[Liana]

Miley Cyrus used to be my idol once upon a time but I've ALWAYS loved Hilary so I choose Hilary

[J.Givenchy]

Originally posted by Middle of Selena

they will surely come for u

surely Tommy Pickles, Chucky Finster, and the other rugrats know better than to try Angelica

[minxie]

The ratings, soundtrack sales, box-office receipts, and the fact Miley was a billion dollar franchise all in all trump everything Elizabeth has to offer. Am I lying?

[minxie]

Originally posted by J.Givenchy

surely Tommy Pickles, Chucky Finster, and the other rugrats know better than to try Angelica

It's not like you've input anything of value to the thread, so why would the Miley stans feel the need to "try" you in the first place?

[PopBoi]

I like Miley but she can irritate the **** outta me

[Right Now]

Originally posted by J.Givenchy

Girl, stop playing with these kids! They don't know any better!

The problem is Miley stans don't think things through. They come up with the most random **** to defend Miley that reaches to a whole new height of stupidity and don't have things to back them up.

The LOL movie, for example. That film was going to bomb at the box office regardless. Lionsgate knew it, the industry knew it, Miley knew it. Some promotion wasn't going to make it a huge film no matter how much Miley fans wanted to think that. Why do they think Miley stayed AWAY from that film.

So Undercover is about to go through a limited release as well. She is NOT a big draw anymore. Much like Hilary, Miley decided she wanted to take personal time off and not do anything substantial for a few years. Both were overworked at a young age. Rather than make excuses, Miley's fans need to deal with the harsh reality of a former child star/teen queen.

[Terra]

Originally posted by J.Givenchy

surely Tommy Pickles, Chucky Finster, and the other rugrats know better than to try Angelica

So youre comparing Right Now to a 9 year old brat? I see.

[pika]

Originally posted by Right Now

I'm going to make this as basic as I can to stoop down to your level:

HSM - Performing Arts
Austin & Ally - Multiple talented kids
Shake It Up - Performing Arts
Lemonade Mouth - Performing Arts
How To Rock - Multiple talented kids
Victorious - Performing Arts

Hannah Montana only featured Miley as the star and the other two as her lessor friends. Eventually, they expanded to make Mitchel's character a rapper/singer/whatever too.

Austin & Ally - Boy trying to become famous
How To Rock - Band trying to become famous
Victorious - Girl trying to become famous
Shake It Up - Girls trying to become famous by dancing
When did I ever bring up Lemonade Mouth, sis?
Death @ you saying "Performing Arts" as if that isn't centered around trying to make it in the business and become famous. And DEATH @ you saying "stooping to my level" when you made the reach of Miley's career being inspired by Hilary's. You can get skeptical and try to act like Disney AND Nickelodeon haven't tried to clone Hannah Montana's success, but at the end of the day, HM stays with more cultural impact than Lizzie McGuire ever had.

[Right Now]

Originally posted by pika

Austin & Ally - Boy trying to become famous
How To Rock - Band trying to become famous
Victorious - Girl trying to become famous
Shake It Up - Girls trying to become famous by dancing
When did I ever bring up Lemonade Mouth, sis?
Death @ you saying "Performing Arts" as if that isn't centered around trying to make it in the business and become famous. And DEATH @ you saying "stooping to my level" when you made the reach of Miley's career being inspired by Hilary's. You can get skeptical and try to act like Disney AND Nickelodeon haven't tried to clone Hannah Montana's success, but at the end of the day, HM stays with more cultural impact than Lizzie McGuire ever had.

What cultural impact? Miley is best known for her scandals.

At least Hilary has an undeniably charming character that she is most recognized for. Miley will always be known as the Disney good girl gone bad.

[pika]

Originally posted by Right Now

The problem is Miley stans don't think things through. They come up with the most random **** to defend Miley that reaches to a whole new height of stupidity and don't have things to back them up.

The LOL movie, for example. That film was going to bomb at the box office regardless. Lionsgate knew it, the industry knew it, Miley knew it. Some promotion wasn't going to make it a huge film no matter how much Miley fans wanted to think that. Why do they think Miley stayed AWAY from that film.

So Undercover is about to go through a limited release as well. She is NOT a big draw anymore. Much like Hilary, Miley decided she wanted to take personal time off and not do anything substantial for a few years. Both were overworked at a young age. Rather than make excuses, Miley's fans need to deal with the harsh reality of a former child star/teen queen.

Did your ass NOT run in here saying Miley's career was based off of Hilary's with no receipt? Did you NOT say Awkward and other shows were based off of Lizzie McGuire. The resemblance between Hannah Montana and the shows I listed have at least some similarities, and others will agree. Yet you cling to current shows being inspired by one that came out ages ago.

The hypocrisy

[Terra]

Originally posted by Right Now

What cultural impact? Miley is best known for her scandals.

At least Hilary has an undeniably charming character that she is most recognized for. Miley will always be known as the Disney good girl gone bad.

Next time I go to the store, I'll take note of all the HM merchandise I see. And I'll attempt to find anything LM related.

[minxie]

Originally posted by Right Now

At least Hilary as an undeniably charming character that she is most recognized for.

Might want to open up Word and correct that sentence fragment.

[Liana]

Hilary was the queen during the Lizzie McGuire era & Miley was the Disney queen during the Hannah Montana era. They are both from different generations & I really love both but I chose Hilary only because I kind of prefer her more & she was my childhood.

[xLovatoEve]

Miley has 22 votes

[pika]

Originally posted by Right Now

What cultural impact? Miley is best known for her scandals.

At least Hilary has an undeniably charming character that she is most recognized for. Miley will always be known as the Disney good girl gone bad.

Are you that dumb and blind, sis? I listed all the shows that HM had an impact. You tried it with "performing arts" and "multiple talented kids" but their premises still stand as kids that want to make it in the business and ultimately, perform to millions, sing, dance, and overall be famous.

For you to get into "image" and "what they're most recognized for" is completely off topic. I don't care, and many others don't if Miley is seen as the bad girl. But if it helps you sleep at night, then cling to Hilary always being remembered as the boring plastic nice girl.

[Right Now]

Originally posted by pika

Did your ass NOT run in here saying Miley's career was based off of Hilary's with no receipt? Did you NOT say Awkward and other shows were based off of Lizzie McGuire. The resemblance between Hannah Montana and the shows I listed have at least some similarities, and others will agree. Yet you cling to current shows being inspired by one that came out ages ago.

The hypocrisy

You're the one with no receipts in this thread. All of the shows you mentioned and the film I brought up, Lemonade Mouth were more than likely inspired by High School Musical, rather than Hannah Montana. Note how all the current Disney & Nick girls refer to Lizzie McGuire & Hilary as their childhood inspiration not Hannah & especially not Miley. Well unless you count Carly Jae Repson.

[PopBoi]

I had no idea members here took Disney this seriously

[minxie]

Originally posted by Liana

Hilary was the queen during the Lizzie McGuire era & Miley was the Disney queen during the Hannah Montana era. They are both from different generations & I really love both but I chose Hilary only because I kind of prefer her more & she was my childhood.

Thank you for supporting my theory that Hilary's only good for novelty value.

[PopBoi]

Originally posted by kaleidoscope

Thank you for supporting my theory that Hilary's only good for novelty value.

But you can't forget that Dignity >> any Miley album

[Terra]

Originally posted by PopBoi

I had no idea members here took Disney this seriously

Really? This is nothing. You should have seen the Disney Girl rate thread.