I have never been a fan of Katherine McPhee, but her losing to Taylor Hicks, the poor sis did not deserve that.
And Daughtry was in Season 5 with Katherine, not Season 6. I'm trying to think of who you might be thinking of instead. Phil Stacey?
No I meant Daughtry. My memory is kind of a fail sometimes and for some reason I remembered them being in the same season together. He was my fave in season 5 then I started rooting for Katherine after he left. Jordin was one of my favorites from season 6 from the beginning. My bad.
Mess Dragged down Jordin mostly because y'all overrated her a lot, but there are defo some amazing songs there. Fantasia's average got dragged down by those awful remixes Her album is still my least favourite out of all 4 tho.
My ratings are going to be pretty low, I'm trying to be a lot more objective. If I find a song 'good' it will get a 7/10 - however I am only giving songs that are truly extraordinary above a 7/10.
Poor Carrie, I hated Some Hearts so she may be in jeopardy.
I need to tabulate what the results look like currently, but from a cursory glance, these scores are so messy. Every girl has scores that are all over the place.
I need to tabulate what the results look like currently, but from a cursory glance, these scores are so messy. Every girl has scores that are all over the place.
And please, send in Tyler!
I've already heard Carrie and Kelly's and most of Jordin's, but I can't with Fantasia. She's so annoying