This scene makes so little sense, it's the only reason I still don't want to believe Wren is A despite all the clues pointing at him. It fits the part that Mona and Charles were playing together but it also implies that there is someone above Wren
Another thing. How old do these boys look? They look like 3 and 4 year old boys to me. They have to be 7 and 8 year old in order for that baby to be Alison. We already know by now that Jason is 7 years older (Jason's prom was 7 years ago) than Alison and Charles 8 years older (He is 15 months older than Jason). While Bethany is 3/4 years older than Alison.
So if Jason and Charles really are 3 and 4 year old in that picture, that would mean Bethany is the sister Charles is kissing and not Alison. This also confirms that it's impossible for Bethany to be Charles twin since Charles is 4 years older than Bethany. But he could as well be her older brother.
It makes sense. If Bethany's their sister
Quote:
Originally posted by Nialler
the dancing girl was definitely young Spencer in Radley and she knew Charles for sure, that's why he felt familiar
This is so true, Spencer is a psycho, I know it.
Quote:
Originally posted by waryofothers
No matter who A is, I love the ATRL PLL family. Y'all make this show even better!
So I have no idea who A is. All those new characters showing up, they make no sense at all
I swear, they bring them just to make us even more confused
CeCe + Wren would be a reasonable A-duo. I mean, Wren is similar age as Charles and CeCe may be Red Coat. I'm still not sure what CeCe has to do with all this.
Bethany being a DiLaurentis? Why's everyone in their family mentally unstable?
Looks like Spencer, Lesley, Bethany and Charles were all at Radley. So many freaks in one town
So, here are all the people who were in Ali's backyard that night:
Charles
Bethany
CeCe
Mrs. DiLaurentis
Jason
Mr. Montgomery
Ian
Melissa
Garrett
Jenna
Ezra
Toby
Mona (I'm assuming she took that pic of Ali)
Wilden (Jenna said Garrett told her that he was there as well)
Can Wren be "A" though? I mean, wasn't he dating Melissa? Hastings family lives next to DiLaurentis family. How could Alison's parents never saw Wren?
I think they moved after Alison's been gone...that's when Wren comes back to Rosewood
Mrs D only appeard in season 2 for that fashion show I think, and they moved back in season 4
I never really post, I don't even know why.
But I've been on Wren is A train since season 1.
One big clue that I barely see in these theories is the one Ms. Grunwald gave us, when we were made to believe Ezra was A. She told the girls "One of you has been touched by the one Alison fears the most."
I feel like this could be referring to A/Charles/Wren.
I also really do think Cece has to be involved somehow.
I've come to the conclusion there is nothing shady about Sara. I think she's honestly who she says she is...it's been too many episodes in a row now for her to be involved.
I'm going to be really sad if we never get our twins.
Is it me or does the promo for next week look like Mona and Alison are in the same car??
I loved scenes between Hanna and Caleb in this episode.
Spencer and Dean need to get together, Toby needs to die.
Spoilers were true about this episode, right ?
No, they weren't. There was no scene of Dean eating the pot brownies and no scene of the liars being attacked by A while Lesli was distracted. The only thing he got right was Emily and Sara kissing, but everyone saw that coming tbh.
Btw, I seriously don't understand why they don't have Mona appear in more scenes/episodes. She's one of the more interesting characters on the show and is one of the few that has a brain.
I've come to the conclusion there is nothing shady about Sara. I think she's honestly who she says she is...it's been too many episodes in a row now for her to be involved.
I'm going to be really sad if we never get our twins.
Is it me or does the promo for next week look like Mona and Alison are in the same car??
Yeah, there will be a Mona and Alison scene next week. I'm assuming it's the scene where they'll at least 'kind of' make up and start working together, which looks very exciting! Now all we need is a Melissa and Ali scene.
No, they weren't. There was no scene of Dean eating the pot brownies and no scene of the liars being attacked by A while Lesli was distracted. The only thing he got right was Emily and Sara kissing, but everyone saw that coming tbh.
Btw, I seriously don't understand why they don't have Mona appear in more scenes/episodes. She's one of the more interesting characters on the show and is one of the few that has a brain.
Hmm ok
But it looks like they're being attacked by A in the next episode, maybe the person who spilled those spoilers mixed episodes
Y'all make this show even better!
I literally was texting my friends throughout the episode until the last 5 minutes. 
****ing hate Marlene.