[Shinning]

Judas of course. It had like hundreds of extras/dancers and all of them had to be clothed and payed. Not to mention the multiple sets and the water scene. E.T. had three people in it and was mostly filmed in front of a green screen. I don't know how expensive those special effects are though so maybe I'm wrong

[Glamorous]

Expensive =/= good quality.

[SylMacPer]

I guess ET! It looks more expensive!

[Superiore]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

E.T. has 50 million more views than Judas.
E.T. has 2 VMA's while Judas has none.
E.T. (song) experienced a rise in sales after the video was released.
Judas (song) experienced a decline in sales after the video.
Do i need to go on?

FAIL. It returned in Top 10 for a little while after the video's release and then you have to consider the strength of the song that the video is for. Judas has sold not even 3 million worldwide and I think E.T. surpassed 6 million so 50 million it's not that big of a gap considering their power on charts!

[˚Greedy for Ari˚]

Originally posted by superiore-93

FAIL. It returned in Top 10 for a little while after the video's release and then you have to consider the strength of the song that the video is for. Judas has sold not even 3 million worldwide and I think E.T. surpassed 6 million so 50 million it's not that big of a gap considering their power on charts!

The Judas video is all you little monsters have to something close to decent from the BTW videography.
While we Katy Cats have a fabulous selection from 8 impeccable videos, each being unique and diverse from the other.

[BlooRiverAnimal]

I'll say E.T. just because of the CGI and whatnot, That was probably really pricey.

[SylMacPer]

Originally posted by superiore-93

FAIL. It returned in Top 10 for a little while after the video's release and then you have to consider the strength of the song that the video is for. Judas has sold not even 3 million worldwide and I think E.T. surpassed 6 million so 50 million it's not that big of a gap considering their power on charts!

Sales =/= YouTube views

Baby and all the other Bieb vids except ALAYLM and BF flopped but their views are 200M + each!

[Dickard]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

The Judas video is all you little monsters have to something close to decent from the BTW videography.
While we Katy Cats have a fabulous selection from 8 impeccable videos, each being unique and diverse from the other.

can I keep this quote forever? You honestly think WA, POM, CG and LFN are THAT good?
So cheesy, so cheap looking, so trite!


This is all my opinion of course, but you cannot say without the slightest apprehension in your heart that those videos are pristine.

[˚Greedy for Ari˚]

IS CGI Really that expensive you guys. I mean let's not act like the production is Avatar worthy.
Judas had hundreds of dancers and costumes and bikes and set designs, while E.T. only needed a green screen and Katy's flawless face.

[Benjamin]

Originally posted by Dickard

Judas was blacklisted on radio
Judas was obviously more controversial, causing the decline in sales and popularity
Perry enlisted West for shameless promotion

Yes; please do spew more Wikipedia facts I'm sure it will convince me.


--

Anyway, gaga doesn't spend THAT much on music videos

Wikipedia facts? Wut? Those are facts full-stop, no Wikipedia about it.

And your Kanye point would make more sense if she didn't have 5 equally as successful videos form the era without him on it.

[˚Greedy for Ari˚]

Originally posted by Dickard

can I keep this quote forever? You honestly think WA, POM, CG and LFN are THAT good?
So cheesy, so cheap looking, so trite!
This is all my opinion of course, but you cannot say with the slightest apprehension in your heart that those videos are pristine.

Wide Awake was nominated for Video of the year was Judas even nominated for a significant VMA? i mean, clearly the professionals side with me.

[˚Greedy for Ari˚]

Originally posted by Benjamin

Wikipedia facts? Wut? Those are facts full-stop, no Wikipedia about it.

And your Kanye point would make more sense if she didn't have 5 equally as successful videos form the era without him on it.

YAS!!!! DRAG!!

[Dickard]

Originally posted by Benjamin

Wikipedia facts? Wut? Those are facts full-stop, no Wikipedia about it.

And your Kanye point would make more sense if she didn't have 5 equally as successful videos form the era without him on it.

I know they are facts you can go on Wikipedia and copy and paste verbatim what was posted. That's what I meant.


I stand by my point that expensive video =/= better video

[Superiore]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

The Judas video is all you little monsters have to something close to decent from the BTW videography.
While we Katy Cats have a fabulous selection from 8 impeccable videos, each being unique and diverse from the other.

Read well my post. Have I said anything bad about E.T.?

I don't get it, if you have no constructive and on-topic things to say you better shut up not?

Originally posted by SylMacPer

Sales =/= YouTube views

Baby and all the other Bieb vids except ALAYLM and BF flopped but their views are 200M + each!

I know

It's just that he built his point on that saying how the Judas' video was bad and made the song flop

[KRL]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

The Judas video is all you little monsters have to something close to decent from the BTW videography.
While we Katy Cats have a fabulous selection from 8 impeccable videos, each being unique and diverse from the other.

Born this way is better than any Katy perry video

[Dickard]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

Wide Awake was nominated for Video of the year was Judas even nominated for a significant VMA? i mean, clearly the professionals side with me.

The VMAs are not and were never important. The only awards that hold any pertinence are Grammys, and even those are becoming a joke. Obviously this is all subjective, and I'm not about to change your mind and vice versa.

[˚Greedy for Ari˚]

Originally posted by Dickard

The VMAs are not and were never important. The only awards that hold any pertinence are Grammys, and even those are becoming a joke. Obviously this is all subjective, and I'm not about to change your mind and vice versa.

The VMA's are the only thing that award Music videos, so let's not.
VMA's opinions, Youtube views, Song sales are music video premiere >>> your opinions
I'm sorry that's reality!

[Dark Miracles]

Why are y'all wailing about "expensive doesn't equal better"? Duh, of course it doesn't always mean it's better. But that's not the point of this thread.

[Dickard]

Originally posted by iKatyCats

The VMA's are the only thing that award Music videos, so let's not.
VMA's opinions, Youtube views, Song sales are music video premiere >>> your opinions
I'm sorry that's reality!

No it's not

[JasperX]

don't care they are expensive or not. both are bad