Tbh I wouldn't include covers like Lies, Walking After Midnight etc but I wouldn't include iTunes sessions versions of MKIA and so on either because they are only acoustic versions of the original songs. But I would include the EP version of Never Again, You Love Me and If I Can't Have You because the songs are different with different arragement and atmosphere. Merely saying.
Are the Smoakstack and iTunes sessions not official recordings? Are Beautiful Disaster and Up To The Mountain not live? What kind of "discography rate"? If you have the time to include a song that she does BACKING vocals on, you have the time to include the songs that she specifically chose to rework herself. If you think they're all worthless just rate them 0 and move on, or do you not know how to use Excel efficiently enough to tally up the numbers for ten more songs?
Quote:
Originally posted by xDiamondx
They may be the same songs, Strangergab but instrumentally they are very different. For one thing, people definitely rate one higher than the other.
Ignore lifeofpariah, ha opinion is about as meaningful as a National Enquirer story piece.
Let me quote this for you so you can educate yourself then.
Just go to other discography rate threads. An artist discography rate should only include the artist's original songs made for the singer not the live versions or cover songs. If the live versions need to be included just because they sound different, then all of the official remix songs also need to be included. Stop reaching. I think these songs need to be deleted from the list.
(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman
Beautiful Disaster (Live)
I'll Be Home For Christmas
I Can't Make You Love Me
I Never Loved A Man
Your Cheatin' Heart
Walking After Midnight
Lies
That I Would Be Good / Use Somebody
Up to the Mountain (featuring Jeff Beck)
Oh, Holy Night
My Grown Up Christmas List
Respect
Trying to Help You Out
There's A New Kid In Town
Foolish Games
Mr. Know It All (Country Version)
Because Of You (with Reba McEntire)
Include that songs because some are official singles and others are in studio álbums and others written By Her
Include that songs because some are official singles and others are in studio álbums and others written By Her
Yeah but Lies, Your Cheating Heart and co. are neither song written by Kelly nor singles. They are merely random covers on random EP. And if those are included, then EP versions of MKIA, NA, YLM, Stronger etc should be included as well. That would be only fair.
But are The same songs because that dont include but i think would consired. Please wait me to The weekend. but i Still think these song are The same, The others are diferent.
Are the Smoakstack and iTunes sessions not official recordings? Are Beautiful Disaster and Up To The Mountain not live? What kind of "discography rate"? If you have the time to include a song that she does BACKING vocals on, you have the time to include the songs that she specifically chose to rework herself. If you think they're all worthless just rate them 0 and move on, or do you not know how to use Excel efficiently enough to tally up the numbers for ten more songs?
sorry busy day :/
Just go to other discography rate threads. An artist discography rate should only include the artist's original songs made for the singer not the live versions or cover songs. If the live versions need to be included just because they sound different, then all of the official remix songs also need to be included. 
Stop reaching. I think these songs need to be deleted from the list.
and others written By Her 
but i think would consired. Please wait me to The weekend. 
but i Still think these song are The same, The others are diferent. 
wait me to the weekend 
