[MoodyBumps]

Originally posted by Ferst

More like #1 with the BBMA performance.

💃

[ToxicKat]

I'll be happy with this at least going platinum. Katy makes her flops look successful.. Who else tbh?

[MoodyBumps]

Originally posted by ToxicKat

I'll be happy with this at least going platinum. Katy makes her flops look successful.. Who else tbh?

No one. Top 20 hit = Katy flop hit

[Jackson]

TOY got platinum eventually so Id be surprised if this doesn't, considering its a bigger hit as of today.

[spree]

I think they need to release the Cash Cash remix either this coming Monday or the following Monday (at the latest). I want that Top 20 peak.

[heartbeats]

Originally posted by SupahBass05

Ezra's back, it seems.



So glad she's performing it at the BB awards. It'll be the deciding factor if the song becomes big tbh.

lmaooo

[Aurora]

What needs to happen is:

Billboard Music Awards live performance with elements of Cash Cash Remix.
2nd Music Video for "Birthday" released on YouTube immediately after performance, fun and sexy, only 3-4 minutes long.
Cash Cash Remix added to iTunes along with original in a dual single (so people don't have to buy just the PRISM version).

[ethan]

Originally posted by Sam Jay

What needs to happen is:

Billboard Music Awards live performance with elements of Cash Cash Remix.
2nd Music Video for "Birthday" released on YouTube immediately after performance, fun and sexy, only 3-4 minutes long.
Cash Cash Remix added to iTunes along with original in a dual single (so people don't have to buy just the PRISM version).

Some minor edits:

- 2nd music video uses Cash Cash Remix
- no dual single because it will affect the album version's charting (it's struggling enough)

[Sadie Saxton]

Originally posted by Grgech

I guess this is her downfall. Katy is nothing without her #1s. Even aggressive radio support (?!) can't save this.
Katy Perry is over.

Your reaching is worse than Solange tryna grab Jay-Z's wig.

[spree]

And a discount!

[TheSinglesClub]

Originally posted by Sam Jay

What needs to happen is:

Billboard Music Awards live performance with elements of Cash Cash Remix.
2nd Music Video for "Birthday" released on YouTube immediately after performance, fun and sexy, only 3-4 minutes long.
Cash Cash Remix added to iTunes along with original in a dual single (so people don't have to buy just the PRISM version).

Hope it comes true.

[Aurora]

Originally posted by ethan

Some minor edits:

- 2nd music video uses Cash Cash Remix
- no dual single because it will affect the album version's charting (it's struggling enough)

But then there would be two songs charting on BB, and that'd be a mess... and I doubt it'd go down well if the original didn't hit #1 and the remix did...

[MusicTalker]

50 Birthday

This is doing really awful. I think she should switch it out by June.

[ethan]

Originally posted by Sam Jay

But then there would be two songs charting on BB, and that'd be a mess... and I doubt it'd go down well if the original didn't hit #1 and the remix did...

I don't think so, none of the remixes from TD charted separately. It would all count as Birthday.

[spree]

Personally I don't even think the remix is that good, but It might sell 25-30k first week and make the song jump a few spots in the Hot 100.

[ethan]

idk why I'm talking about it, this song is a flop and Katy is over. She had a good run, it's a shame this era has been flop after flop after flop. The 1-2-3 punch of Walking on Air promo single (only #1 on iTunes for like a day), Unconditionally (Top 15), and now Birthday (Top 25) has just annihilated her and I know Capitol is pissed that she hasn't had a hit yet this era.

[TheSinglesClub]

Originally posted by ethan

idk why I'm talking about it, this song is a flop and Katy is over. She had a good run, it's a shame this era has been flop after flop after flop. The 1-2-3 punch of Walking on Air promo single (only #1 on iTunes for like a day), Unconditionally (Top 15), and now Birthday (Top 25) has just annihilated her and I know Capitol is pissed that she hasn't had a hit yet this era.

Who The Hell Are You?
Sis are you hacked?

Bday is an important single

[Aurora]

Originally posted by ethan

idk why I'm talking about it, this song is a flop and Katy is over. She had a good run, it's a shame this era has been flop after flop after flop. The 1-2-3 punch of Walking on Air promo single (only #1 on iTunes for like a day), Unconditionally (Top 15), and now Birthday (Top 25) has just annihilated her and I know Capitol is pissed that she hasn't had a hit yet this era.

I hope you're not being serious, because

Birthday will do fine. I only think the Cash Cash remix would chart differently due to Summertime Sadness charting differently for Lana... it's not just an added verse, it's a complete rearrangement of vocals and new production. So I don't think it would chart as the same song.

[ethan]

I was mocking the people in here that are trying to make it seem like this is a disaster.

Katy's had two of her biggest hits yet this era. Roar is just massive. Katy can survive an underperformance. Birthday will be fine.

[TheSinglesClub]

Originally posted by ethan

I was mocking the people in here that are trying to make it seem like this is a disaster.

Katy's had two of her biggest hits yet this era. Roar is just massive. Katy can survive an underperformance. Birthday will be fine.

Mess
There's so much hysteria in here that its difficult to differentiate what's real from pretend