[SwagLikeALegend]

Originally posted by N@te

Try this is such an underrated album, it makes me cry. It sold 3 million ww and P!nk got a Grammy for Trouble.

!!!

"Last To Know"

[Violet Skye]

Well... Christina has expanded her business. Pink is fabulous but doesn't have the potential or isn't very marketable other than music.

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Violet Skye

Well... Christina has expanded her business. Pink is fabulous but doesn't have the potential or isn't very marketable other than music.

How has Xtina expanded her business?

[Violet Skye]

^She has a lot of endorsements, perfume, movie, etc. She's making a brand out of her name.

[Hooligan]

Hmmmm comparing 'Try This' to 'Bionic'. Both were flops for Pink and Xtina, yet one still managed to go Platinum. Decisions, Decisions :eyeroll:

[Hooligan]

Also dead at no one choosing Lil' Kim. Has no one remembered "The Jump-Off" or "Magic Stick"

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Violet Skye

^She has a lot of endorsements, perfume, movie, etc. She's making a brand out of her name.

Oh I see... but even at that shes not overly dominating each area per-se imo. P!nk still has the better career cause even with that its not like everyones rushing out to see her movies or buy her perfume.

[Violet Skye]

Originally posted by Hooligan

Hmmmm comparing 'Try This' to 'Bionic'. Both were flops for Pink and Xtina, yet one still managed to go Platinum. Decisions, Decisions :eyeroll:

Sales then were a whole lot more compared to now. If Bionic were released then it would have trumped over Try This tbh. Try This flew under the radar and she wasn't even as popular either.

[Violet Skye]

Originally posted by firstlove

Oh I see... but even at that shes not overly dominating each area per-se imo. P!nk still has the better career cause even with that its not like everyones rushing out to see her movies or buy her perfume.

But overall Xtina has had the better career. Even though Xtina is in flopfest right now, Pink hasn't even been close to the relevancy during Xtina's peak.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Violet Skye

But overall Xtina has had the better career. Even though Xtina is in flopfest right now, Pink hasn't even been close to the relevancy during Xtina's peak.

Christina's peak was her first album.

[Violet Skye]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Christina's peak was her first album.

People will still remember Xtina over Pink 10 years from now tbh.

Pink makes accessible and serviceable music and doesn't take much risks, so she's not ever really going to flop but isn't going to be remembered that much either.

[GabeEd]

P!nk shes managed to stay on top after all this years so yeah
Xtina ruined her carrer with bionic ..
Mya last time i hear of her was in L.M. Lol
Lil kim is desperate for attention and dissin nicki sooo she sucks lol

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Christina's peak was her first album.

It doesnt matter if shes never seen that peak imo cause she never maintained her momentum & built a solid fanbase so its almost all for what? You were really popular on your first album (still in someones shadow) released another album (lost fans) released another album (lost even more fans) released another album ( lost more & more fans) In this case consistency is key and in the event Xtina never had that.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Violet Skye

People will still remember Xtina over Pink 10 years from now tbh.

Pink makes accessible and serviceable music and doesn't take much risks, so she's not ever really going to flop but isn't going to be remembered that much either.

People will remember Pink. Really, the only thing people will remember Christina for is her voice.

Christina has been on the decline for years. First album was huge, second album was a success, third album did okay and fourth album flopped miserably. Pink's debut did decently, second album took her to the next level commercially and critically, she had a commercial bump with her third album, came back nicely with fourth album and remained consistent with fifth album and GH. Trajectory and consistency play a big part in this, and Pink wins in both arenas.

[spc08]

P!NK.

Even though at one point Christina was the biggest out of all of them.

[Violet Skye]

OK I'm not going to stan for Xtina because I do not even like her

But I'm just being real, Xtina compared to Britney is nothing, but Xtina compared to Pink then obviously Xtina has had the better career. I mean Xtina was the closest who could ever touch Britney. That says it all.

Pink is safe, and safe is boring and you won't be remembered for that. People don't crave for new Pink music. Xtina still has the potential for that.

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Violet Skye

People will still remember Xtina over Pink 10 years from now tbh.

Pink makes accessible and serviceable music and doesn't take much risks, so she's not ever really going to flop but isn't going to be remembered that much either.

What are you talking about Pink never tkes risks? Mizzundastood was a BIG RISK at the time especially when they wanted to portray her as a certain artist and she fought against it to incorporate messages about what she had to say which may or may not have been sucessful & honestly imo theyre about the same in terms of memorability, but Xtina's decreasing her chances with each flop album.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by firstlove

What are you talking about Pink never tkes risks? Mizzundastood was a BIG RISK at the time especially when they wanted to portray her as a certain artist and she fought against it to incorporate messages about what she had to say which may or may not have been sucessful & honestly imo theyre about the same in terms of memorability, but Xtina's decreasing her chances with each flop album.

Right. Pink was originally an R&B singer, but she wanted to be a pop/rock singer. It was definitely a risk and big transition for her at that time, since she sorta formed an urban fanbase. It was the right move on her part.

[NE.]

Damn, I didn't Christina could SANG like that!

[Bad Wolf]

P!nk