Fantasia was not the best winner that season -- Jennifer Hudson should have won.
Hopefully the finale is in between Jordin and Blake, there are so good at what they do -- entertaining us. I LOVE watching them perform. I don't get that kind of vibe from the supposedly better performers -- Lakisha and Melinda :-\
Katharine definitely should have won last season. It's a given that Taylor sucks major ass? No one can deny that is would definitely (and has been) be better that Kelly Clarkson won the American Idol season one competition. Look at her now (Never Again
, but regardless... she rocks).
Carrie Underwood was totally in her own league that season and is awesome.