[Lambo.]

Originally posted by KillaCham.

She gonna sound like **** live being afraid to go for the high notes or nah?

Probably.

[KyKy]

Originally posted by Lambo.

Then why bother posting?

Because it's a music forum where I have the freedom to post wherever I want and share my opinion on a song... Why bother responding if you don't like what I have to say

[KillaCham.]

Originally posted by GaSkrillex

Welp. This flopped.

I guess we got a new Queen of Rap.

You a bitch.

[Lambo.]

Originally posted by KyKy

Because it's a music forum where I have the freedom to post wherever I want and share my opinion on a song... Why bother responding if you don't like what I have to say

I just don't understand the mentality of going into a thread of a song you dislike.

But that's you, not me.

[KyKy]

Originally posted by Nnmmo

Or maybe you should just get the **** out of here since you don't even like the song

[Rian.]

Originally posted by KillaCham.

She gonna sound like **** live being afraid to go for the high notes or nah?

Yes. I don't wanna hear her sing it live tbh.

[X4vi]

Originally posted by Diar7

Actually you judge the genre of a song mostly by it's instrumental,

Yes.

Originally posted by Diar7

so WI has an EDM intrumental, but poppy vocals.

No. It not has an EDM instrumental, not entirely. It has a kinda basic dancey instrumental meant to have vocals on it to fill it.

Originally posted by Diar7

I guess we can call most of EDM songs pop since they have SUPER POPPY male/female vocals.

That's not true. A lot of EDM songs don't even have vocals.

Originally posted by Diar7

By your logic, Roar or Diamonds is in the same category as Whip It.

Not exactly in the same one. There are subgenres. But pretty close. More close to them than to EDM.

[JoeRobert]

Originally posted by Lambo.

Probably.

Originally posted by KillaCham.

You a bitch.

Originally posted by Nnmmo

Yes. I don't wanna hear her sing it live tbh.

I live for this thread!
Its doing well in the UK considering its her first OA/OS release (that I know of), and its not fallen like a brick in the US after the expected early peak so anyone ready to throw the word flop around needs to sit back and wait a little more than a week to judge this. It's by no means her best work but it's far from her worst...PTA.

[slw84]

Originally posted by Nnmmo

----------

The slw tease this post is giving me

My impact...I still love I still love I still love I still love I still luh uh uh

Originally posted by Lambo.

I just don't understand the mentality of going into a thread of a song you dislike.

But that's you, not me.

Reflect on em.

[Diar7]

Originally posted by X4vi

No. It not has an EDM instrumental, not entirely. It has a kinda basic dancey instrumental meant to have vocals on it to fill it.

But dance is closer to EDM than it is to pop. Plus it has a pure EDM breakdown.

Originally posted by X4vi

That's not true. A lot of EDM songs don't even have vocals.

Yeah, but some of them get vocal mixes. For example, Reload (Sebastian Ingrosso, Tommy Trash ft. John Martin). Don't You Worry Child has poppy vocals, but is still an EDM song.

Originally posted by X4vi

Not exactly in the same one. There are subgenres. But pretty close. More close to them than to EDM.

Actually I think Whip It is closer to EDM than to songs like Roar, Diamonds. But maybe that's just my opinion.
I like it how we kept it cute though.

[SebaMonster]

Whip It is Europop, but who cares?

[Diar7]

I got reported, smh. Can't deal with the **** that YOU started, then go report whoever replied to something YOU said first. Reporting is for pu$$ies who can't solve their problems.
Oh well, I still have a loooooong way to get banned.

[Diar7]

Originally posted by SebaMonster

Whip It is Europop, but who cares?

It was a cute discussion, no bad blood.
---------
And Europop is closer to EDM than it is to pop.
At least imo.

[Rian.]

Originally posted by SebaMonster

Whip It is Europop, but who cares?

You just came thru and slapped them both in the face with the truth

[Diar7]

This whole time I said that Whip It is EDM... Europop is pretty much EDM, so...

[Rian.]

Sistrens, this is a thread about Pills N Potions. So let's talk about that. Keep it cute

[Diar7]

This is pretty much our new Base.

[Rian.]

The topic is still 'Pills N Potions'.

It's still getting better and better every time I listen to it.

[KillaCham.]

Originally posted by Flare

The fact it's lasting near the top 10 without fully radio support yet.

This song will blow up once radio gets behind it. Then when the video comes, instant #1.

People keep jumping the gun calling this a flop smh. We Are The World didn't sell 20 million in less than a week either but it got there. And I feel like PnP will reach the renowned status of that song some day so the possibilities are endless.

[Diar7]

That doesn't mean we can't talk about other things related to Nicki though.
-------
Not me getting 2 WPs for one post... Still not banned though
-------
When do you guys think she's dropping the Myx commercial? Maybe she should drop it this week, then drop the video next week. Or maybe the commercial after like... a month, until the song takes off.