|
Tournament: ATRL's Holy Trinity: Renewal ▲
Member Since: 9/15/2012
Posts: 22,487
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Dessy Fenix
Mess I thought my song & number was fairly obvious with Mariah Carey and Without You.
It's surely related to the entries in your trinity.
|
Believe it or not the hints have nothing to do with your entries!
Also if Huga submits within like the next two hours I'll do results before I leave so
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/12/2012
Posts: 26,389
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
Believe it or not the hints have nothing to do with your entries!
Also if Huga submits within like the next two hours I'll do results before I leave so
|
Well ****, no walk for me then.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/15/2012
Posts: 22,487
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Hugamari
Well ****, no walk for me then.
|
lkdjsalsf;;; no take a walk if you want.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 23,857
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
Believe it or not the hints have nothing to do with your entries!
|
Well **** I looked too deep
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/5/2014
Posts: 29,111
|
Welp, I tried to figure out the hints and I came up with nothing.
I thought maybe the letter they started with had to do with our user name or the letter we chose, but idk.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/12/2012
Posts: 26,389
|
Adam doesn't even send us reminder PMs to send our judgments in anymore. I guess he knows we're on it.
One of y'all came from NOWHERE and scalped me, by the way. You'll know who you are from the comments.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/15/2012
Posts: 22,487
|
Alright, the data is compiled! When should I start results?
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 10,195
|
Nows good.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 15,103
|
as soon as possible
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 23,857
|
Ready
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 26,488
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
Alright, the data is compiled! When should I start results?
|
now
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/15/2012
Posts: 22,487
|
sakldfjkalsdfjkal;; okay now I guess.
The
A R T
Trinity
Quote:
Originally posted by Hugamari
pow - Well...I can't tell you how you percieved your piece was wrong. I just don't think you did all that good of a job convincing me to agree. I feel like you kinda rushed this one.
Kxvk - I liked the reasoning behind your song choices, and as usual, you have a way of choosing songs I know only you could. That's something I really appreciate about your entries. I do think this was a bit forward in how you approach the piece, but that's not to say it isn't still solid.
DripDrip - Well that's definitely a way to think of it. She's FAKE. Everything about her is FAKE. But seriously, the choice in the first song was really interesting to me, but it fell off at the second one. I wish your trinity had more songs like the first one because it seemed to be an odd yet fitting choice.
theycallmemaraj - Of all the rounds to do a Me trinity part 2 in, I don't think this one was a particularly good choice. I felt like the art piece was a foot note in this entry.
A Bomb - Your entries are always distnctively you regardless of what approach you take. ♥ Besides for your reasoning, which you do a great job at convincing me on, I think you had good choices to begin with. I also love how the font is your handwriting. Would've been better in the "Me" trinity, but too little too late I suppose!
Pecintah Mariah - HELP. These images have me YELPING. They're gonna be the next hit reaction pics tbh! Anyway, although I can see what you were getting at, I think leaving things unsaid wasn't the best way to approach this entry.
Fidel - What the ****. This entry is so sappy and corny but it's adorable and I love it a lot. It's not the most out-there approach to the challenge, but idk, I think you just executed your idea well.
Speezy - My favorite picture this round...this entry, however, felt very put together at the last minute. There was a lot you could have done with it, but didn't. Kinda disappointed.
Clueless - Oh. Well, I get you didn't have much to work with here, but I felt this was more of a lesson on colors than an interpretation of an art piece. Personally, I would've went with something like a descent into madness, or a clash between two (or more) forces.
Dessy Fenix - Spelling mistakes aside, I love the fairy-tale idea from this picture. You interpreted the picture in such a unique way, which I love! Not entirely sure on how much I agree with the song choices, but good entry nevertheless!
Bloomers - WTF That's so creative. I'm kinda obsessed with this. Loved the entry! Well done. I don't have anything to critique you on, really.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Navyofbadgals
Girlicious - You also said it yourself, but yeah next time include a picture because I have never seen your artwork before. Anyways, I think you did good. You made an entry that made sense, I wish it was a bit more about the artwork instead of the imaginative relationship. Love the first 2 song choices, Just Askin' is okay to end your story but I don't see the connection with the artwork.
DevonDreams - You analyzed the meaning of this painting very well, and it's smart to not only include the mother-child relationship but also the chaos. Love this approach, a bit simplistic tho. So it's adequate, but I'm hoping you bring us a bit more next round
Chill Bill - with this story I thought you captured the girl in the painting in perfectly. I had to read it multiple times to understand that you were going for this direction, but yeah. Try to avoid using a story format every round tho, it fits with this challenge so it's fine, but don't do it when it's not needed in later challenges.
Mirrorwriting - The last song was so indie it didn't even have 1000 views
I think you really captured the girl's sadness and other elements like the fish.. but this was kind of hard to understand (just like the painting hihi). I had to read it over and over a few times until I got your point. But this was strong and you got the essence of the painting across.
JPOW - idk why but I cackled at the first song when the woman started singing
I really like this, you did it smart, because honestly if you started to do songs about leaves and water drops.. yeah
I think Carribean Blue is by far your best choice and it kinds of obliterates the other two. This song was enough and the other songs feel like they are just there to fulfill the task of choosing 3 songs. But still... smart approach
kvxk - This is like the first one to really analyze every aspect of the artwork
mess @ that song having 14 views tho you uploaded it, right?
Also the second song itself is a mess I think the choice of it is clever tho.
The third song having 5 views coming for that VEVO record!
But you analyzed every important aspect of the artwork, I wish you would've gotten a bit deeper, but this is good and you got the most important things across.
DripDrip - I had to stop your song after the first minute because I couldn't handle it anymore. It did got your point across and I think it's smart that you really went in the deep with this painting, also like how you didn't do a comic book approach. You analyzed this painting well.
theycallmemaraj - You could've went even deeper with this. Floating and feeling free are things that definitely fit the artwork, but they aren't really exciting. I also don't like your second song choice, it's a bit of a stretch. Also Higher is about a breakup, but I like your interpretation of it
A Bomb - I almost think they should give you an extra task, because you are too good now
You captured the essence of the painting, you went into the 'deep' with it and you had good song choices. A very well made trinity.
Pecinta Mariah - I like how you analyzed every body and had a song for all of them, smart approach. Don't know if I'm a big fan of the first song choice, and without explanation that falls flat. I get what you wanted to accomplish with the other songs tho.
Fidel - You also had a relationship approach, just like Girlicious. I think you chose cute songs that represent the story well, I hoped you got into the painting a bit more, but I really like that you switched up your entry, compared to the previous rounds.
Speezy - One Step At A Time, is about not rushing things, but I don't see the link with working hard. I also think the Kelly Clarkson song is a bit out of place here. Even tho the Jordin song doesn't feel about working hard, I do think that it fits with your artwork. This feels more like a duo + one song, then a trinity somehow.
Clueless - You did good, you analyzed the painting well. I wish you could've went even deeper, but this is adequate.
Dessy Fenix - you made me cackle but this is a bit of a mess. Idk if that's a good or bad thing in this case, but at least you were original and unique
but still really conflicted about this, I mean that thing turning back into a prince, the girl falling for that monster
Bloomers - You're trinity really became part of this artwork. This was really clever and creative. love this.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Staryu
Disclaimer: I'm taking vicodin b/c I have a tooth infection and can't sleep or eat solid foods, sorry if I'm a mess
Girlicious - Your entry was solid, a little overdone, egg joke idk, I liked the FKA twiggy twigz song choice... your explanations were long, maybe a little reachy for Iggy
DevonDreams - I thought your interpretation was really lovely, the story and songs were good mates, like the robotic insect things, but I felt you could have explained your song choices more.
Chill Bill - Your story was interesting, I feel it fit your painting well, she looks like a tough lil prostitute to me
Mirrorwriting - Loved your song choices, they really fit the artwork and gave your entry the perfect tone/vibe or whatever, I feel all your entries have like a sophisticated air about them
jpow - yas Enya and Enigma, love the song choices, simple but good entry, you're very consistent so far
Kxvk - I liked the Rainbow song, it was cute, even though I don't understand it, I saw colours. I respect you keep choosing your favorite genre of music, but maybe try to expand your horizons or whatever next round idk don't let yourself be predictable
DripDrip - Your entry was really all connected well, I thought your three songs went together with your art and you explained it very well
theycallmemaraj - I think you did your best this round, the songs fit the picture, you gave good personal reasons
A Bomb - Loved the Kylie Jenner commentary and the look/layout of your entry, it's very heavenly, which is where Selena is You would be higher but I feel awkward ranking you high when your entry has the same explanation twice for two different songs, I know its a mistake but yeah don't come for me like last week
Pecinta Mariah - Your entry made me laugh, idk if it was supposed to but I can't with those statues faces above the songs
Fidel - Aw a Carpenters song idk I don't have much to say, your entry is cute
Speezy - omg the Jordin song was perfect for your painting I don't get how 'Breakin' down the walls, Do the impossible' really fit the painting though.
Clueless - I love how your interpreted the art and did your layout, it was clever, but it did make me think of Germany's flag
Dessy Fenix - The picture you have like really creeped me out, I can't connect that Mariah song to it at all the rest was good though, idk what you quoted at the start but it described the art well
Bloomers - omg I love things represented like words cutout from other things, like a serial killer or kidnapper. Anyway your song choices were flawless, they went well with your art
|
I'll try to format the results quickly but it takes a while so give me a sec. For now, read through the judging!
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 26,488
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Navyofbadgals
JPOW - idk why but I cackled at the first song when the woman started singing
I really like this, you did it smart, because honestly if you started to do songs about leaves and water drops.. yeah
I think Carribean Blue is by far your best choice and it kinds of obliterates the other two. This song was enough and the other songs feel like they are just there to fulfill the task of choosing 3 songs. But still... smart approach
|
The two first songs were the two that I really felt strongly about and Caribbean Blue was there so I could have three songs I wanted Orinoco Flow but it has the word "never" in it's lyrics
Such a reverse warholian experience.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 23,857
|
Oh god the mixed reception
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 10,195
|
2/3 songs I uploaded myself as the full ones are nowhere online.
Thanks for the feedback though guys!
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/12/2012
Posts: 26,389
|
RIP, I could've sworn I copied everything. Do you want me to post my full comments myself, @Adam, or should I send them to you?
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/12/2012
Posts: 26,389
|
I'm gonna post myself.
Quote:
Girlicious - I'm not sure how seriously the reasonings behind your song choices were supposed to be, but I enjoyed them regardless. An enjoyable entry is, for the most pat, a good entry, so that's a plus! I would've liked to have your piece included in the entry, but it's nothing major.
DevonDreams - LOVE how you took the picture and gave it a flavor most may not have thought of. You decided to go deeper than what was at the surface and I think that's the best way to tackle this round.
Chill Bill - What a great story you crafted around the painting. I was eager to keep on reading the whole time, which is important since I have a lot of these entries to go through. You also still have a way of picking songs that don't feel forced at all. Brilliant effort all around, once again!
Mirrorwriting - You could've seperated it into 3 pieces, although splitting it into 4 may have been part of the aesthetic idk. Anyway, although I appreciate minimalist approaches to entries, and I particularly enjoyed the way you wrote in this entry, I felt like a piece was missing to truly complete this entry; it was like this was a draft or something.
jpow - Well...I can't tell you how you percieved your piece was wrong. I just don't think you did all that good of a job convincing me to agree. I feel like you kinda rushed this one.
Kxvk - I liked the reasoning behind your song choices, and as usual, you have a way of choosing songs I know only you could. That's something I really appreciate about your entries. I do think this was a bit forward in how you approach the piece, but that's not to say it isn't still solid.
DripDrip - Well that's definitely a way to think of it. She's FAKE. Everything about her is FAKE. But seriously, the choice in the first song was really interesting to me, but it fell off at the second one. I wish your trinity had more songs like the first one because it seemed to be an odd yet fitting choice.
theycallmemaraj - Of all the rounds to do a Me trinity part 2 in, I don't think this one was a particularly good choice. I felt like the art piece was a foot note in this entry.
A Bomb - Your entries are always distnctively you regardless of what approach you take. ♥ Besides for your reasoning, which you do a great job at convincing me on, I think you had good choices to begin with. I also love how the font is your handwriting. Would've been better in the "Me" trinity, but too little too late I suppose!
Pecintah Mariah - HELP. These images have me YELPING. They're gonna be the next hit reaction pics tbh! Anyway, although I can see what you were getting at, I think leaving things unsaid wasn't the best way to approach this entry.
Fidel - What the ****. This entry is so sappy and corny but it's adorable and I love it a lot. It's not the most out-there approach to the challenge, but idk, I think you just executed your idea well.
Speezy - My favorite picture this round...this entry, however, felt very put together at the last minute. There was a lot you could have done with it, but didn't. Kinda disappointed.
Clueless - Oh. Well, I get you didn't have much to work with here, but I felt this was more of a lesson on colors than an interpretation of an art piece. Personally, I would've went with something like a descent into madness, or a clash between two (or more) forces.
Dessy Fenix - Spelling mistakes aside, I love the fairy-tale idea from this picture. You interpreted the picture in such a unique way, which I love! Not entirely sure on how much I agree with the song choices, but good entry nevertheless!
Bloomers - WTF That's so creative. I'm kinda obsessed with this. Loved the entry! Well done. I don't have anything to critique you on, really.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 26,488
|
Let me also say, the first song I submitted "Sweet Lullaby" by Deep Forest is one of my all time favorite songs and I'm so happy I got to submit it somewhere finally. When I was 18 or 19 and I used to smoke, I'd put on the Deep Forest album and feel like I was transported to the Blue Rain concert from That's So Raven
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 15,103
|
my rankings are going to differ so much from the other judges
I think and hope we have the same #1 tho
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 15,103
|
Quote:
Originally posted by jpow
The two first songs were the two that I really felt strongly about and Caribbean Blue was there so I could have three songs I wanted Orinoco Flow but it has the word "never" in it's lyrics
Such a reverse warholian experience.
|
I loved that song because it also connected with the painting somehow for me. The other 2 not so much.
But your artpop could mean anything!
|
|
|
|
|