[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Madonna is not in the trinity.
Think of the Trinity as Charlie's Angels, She would be Charlie.

So, she basically has them working for her? That sounds... right.

[BadKidBrodie]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Madonna is not in the trinity.
Think of the Trinity as Charlie's Angels, She would be Charlie.

[pika]

Originally posted by Boop

No she's not.

And what makes you say that? Please, do tell all.

[Orsay]

Originally posted by Love ♥

Madonna just wasn't for the 70's/80's. She was still able to go #1 on her 11th album in 2008. Queen.

asdfsg Madonna debuted in the 80's

you betta stan

[Duca]

Originally posted by pika

Of course you call it 'local', since Britney has always been ignored at the Grammys. Yet I've seen you fly around the forum bragging about Justin's Grammys. Hypocrite. And Duca, if you're really trying to use critical success to keep Britney in the trinity, you might as well look at the amount of awards Gaga and Beyonce have won in the last couple of years compared to Britney. Rihanna or Adele take her place when it comes to that.

Both are highly critically acclaimed outside the Grammys. Britney received three lifetime achievement awards in the last two years. I don't care about Rihanna's 40 Barbados Music Awards.

[RichGirlPlanet]

Originally posted by Love ♥

So, she basically has them working for her? That sounds... right.

Don't get it twisted, sister.

[KitKat]

Originally posted by BadKidBrodie

Have I done something wrong?

Her debut album didn't come out till '83

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by Orsay

asdfsg Madonna debuted in the 80's

you betta stan

I screamed @ 70's, but I'll go along with whateva she says. I am NAWT gonna disagree with a Gaga stan who really believes she started in the 70's.

[EmaciatedHooker]

THIS REIGNING POP QUEEN!

[Guero]

Originally posted by Katie

Her debut album didn't come out till '83

Madonna - the true queen of pop, with the ability to smash the charts before even debuting.

[BadKidBrodie]

Originally posted by Orsay

asdfsg Madonna debuted in the 80's

you betta stan

I realize that now

[ChapStick]

Originally posted by metacritic

Summary: The British singer’s sophomore album is full of soul and pop rhythms, comparable to Amy Winehouse and Duffy.

Originally posted by metacritic

Genre(s): R&B, Soul, Pop/Rock, Adult Alternative Pop/Rock, Alternative/Indie Rock

nobody remains part of "the trinity" forever, and people can also be temporarily in the trinity if they're successful enough. with time comes change... but if we don't embrace that change, it will eat us alive. let the cockney non-traditoinal pop star live out her moment in the pop spotlight, for it is still her time as of now. if she can't be in the trinity, she shall be above it where the past year and current portion of 2012 is concerned.

[KitKat]

Originally posted by Guero

Madonna - the true queen of pop, with the ability to smash the charts before even debuting.

And that's how you know you're a bad bitch.

[EmaciatedHooker]

Originally posted by Love ♥

Gaga ain't the Queen of Pop of this current time with an 80%+ drop a second week.
I don't have anything against her, but the Monsters sometimes annoy me when they try it with Madonna and then act as if Gaga is the second coming of Jesus Christ.

Hun, even with that 80% drop, her second week was higher than Rihanna and Katy's first week and Britney's album didn't even break platinum, so stop. BTW also went on to sell more than FF and "4" combined times two.

If Adele is part of the trinity, then we must knock Britney out.

[Duca]

Originally posted by ChapStick

nobody remains part of "the trinity" forever, and people can also be temporarily in the trinity if they're successful enough. with time comes change... but if we don't embrace that change, it will eat us alive. let the cockney non-traditoinal pop star live out her moment in the pop spotlight, for it is still her time as of now. if she can't be in the trinity, she shall be above it where the past year and current portion of 2012 is concerned.

And she's still not a popstar.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Some of these members are making me cringe. I remember why I left that stanbase.
But anyway, still screaming @ "70's" and JLo being alone in the groups.

[BadKidBrodie]

Originally posted by Love ♥

I screamed @ 70's, but I'll go along with whateva she says. I am NAWT gonna disagree with a Gaga stan who really believes she started in the 70's.

Sis, It's called a joke. To extend my point of view.

[pika]

Originally posted by Duca

Both are critically acclaimed outside the Grammys. I don't care about Rihanna's 40 Barbados Music Awards.

Yet you were saying in the OP that Britney, Gaga, and Beyonce are the current trinity. Metacritic ain't everything. Awards speak much better. Rihanna is in, Britney is out. Accept and deal

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by EmaciatedHooker

Hun, even with that 80% drop, her second week was higher than Rihanna and Katy's first week and Britney's album didn't even break platinum, so stop. BTW also went on to sell more than FF and "4" combined times two.

If Adele is part of the trinity, then we must knock Britney out.

Except I'm not comparing her to Katy, Rihanna or Britney.

[Duca]

Originally posted by EmaciatedHooker

Hun, even with that 80% drop, her second week was higher than Rihanna and Katy's first week and Britney's album didn't even break platinum, so stop. BTW also went on to sell more than FF and "4" combined times two.

If Adele is part of the trinity, then we must knock Britney out.

It wasn't bigger than Rihanna's and Katy's first weeks. Britney's album had two promo performances. It’s not comparable. And it also didn't sell more than 'Femme Fatale' and '4' combined, times two.