[Gangsta4alife]

Originally posted by jdmc218

Metacritic already scored London Calling a perfect 100!!

I knew it would score a 100, just a flawless album from start to finish. Thank you so much for this thread gives me more information on who in the past was really acclaimed.

[Aqim]

Like A Prayer . Truly a perfectly powerful album.

[Reverie]

Aretha?
She has too many albums though

[Kool_Aid_King]

I think these are kinda inaccurate because you have to look at the reviews MC actually takes.

[Auburn]

Janet's are too low! Can you do Shania Twain? Thanks in advance!

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by stereo.love

Can you do Shania Twain? Thanks in advance!

I was about to ask this!

[jdmc218]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

I think these are kinda inaccurate because you have to look at the reviews MC actually takes.

What do you mean she takes? She takes what she gets, and you know these scores are accurate to what the reviews say.

[posh]

Janet Jackson=51
Dream Street=47

Dream Street is way better than JJ.

[jdmc218]

Originally posted by posh

Dream Street is way better than JJ.

I agree but the reviews don't

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by jdmc218

What do you mean she takes? She takes what she gets, and you know these scores are accurate to what the reviews say.

MC = Metacritic. Totally forgot you were a stan. Prolly shoulda wrote out the word instead of using an acronym

[BLaCKPoWeR]

Janet Jackson
Control=78
Rhythm Nation 1814=80
Janet=64
Velvet Rope=83

Aaliyah
Age Ain't Nothing But a Number=68
One In a Million=70

[Cheetos]

Originally posted by jdmc218

Like A Prayer had widespread acclaim, while Bedtime Stories and Erotica had well received reviews. Trust me!

OH im sure your method is fine lol i just mean that they should've been rated better by critics

[Forevermore]

Madonna's scores should be way higher. Ray of Light should be in the 90s.

[Misanthrope]

Why is Kelly Clarkson included?

[Misanthrope]

Originally posted by TheGeoKing

Madonna's scores should be way higher. Ray of Light should be in the 90s.

She got the scores she deserved mostly. However I think Like A Prayer should be in the 70s and Ray of Light in the 90s.

[Soda Pop Queen]

I've always wondered why MC didn't have pre-21st scores on their site. Do you know?

edit: oh, I see. They didn't exist until 2000. They could have went back and scored all the old albums but that probably would've taken a long time...

Anyway, these look reasonable, good job.

Could you do....

Björk
Radiohead
Usher
Alanis Morissette
Fiona Apple
Monica
Tori Amos
Red Hot Chili Peppers
Queen
The Cardigans
En Vogue
Brandy
No Doubt

Thanks

[Pressed Bitch]

Can you do Björk's Homogenic it's 85+ score?

[jdmc218]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

MC = Metacritic. Totally forgot you were a stan. Prolly shoulda wrote out the word instead of using an acronym

Well Metacritic usually takes all of the reviews, except for any review that's not noticeable and just pops in unexpectedly.

[jdmc218]

Originally posted by Misanthrope

Why is Kelly Clarkson included?

Because Breakaway wasn't scored by Metacritic.

[like2throw]

calculate the rating for Purple Rain and Sign of the Times please.

edit:Oh so SOTT got a 98 I see, as expected