Easily. The only thing Britney has on Gaga is dancing, and that doesn't mean much as an artist.
Quote:
Originally posted by longjohn9898
I don't know why some people insist on the whole idea that Britney has been relevant for a decade. Yes, she's been in the public sphere for over a decade, but between her peak around 1999-2001 and now 2010-2011 her relevancy was mediocre at best. She had some hits here and there, but her relevancy revolved more around the paparazzi digging up juicy, sometimes false, information on her and spreading it to the masses rather than Britney actually releasing huge hits.
In any case, in terms of careers Gaga is on a similar level to Britney. Both have had massive success, but Gaga's done it in far less time and has critics and awards on her side. In terms of talent, Britney's not as talentless as Katy Perry, but Gaga ***** on her---be it singing, writing, performing, playing instruments, etc.
|
Exactly. Her relevancy was 1998-2004. The past 6-7 years was centered around her personal life. So her being 'here for 13 years' is not some big deal. Beyonce has been around for 14, I don't see any of her stans bring that up a million times.
Quote:
Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning
Not forgetting that Britney made more of an impact in her first 3 years and revived a whole music genre.
|
Britney didn't revive anything.
Pop music made its comeback in 1996 with Hanson, The Spice Girls and the Backstreet Boys. Britney didn't come out until 1998. She's even said herself in interviews from 1999 that pop music has made a comeback because of those acts.
Quote:
Originally posted by Anthagio
This whole "let's see where she is in ten years" thing is irrelevant because that's not what this is asking.
I personally say yes because I don't see Britney as an artist. She's been controlled and told what to do from day one, so she's more of a vessel for other peoples' ideas. Gaga writes all of her lyrics, composes all of her melodies, co-produces all of her songs, comes up with all of her video ideas, etc. and Britney does not. That is all.
|
[britney stan] BRITNEY CAME UP WITH THE VIDEO CONCEPT FOR BABY ONE MORE TIME!!!!!!!ONEONEELEVENTY
[/britney stan]