Quote:
Originally posted by Underdogs
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and assume you're familiar with Pink's discography unlike others in this thread who are admittedly blind stanning.
You can't tell me that The Fame/ Monster + Born This Way showcases more variety than Can't Take Me Home, M!ssundaztood, Try This, I'm Not Dead, Funhouse & The Truth About Love.
Gaga has three releases so far. Pink, by her first three releases, had experimented more than most if not all of her contemporaries.
|
I actually do listen to P!nk's material - maybe not as often as you do, but I've heard all of her albums in full.
Compared to TF/TFM, BTW is noticeably different. Can you pin point a song like HML, BM, Hair, etc. on TF/TFM? Nope. BTW is more "adventurous" than anything P!nk has done, but that's not saying much itself.
And when I say P!nk's material has been consistent, it's not meant to literally mean they all sound exactly the same. Can't Take Me Home has more of a repressed pop sound compared to M!zzw/e else it is - < is more amplified, but not different as a whole. I'm Not Dead isn't that much different from the rest of her material - if anything, it seems like another copy of Try This with a more amplified pop song
. Funhouse isn't any different, and TTAL sounds like another M!ssw/e to me.
^ to sum that up: Some albums have a repressed pop-punk sound(CTMH, TT), while her others have more amplified pop sound(TTAL,M!ssw/e, Funhouse). That does not make it any more or any less punk-pop-ish when it comes to her music.
And the last part, I agree. Neither go out on a limb with their music, so I don't know why you and some other P!nk fans are acting like she completely changes her sound each time when she sticks to what she's familiar with, punk pop.