

Aretha is known as the queen of soul for a reason.

I love both but to call Aretha pop is an insult to what she brought to r&b/soul music tbh

[slw84]

Originally posted by dabunique

i luv how my bitch is da common denominator lol

Madonna above all lol
Miss Jackson
MiMi
Nippie

In dat order

I luv Whitney so much but honestly she was all voice, unlike MiMi who wrote and produced her own **** jus like my bitch

trust youngins, get into songwriting and producing, is where the money is and that way you have more control


while my bitch and janet don't have the vocal abilities of the others, they make it up in other things that surpass the other ones

I agree. Britney is definitely top 10 and I would say #5 but definitely not before Madonna, Janet, mariah and whitney

[Bang Up]

Originally posted by idkher

If we're not going way back to the Barbra, Cher, Tina days... then Madonna, Mariah and Janet by far. Not people seriously mentioning Britney


Mariah is more influential when it comes to vocals and music trends

Right?

Madonna, Tina Turner, and Cher.

[mcuykend]

Madonna, Kate Bush, Britney Spears

[One Nation]

Originally posted by StonedSoulPicnic

Madonna
Whitney
Mariah

.

[Mr. Wonder]

Originally posted by ArtForFreedom

Madonna
Whitney
Janet

If we're talking the last 30 years, this is the correct answer.

[Rei]

Madonna, Britney and someone else.