[Mariano]

It's like asking whether McDonalds will have more profit in one day than the grocery shop nearby.

In the USA Birthday, WW It'd be close.

[MoodyBumps]

Assuming Gaga's video and image are on point, gaga should at least hit top ten in the US and be notable WW. The song is catchy, but so is birthday and Katy has in her favor that she's very popular right now WW. Guy may be a little too overly EDM for the GP, but that could make the single stand out? Either way, it looks like Katy has the odds in her favor.

[Gouldkaty]

Bday obvsly

[Slayonce]

Even though G.U.Y. is not a smash waiting to happen we have to keep in mind that Gaga was behind the scenes for a long time now and maybe she was preparing a huge campaign for it. If the video is actually good and not an Applause mess it can do well. Everything is in Katy's favor right now, so I'm going to say Birthday.

[cuneytb]

i am a Gaga stan and i see what the Katykats are doing
they remind me of the old us so i'm just saying nothing and leaving it here.

[Beyy]

Birthday.

G.U.Y. will probably peak somewhere top 40 and then few weeks later fade into irrelevancy.

[mike_10]

Birthday: US & WW

EDIT: wait, you mean Katy's birthday, right? the same answer i guess

[Katy V.!]

You're wrong for this Umich

All the "It'd be close WW" posts, though It's like August 12th never happened

[KillingYourCareer]

Originally posted by Rusty

#4 on the Hot 100 and coming for that 3x platinum = Bubbling Under Chart?

re-read my post ty

[DanceForYou]

The KatyKats are so desperate to feel superior. As usual, sales and chart positions are the only way in which they can do so.

I mean we all know the answer but if Gaga didn't have as messy of an era as she's had thus far it would be close. Birthday is overrated. It's cute but nothing amazing and will have less appeal to the public than Roar and DH. All I know is G.U.Y. ***** all over it quality wise so I'm fine with it.

[Katy V.!]

Originally posted by DanceForYou

The KatyKats are so desperate to feel superior. As usual, sales and chart positions are the only way in which they can do so.

I mean we all know the answer but if Gaga didn't have as messy of an era as she's had thus far it would be close. Birthday is overrated. It's cute but nothing amazing and will have less of an appeal than Roar and DH to the general public. All I know is G.U.Y. ***** all over it quality wise so I'm fine with it.

Sure honey

[clbylara]

at people voting G.U.Y.

[KillingYourCareer]

Originally posted by DanceForYou

The KatyKats are so desperate to feel superior. As usual, sales and chart positions are the only way in which they can do so.

I mean we all know the answer but if Gaga didn't have as messy of an era as she's had thus far it would be close. Birthday is overrated. It's cute but nothing amazing and will have less appeal to the public than Roar and DH. All I know is G.U.Y. ***** all over it quality wise so I'm fine with it.

whatever makes you sleep at night

[NewRihannaStan]

Birthday will be a huge summer smash ... It will be the next roar..

G.U.Y maybe be a big WW single

[DanceForYou]

Originally posted by Katy V.!

Sure honey

It does though. Either way it's just my opinion but it's hilarious Katy Kats of all people really try and come for anyone over quality of music. pure irony.

[MusicTalker]

G.U.Y. is a much better song, but Birthday will do better for obvious reasons.

[Gagamon]

Bday, but GUY should!

[umich]

Originally posted by ezra.jones

G.U.Y. WW and US.

G.U.Y. - US; Birthday - WW
ezra.jones, Losing my ground, Rihannamar, Steffani Gaga

[umich]

Statistically, GUY should do better than Birthday.

[Katy V.!]

Originally posted by DanceForYou

It does though. Either way it's just my opinion but it's hilarious Katy Kats of all people really try and come for anyone over quality of music. pure irony.

Yess Girl! Drag us with ARTPOP's quality, let it out!