[Jared]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

You're asking why Pink is never in consideration for the Trinity. Titles like the Trinity are created by super devoted online stans who stalk the moves of pop stars. They live through those popstars. They get "life" from those popstars. And to them Pink is nothing but an afterthought. She's too tomboyish. She looks like she's gonna beat someone up.

Pink has her supporters, but they're not the super obsessed online fans who need to get their fill from a popstar. Concert-goers are not like that. If you go to a pop concert, there are a lot of casual fans. They're not crazy online stans like those who make up titles such as the Trinity. Gaga fans attend Britney concerts. Britney fans gave Gaga as warm a welcome in AC as they did Britney herself.

Pink has limited appeal to the "stan," and that's the person who excludes her from the Trinity when making the list.

YASSS Nicole.

[J a y]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

You're asking why Pink is never in consideration for the Trinity. Titles like the Trinity are created by super devoted online stans who stalk the moves of pop stars. They live through those popstars. They get "life" from those popstars. And to them

Pink is nothing but an afterthought. She's too tomboyish.
She looks like she's gonna beat someone up.

Pink has her supporters, but they're not the super obsessed online fans who need to get their fill from a popstar. Concert-goers are not like that. If you go to a pop concert, there are a lot of casual fans. They're not crazy online stans like those who make up titles such as the Trinity. Gaga fans attend Britney concerts. Britney fans gave Gaga as warm a welcome in AC as they did Britney herself.

Pink has no limited appeal to the "stan," and that's the person who excludes her from the Trinity.

I Lol'd.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Hooligan

Where'd you get Madonna? The only trinity I know of consists of Britney/Beyonce/Gaga.

"Queen of Pop," but even Beyonce has been considered for that.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Chemist

Actually The Immaculate Collection is Madge's bigger seller

wasn't that true blue

[MrCookiepants]

Originally posted by Hi.Def

Pink is a consistent seller when it comes to albums so it's no surprise that record has sold more than 4 & FF, especially since it came out during Holiday season of 2010. When did 4 & FF come owt again? Exactly.

And let's nawt since both albums are right on GHSF's heels. And don't even speak on single success because it took her how many years just to get 2 number ones?

Do nawt get Pink dragged in here tonight.

GH...SF has sold almost 3 million worldwide. Femme Fatale is never doing that and 4 will struggle to catch it.

But all I said was P!nk deserved more recognition. I don't think she should be a member of the trinity. And this is partly the reason why. Beyonce's stans would raise HELL if she were to be booted out.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Kisuke

lets get in to how each member of the trinty has peers legends and the ones that came after them praising them.

also non of the trinity members diss or shade people bigger then them ( like pink does)

and all 3 of them are what all the other female acts now a day are compared to they are the standard and the others just dont cut it

Right.

[Sunlighter]

Originally posted by Hi.Def

See what I mean? Adele and Katy would both look out of place in one of these. So would Pink.

[GeezusHaberdash]

But let's not drag P!nk too much in here, people
I would hate to call the P!nk P!lgrims in here.

[Cobato]

Originally posted by Hooligan

Where'd you get Madonna? The only trinity I know of consists of Britney/Beyonce/Gaga.

I've seen people put Madonna or some random artists in the "trinity" before. lol

[Orsay]

Current real world trinity - Gaga, Rihanna, and as much as it pains me to say it - Katy. Her single success has made her into an icon that's not to be reckoned with.

Current ATRL trinity - Britney, Beyonce, Gaga

Cultural era-defining pop star trinity - Madonna, Britney, Gaga

And that's that

P!nk is great but pretty much everything Nicole said about her is the truth, she just doesn't have that it factor that really rakes in the ****.

[Nicole]

Originally posted by BornThisWay

Current real world trinity - Gaga, Rihanna, and as much as it pains me to say it - Katy. Her single success has made her into an icon that's not to be reckoned with.

Current ATRL trinity - Britney, Beyonce, Gaga

Cultural era-defining pop star trinity - Madonna, Britney, Gaga

And that's that

P!nk is great but pretty much everything Nicole said about her is the truth, she just doesn't have that it factor that really rakes in the ****.

Much more succinct way of putting it.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

But let's not drag P!nk too much in here, people
I would hate to call the P!nk P!lgrims in here.

Her army of lesbian amazon women stans are not to be messed with

[Cap10Planet]

The Trinity - Beyonce, Britney & Pink

[Hooligan]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Her army of lesbian amazon women stans are not to be messed with

OOP

[Nicole]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Her army of lesbian amazon women stans are not to be messed with

Right, Pink is sort of like the Xena: Warrior Princess of pop who has a crazy devoted lesbian following b/c she's built and husky and looks like she could kick your ass.

[Chemist]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Her army of lesbian amazon women stans are not to be messed with

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

The Trinity - Beyonce, Britney & Pink

I actually love this commercial, they should re-make a commercial like this

The Bey/J.Lo was so ****ing fierce as well. Popstars nowadays only make ****** remixes without videos

[EarlyMorning]

As countless others have already said P!nk is an afterthought. When I think of P!nk I think of someone who complains about being ugly or an outcast in each one of her songs. It's nothing an average person would aspire to look up to which would create stans. Yeah, we'll shed a tear or two to her emotional songs maybe, but after that we move on to the next and forget about her.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Right, Pink is sort of like the Xena: Warrior Princess of pop who has a crazy devoted lesbian following b/c she's built and husky and looks like she could kick your ass.

cept Xena is a icon

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

I personally think there should be a new "Trinity" with GaGa leading and maybe Katy and Rihanna in it. I know I said it sounds ridiculous, but it's fairer.

NEVER Katy

Rihanna may be a bit of a stretch. She could definitely be in the "Fearsome Foursome" though

[EarlyMorning]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Her army of lesbian amazon women stans are not to be messed with

What happened to Fanoftalent? I would've expected him to be in here by the 2nd page posting the Glitter in the Air performances and her tour gross.