[Albany Guest]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

Right! I can count on my hand the number of times Bey has had a less than stellar vocal performance.
Florence has MANY...
Am I hearing these women differently?
Plus Bey has shown way more power, consistency, use of dynamics, vibrato...
Only ATRL...

Bey more power, really? Since when?

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Albany Guest

Yeah, take one of Florence's worst performances, covering someone else's song as a comparison..... (and this from someone who already voted for Bey).

cheap.

well, a good way to illustrate the differences would be to show them singing the same song, no?
whose fault is it that Florence's cover is bad? mine? Beyoncé's? or Florence's?
I actually like Flo's voice, she has a haunting quality that I know Beyoncé doesn't posses.
I don't hate her.

[mariska]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

Right! I can count on my hand the number of times Bey has had a less than stellar vocal performance.
Florence has MANY...
Am I hearing these women differently?
Plus Bey has shown way more power, consistency, use of dynamics, vibrato...
Only ATRL...

MESS.

[Chimier]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

Right! I can count on my hand the number of times Bey has had a less than stellar vocal performance.
Florence has MANY...
Am I hearing these women differently?
Plus Bey has shown way more power, consistency, use of dynamics, vibrato...
Only ATRL...

And Florence's godawful tremolo that they think is great vibrato....

[Lipton]

Originally posted by Albany Guest

Bey more power, really? Since when?

Right. Beyoncé is no one's vocal powerhouse.

[Brave.]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

well, a good way to illustrate the differences would be to show them singing the same song, no?
whose fault is it that Florence's cover is bad? mine? Beyoncé's? or Florence's?
I actually like Flo's voice, she has a haunting quality that I know Beyoncé doesn't posses.
I don't hate her.

Florence clearly contains the better vocals though...

[B94]

Originally posted by MrHiphy

Really? I always thought of Flo as a contralto.

Lol no way. Her voice is far too strong to be a Contralto, now that's a understatement. Also her voice isn't deep like a true Contralto singer.






And Florence may not have the exact technicality Beyonce has, but she's very close as far as technicality goes so don't even try it. Even if we take that out of the subject, Florence still has superior qualities to her voice that Beyonce will never have, no matter how good of a technical vocalist she is.

[Harmonic Dreamer]

And lets not talk about belts...
Beyoncé can go from a clear and resonant C5 just the same as an F5.
She can hit the notes as easily as she talks.
Not to mention her use of dynamics, she can go from a pianissimo to a fortissimo in a split second.
Her crescendos are precise and accurate, she does decrescendos as well.
Pretty much any advanced vocal feat you can name, Beyoncé has done it and has mastered it.

[QueenB]

Originally posted by Lipton

This only makes me want to back Florence even more. She sounds so rich there and Beyoncé was flat and average being totally carried by her background singers.

Tha ignorance. Cleary you have something against Bey (tha shade in your first post in this thread proves that).

[Brave.]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

And lets not talk about belts...
Beyoncé can go from a clear and resonant C5 just the same as an F5.
She can hit the notes as easily as she talks.
Not to mention her use of dynamics, she can go from a pianissimo to a fortissimo in a split second.
Her crescendos are precise and accurate, she does decrescendos as well.
Pretty much any advanced vocal feat you can name, Beyoncé has done it and has mastered it.

Yet Florence's belts are more powerful and superior than Bey's.

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Originally posted by B94

Lol no way. Her voice is far too strong to be a Contralto, now that's a understatement. Also her voice isn't deep like a true Contralto singer.

Do you know what a true contralto is? Contraltos can also possess strong and powerful voices. The depth of the tone and where the voice naturally sits shouldn't be confused with strength.

[mariska]

The only thing Beyoncé has on Flo is her ability to do complicated vocal runs, but the difference isn't huge.

But ATRL has spoken and I'm rather surprised at the results considering there's more Bey stans. I'm out.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Lipton

This only makes me want to back Florence even more. She sounds so rich there and Beyoncé was flat and average being totally carried by her background singers.

bye Craig

[Brave.]

Her vocal power >>>>

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Brave.

Florence clearly contains the better vocals though...

based on?

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Originally posted by Albany Guest

Bey more power, really? Since when?

Yes really. Especially when she's sang and projected an even amount of power throughout all of her registers. Even in acoustic settings, she's shown to have a powerful and even voice.

[Lipton]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

And lets not talk about belts...
Beyoncé can go from a clear and resonant C5 just the same as an F5.
She can hit the notes as easily as she talks.
Not to mention her use of dynamics, she can go from a pianissimo to a fortissimo in a split second.
Her crescendos are precise and accurate, she does decrescendos as well.
Pretty much any advanced vocal feat you can name, Beyoncé has done it and has mastered it.

The delusion.

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by Lipton

This only makes me want to back Florence even more. She sounds so rich there and Beyoncé was flat and average being totally carried by her background singers.

Mess.

[2AM]

Florence is superior. Sure, Bey is more consistent, but I think Florence's highs are slightly better than Bey's.

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Originally posted by Lipton

The delusion.

I'd like you to prove my posts wrong then.
I have plenty of videos to back my argument up...