Quote:
Originally posted by P!nkism
I am not reducing ur thoughts. But again i explained that already. It is not supposed to have metaphors or figurative language. Leave that to Gaga.
She expressed her raw anger with Bush - why would she make it shadey?
It was an angry letter to Bush turned into a song, that was supposed to be a single but she refused coz she wants to keep its integrity as a serious thing instead of a "using Bush to get attention" thing.
P!nk in many reviews is called a brilliant lyricist.
I am sorry but Try Try Try Try Try is very basic lyrically, it can never be compared to her own songs like JLAP, Family Portrait, GITA, Eventually, Chaos and Piss, Crystal Ball and many others  |
You're forgetting Try's amazing chorus (that leads to that hook you quoted) and the lived in, colored in verses, not to mention the use of negative space that separates it from everything else on that album.
And you guys need to know the difference between ATRL shade and SHADING.
Shading - a slight variation or difference of color or character.
Shading - a representation of different values of light and dark in pieces of art.
There is not of that in a typical Pink lyric. There is no grey, just black and white. No attempt at dimension. That's what makes her commendable, but ultimately shallow as a lyricist.
You sound confused.