| |
Tournament: ATRL's FIERCEST ARTIST Season 2 [AND THE WINNER IS....!!]
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 9/9/2010
Posts: 9,528
|
Rem is the King of starting tournaments but getting banned or dropping out before they end. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
I and the other judges will decide if we accept his request... Rem asked if he can send the entries fo the next challenges
btw, i got Guest Judge scores.. so results today 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/18/2010
Posts: 29,224
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Edi_Shak
I and the other judges will decide if we accept his request... Rem asked if he can send the entries fo the next challenges
btw, i got Guest Judge scores.. so results today |
FINALLY!!!! 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
Quote:
Originally posted by ExtraChapstick
Katy, Rihanna, Beyoncé, Fergie.
We need to spice this competition up, though. It's getting a little repetitive... 
|
So you'll have a surprise 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/17/2010
Posts: 10,073
|
Don't let him do that ****, if you do you need to give equal opportunity to FreeBitch.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/18/2010
Posts: 29,224
|
I'm not sure I understand 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
ATRL's Fiercest Artist Season 2
*Made by: Pedro*
CHALLENGE #4 - FIERCEST SINGLE COVER
I'll start by presenting to you the Guest Judge for this week:
One of the most Popular Latin Memebers of ATRL Sunderland 4ever!
and now...
RESULTS!
Quote:
First of all, I want to thank Edi for giving me the oportunity of being the judge of this round.
Okay, I have seen very interesting single covers. I am going to give a short comment to the three best single covers and the three single covers I considered the worst.
As some of you may know, if somebody  , I tend to say 'I like this' or 'I like that' a lot but I hardly ever give a 10 out of 10 for something ( since I can't give 9.5... ).
That being said, let's begin with the single covers I found good but not so outstanding.
4º Ivancastel - Christina Aguilera IMMUNE : 8 points (8.1)
5º Beyoncé_On_Top - Leona Lewis : 8 points
6º Ray Bass - Beyoncé : 8 points (7.8)
7º ExtraChapstick - Adele : 7 points (7.4)
8º fiercE - Pink : 7 points (7.2)
9º Solarie - Jennifer Lopez : 7 points (6.8)
10º Nait Phoenix - Janet Jackson : 6 points (6.3)
The people whose single covers have been ranked can stop holding their breath now!
Ok, it's time to see which covers made up the Top 3!
1º Rem - Fergie : 9 points (9.1)
Back in 2007/2008, for some reason I was truly in love with this whole Fergie vintage look, so that's a big plus for the single cover Rem chose. I really love how Fergie looks here. It is a very simple pose, and that absent stare makes her look incredibly sexy. Charlie approves it. 
2º LightandDarkness- Rihanna : 8 points (8.7)
I tend to prefer soft, sexy single caps, but wow, this would be a great exception to the rule! I mean, how cannot this picture be fierce? Her gaze to the camera is fantastic, along with what barbe-wire-like dress.
3º Mickey - Björk : 8 points (8.4)
What I liked here the most was its simplicity. No colored make up, no fancy clothes. And the fact that is Bjork, a person who is usually known for her odd look, containing very strange clothes (which I sometimes like :P), actually makes me more impressed about the simplicity of this single cover.
Down to the three single covers I liked the least.
11º XtremeSteel - Katy Perry : 6 points (6.2)
I found this single cover very gagaish. It is not that I don't like Lady Gaga style, but I feel like it wasn't the best single cover option for Katy Perry. And also, I didn't like that E.T. font in the front of the single cover.
12º Xenen - Madonna : 5 points
I have seen many great fierce pictures of Madonna, but I just didn't see the fierceness on this one. I would have been a better single cover if it hadn't had that blue/back part below.
13º Venus - Khia : 4 points
I'm sorry but I didn't find something here that actually caused me an impact. She seems pretty awkward on the picture and I also didn't like that sort of magenta circle in the middle.
Well, that's it! I hope nobody took my comments so personally. Remember this is a competition, so somebody has to be first and somebody has to be last.
I wish the best of luck to all of the contestants. 
|
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RESTANT SCORES:
Venus - Khia
Edi_Shak: 6
Not so Fierce but i like the cover. Her outfit looks great and the colors on it
Regina George: 8
You are definitely the Drake Bell of this season  I love that she's comfortable with her body, the only thing that I don't like it's the chair and the effect
SIMon1120: 7
The cover looks misleading with the song title "Spend It On Me". The color, the font, the size ratio need to be improved for a fierce cover. What I found fierce is her standing against herself and that's it.
Pedro: 6
LOL, she looks a little like a prostitute and too ****ty, her outfit is fierce though, but this at least for me is not fierce. Perhaps you’re worst challenge so far.
Votes: 1
TOTAL: 32
Mickey - Björk
Edi_Shak: 5
I'm not into the font. I expected so much more this challenge 
Regina George: 7
She looks like Queen Amidala, and Queen Amidala is fierce  and I love the futuristic and cute font
SIMon1120: 6
The spiritual & marvelous movement express her fierceness, but the other main factors like face, background, font degrade the cover.
Pedro: 6.5
Well This Is actually fierce, BUT, not that fierce you know? I don’t know much about her but I think there’s probably better, judging that Bjork is very extravagant and stuff. Anyway, not terrible
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 32.5
Nait Phoenix - Janet Jackson
Edi_Shak: 5
I don't see any fierceness in this cover. The font saves it
Regina George: 0
I hate everything! You're making fun of the Legendary Miss Jackson, I want you out! Everything is a mess! Her outfit, the necklaces makes her look like a dog, her hair! 
SIMon1120: 5
She can be simply fierce in a classic way, but not so modern. Her standing & a little bit of her clothes might be called fierce but still corny.
Pedro: 6
If this time Regina says “This is about being fierce not ****” I’d have to agree. It’s not JUST about how naked you are, you know, here she looks a little like a ***** in the street waiting for a guy to go pay her to do him favors I am disappointed Nait! The best luck for the next round.
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 22
XtremeSteel - Katy Perry
Edi_Shak: 8
The colors used on the cover are perfect good job 
Regina George: 8
I can't see her outfit, but I love her makeup, ring and the font it's perfect!
SIMon1120: 7
Katy could have made much more fierce cover with the song "E.T", the only thing fierce here is her effective eye toward the viewers that implies her extraterrestrial & supernatural touch, but the rest of the cover doesn't do too much
Pedro: 8
Comment: LOVE IT! Perfect choice, the darkness attached to this picture makes it even fiercer! I love the pose, the eye make up, the facial expression and the outfit looks fierce! Good job!
Votes: 3
TOTAL: 40
LightandDarkness- Rihanna
Edi_Shak: 10
YEAH BABY! Rihanna is doing A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!! Fierceness from the princess of Illuminati
Regina George: 9
Finally!  It's fierce but scary, I love the big R and the bloody Russian Roulette the only thing that I don't like is her hair
SIMon1120: 9
Dark & fierce, the album theme helps her a lot, the cover shows the respectful self-esteem & the pride of the daughter of "R" with the fierce hair & the barbed wire winding her
Pedro: 9.5
Weird how this song is SO not fierce but its cover really is! This was my favorite phase from Rihanna, she was SO fierce. Love the things she has in her body, covering her boobs, the eye accessory, the pose, face, everything! Awesome job! Hopefully there isn’t a certain someone who is going to rate her low due to personal preferences.
Votes: 4
TOTAL: 49.5
Ivancastel - Christina Aguilera
Edi_Shak: 8
The single might flopped but this cover is Fierce!:
Regina George: 4
What is this mess Ivansito? Where were you when she released all her singles from B2B?  Sorry but everything is a mess!
SIMon1120: 7
The costume & the background stand for fierceness, but Christina herself doesn't pose right with the weakened & horny face, the monster tail & bloody font are saying that she will be molested uncontrollably
Pedro: 7
I have never been a big fan of this photo, her boobs look so ew! Anyway, I gotta give you some points because in fact it’s fierce, I gotta let my personal taste out.
Votes: 2
TOTAL: 36
fiercE - Pink
Edi_Shak: 7
Again, the attitude is fierce.. I can't saiy the same for the whole cover
Regina George: 6
Another mess! The only good thing that I can say is that I like her jacket and her body looks great!
SIMon1120: 6
Half ****ty sexy & half fierce, she maybe standing fierce but it doesnot expose much how she can be fierce with the scene, except she can use her dirty "U + Ur Hand"
Pedro: 8
This is the second time you use an U+Ur Hand picture and I must say I never noticed how fierce that video is! This is a nice picture, she looks fierce and all dirty, but not your best job.
Votes: 2
TOTAL: 36
Ray Bass - Beyoncé
Edi_Shak: 9
Beyonce is finally here the make up is soooo fierce
Regina George: 9
You are definitely on my top three! I love her makeup, her outfit and her glove are fierce! The only thing that I don't like it's her big earring
SIMon1120: 7
The font, the costume, and the look all direct toward fierceness, challenging the viewers, even though the song title "Video Phone" has nothing to do with the cover
Pedro: 10
FINALLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yes Yes Yes!!! This is what I’m talking about, the (next to Britney and Shakira) Queen of fierceness is HERE! Couldn’t be more proud of your choice.
Votes: 3
TOTAL: 46
Xenen - Madonna
Edi_Shak: 3
I don't see any kind of fierceness in the cover.. 
Regina George: 5
It's a very simple single cover, there's nothing fierce
SIMon1120: 1
Can anyone find the fierceness in this cover?  the cover even goes against what we call fierce or maybe freakiness
Pedro: 4.5
Don’t like it, and don’t even find it fierce, sad to say this. Oh well, let’s hope next challenge you do better, she just looks silly here a little distracted you know.
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 18.5
ExtraChapstick - Adele
Edi_Shak: 6
The cover can really transmit a strong feeling  not fierce in full but it's a beautiful and simple cover
Regina George: 6
Quote:
Originally posted by ExtraChapstick
Unfortunately, I don't have many choices here with Adele, but I can assure you I've picked the FIERCEST of all her single covers, and have therefore done my best... That's all I can do. 
|
I totally disagree with this statement Mr. ExtraChapstick, for me you could win this, because she looks beautiful, perfect makeup, her hair perfect like always, but the single cover that you send is simple, there's nothing fierce
SIMon1120: 8
Definitely the fierceness is hiding inside the cover with the editing around her head, it is fierce but not the best
Pedro: 5
Sorry Extra, this is not fierce, you’ve been doing good and yourself said she does not have any fierce cover, oh well could be worse!
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 32
Solarie - Jennifer Lopez
Edi_Shak: 6
A step back in this challenge.. But next round don't do the same
Regina George: 4
The only thing that I can say about this single cover is that it looks like a mediocre cover of Maxim
SIMon1120: 4
[i]The pose looks fierce, but her face, the appearance as well as the font are rather to contest for sexy single cover[i]
Pedro: 7.5
It’s okay you know, you are Beyoncé case, you could do so much better but you haven’t =(, this is an OKAY entry, for someone like Jennifer, I must admit I don’t know much about her singles, but I am pretty sure there are better.
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 28.5
Beyoncé_On_Top - Leona Lewis
Edi_Shak: 6
Too simple and a don't like how she looks 
Regina George: 5
It's very simple, there's something missing, maybe another pose? color? I still don't know
SIMon1120: 7
Approved for the fierce theme, but it has something to do with her facial expression & the camera angle
Pedro: 9
I love this! You’re doing such a great job, must be because you’re a Beyoncé fan! Simple but so fierce, her pose and her facial expression says it all! Great Job!
Votes: 0
TOTAL: 35
Rem - Fergie IMMUNE
Edi_Shak: 7
Lovely cover The outfit it's so cute. But it's not fierce
Regina George: 10
I love that fact that you are immune, you don't have to worry about what1 it's your score in this round and you send this single cover! I love EVERYTHING! If this were in real life I would be standing and clapping because It's AMA-ZAYN!
SIMon1120: 4
 this is being cute, not even fierce, but at least some pts for the costumes & Fergie's attitude
Pedro: 7
Comment: I see we have an average entry for Fergie this time! Her facil expression goes into a more silly expression than fierce, her outfit is also very glamorous. I can’t give you as much points as I would like to.
Votes: 1
TOTAL: 38
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RANKING FOR THIS CHALLENGE:
1. LightandDarkness- Rihanna IMMUNE
2. Ray Bass - Beyoncé
3. XtremeSteel - Katy Perry
4. Rem - Fergie
5. fiercE - Pink
6. Ivancastel - Christina Aguilera
7. Beyoncé On Top - Leona Lewis
8. ExtraChapstick - Adele
9. Mickey - Bjork
10. Venus - Khia
11. Solarie - Jennifer Lopez
12. Nait Phoenix - Janet Jackson
13. Xenen - Madonna EMILINATED
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL RANKING:
1. Remeese - Fergie - 171 points (=)
2. LightandDarkness- Rihanna - 156 points (+5) ||| IMMUNE NEXT ROUND |||
3. Beyoncé_On_Top - Leona Lewis - 155 points (-1)
4. Ivancastel - Christina Aguilera - 154.5 points (=)
5. ExtraChapstick - Adele - 151 points (-2)
6. XtremeSteel - Katy Perry - 151 points (=)
7. Ray Bass - Beyoncé - 151 points (+2)
8. Solarie - Jennifer Lopez - 146.5 points (-1)
9. fiercE - Pink - 133 points (+1)
10. Xenen - Madonna - 125 points (-2) ELIMINATED
11. Mickey - Bjork - 123.5 points (+1)
12. Venus - Khia - 119.5 points (+1)
13. Nait Phoenix - Janet Jackson - 116 points (-1)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Nait Phoenix
I'm not sure I understand |
anonymously write what you want.. About the Judges, contestans, entries, etc
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/18/2010
Posts: 29,224
|
Anonymously my ass! I want to tell it to their face! 
JK... but I do want to say that I'm not trying to make Janet out to be a joke. I really have no clear conception about how an artist is to look fierce, and having THREE straight challenge about how fierce the artist can LOOK I'm kinda not getting any better at it. Plus, it's not helping when the comments either seem biased or aren't constructive, but I'm just probably being bitchy about that. I'm not sure if I could've chosen another cover because I have no clear idea on what the judges look for when it comes to their idea on fierce. Again, don't want to sound preachy or bitchy, 'cause I still appreciate any input on what I chose. Thanks.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/3/2006
Posts: 51,724
|
-_- Madonna eliminated? those representatives are a mess.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/3/2009
Posts: 35,844
|
Yay! a thread title with my name on it... or at least the most memorable part.
I wanted to post something about Rem but I waited after to Edi to first post the results. It would have been my first post here and... I probably would have ruined the anonymous thing.
How could you get banned after I gave you the highest score Rem??!!! Still, your single cover reminded me some good times from 2007/2008, which I appreciate.
Congrats to the Top 12!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/20/2010
Posts: 12,356
|
That Madonna picture was a mess. Not trying to be mean, but yikes.... Madonna is the epitome of fierce, especially during her prime. That picture didn't do Madonna any justice nor did it exude any fierceness. I feel the same with Janet Jackson cover. Anyways, congrats to all the people that made it to the next round.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/20/2011
Posts: 3,915
|
Eliminated 
Good luck to the other contestants.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/17/2010
Posts: 10,073
|
Regina, I'm pretty sure that's not a chair
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/21/2011
Posts: 7,654
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Beyoncé on Top
|
i know but he's not a contestant  only contestants can vote
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/21/2011
Posts: 7,654
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Edi_Shak
i know but he's not a contestant only contestants can vote |
OK. I didn't know that. Thanks for informing me. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/16/2009
Posts: 7,283
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
