Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
Beyonce is a multi-dimensional artist. Have you heard 4? It's a very personal and honest album, and has her own personal themes. It's not extremely artsy or... "deep" but it's not like it's vapid and one dimensional.
Xtina is hardly multi-dimensional. Stripped is a joke of an album, which is the album everyone else uses as an example for her being "deep."
|
Yes, I've heard all of Beyonce's albums, and she doesn't offer much variety in terms of her content like Xtina. She's pretty one-dimensional in that aspect. Plus, she's evolving as an artist much too slowly, and we probably won't see the best she can do until nobody really cares about her anymore.
Christina is far more multifaceted than Rihanna and Beyonce. The so-called "joke of an album", although uncohesive, is more personal and realistic than anything the other two have put out.