[RihRihGirrrl]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Was I the only one underwhelmed by Melanie or am I just hard to please?

she started out as my fave but I've been underwhelmed by her performances the last two weeks...she seems to have have the judges wrapped around her fingers but i'm just not feelin it

[Benzene]

Originally posted by Superbitch

Melanie sounded like Stacey tonight and NO that's not a good thing.

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Was I the only one underwhelmed by Melanie or am I just hard to please?

You are not alone.

I've never been a fan of Melanie, honestly. I can't remember a single one of performances an hour later. ****, even the janitor had a memorable performance with "Young Homie."

[Superbitch]

Melanie is.the.new Stacy Francis ...

[IWasHere]

Originally posted by stronger23

because tyson is gay....

Originally posted by Superbitch

Melanie is.the.new Stacy Francis ...

I was just about to say this....

[Airhead]

The only performance I enjoyed was Astros...

Drew bored me to tears. Same ****, different week..
Chris is so handsome, but he needs to go. He sucks.

[Airhead]

And Melanie is FAKE!

[cypriotpcdfan]

DEATH at all of your comments on Nicole. She spilled the true tea tonight.

-Simon doesnt take risk with his contestants and he always plays it safe
-SImon doesnt know how hard it is to dance your ass of and be able to sound AT LEAST decent. Lets not forget Marcus is still a contestant. His performance was equally good to performances by established artists.
-Drew. BEEN THERE. DONE THAT! She was definitely right with Drew.
-Melanie had the best performance of the night.

I dont know why y'all are coming for Nicole every night.

[henrytots]

Originally posted by cypriotpcdfan

DEATH at all of your comments on Nicole. She spilled the true tea tonight.

-Simon doesnt take risk with his contestants and he always plays it safe
-SImon doesnt know how hard it is to dance your ass of and be able to sound AT LEAST decent. Lets not forget Marcus is still a contestant. His performance was equally good to performances by established artists.
-Drew. BEEN THERE. DONE THAT! She was definitely right with Drew.
-Melanie had the best performance of the night.

I dont know why y'all are coming for Nicole every night.

notice theyre the same people over and over? especially that one cheryl fan.

[Airhead]

Originally posted by cypriotpcdfan

DEATH at all of your comments on Nicole. She spilled the true tea tonight.

-Simon doesnt take risk with his contestants and he always plays it safe
-SImon doesnt know how hard it is to dance your ass of and be able to sound AT LEAST decent. Lets not forget Marcus is still a contestant. His performance was equally good to performances by established artists.
-Drew. BEEN THERE. DONE THAT! She was definitely right with Drew.
-Melanie had the best performance of the night.

I dont know why y'all are coming for Nicole every night.

Nicole told NO lies...

[TheDjole]

Originally posted by cypriotpcdfan

DEATH at all of your comments on Nicole. She spilled the true tea tonight.

-Simon doesnt take risk with his contestants and he always plays it safe
-SImon doesnt know how hard it is to dance your ass of and be able to sound AT LEAST decent. Lets not forget Marcus is still a contestant. His performance was equally good to performances by established artists.
-Drew. BEEN THERE. DONE THAT! She was definitely right with Drew.
-Melanie had the best performance of the night.

I dont know why y'all are coming for Nicole every night.

This. Simon's starting to get on my nerves, seriously. Remember last year's UK show, when Cheryl put Cher on the stairs and he was bitching like 'why would you do that, it's boring', and now he's doing the same thing.

I think bottom 3 tonight will be:
- Astro
- Marcus
- Chris/Drew

Wasn't excited about last night's show, hopefully the next one will be better!

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by TheDjole

This. Simon's starting to get on my nerves, seriously. Remember last year's UK show, when Cheryl put Cher on the stairs and he was bitching like 'why would you do that, it's boring', and now he's doing the same thing.

Simon is the biggest hypocrite. He said one of the reasons he created the show was because he got bored of seeing contestants stand there and sing with just mic stand on Idol, yet that's what he's been doing with his acts.

Like I said before, I hope Paula gets the girls next year, she knows what it takes to put on a show.

[Shy Boy]

On now

[Shy Boy]

Did Steve say 16 million people voted last night? Idol would never openly admit that

[Superbitch]

OMG lol at Simon booing Nicole. Triple dead at LA calling Steve Mr personality.

[Superbitch]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Did Steve say 16 million people voted last night? Idol would never openly admit that

Idol lines are open for a whole day x factor is only for two hours.

[potent]

Drew needs to go home. I don't like her voice, and she's does the same ****ing thing every week...hell I didn't even really like her first audition I would have said no

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by Superbitch

Idol lines are open for a whole day x factor is only for two hours.

Idol voting is open for 2 hours, 4 hours for the finale.

[Superbitch]

Originally posted by Airhead

And Melanie is FAKE!

Some of her friends tried to.go.off on me lol. I was laffing really hard.

I see she trynna get all of us people with accents votes.

Not mine tho I stopped voting once lakoda rayne left.

[Shy Boy]

We get to pick their songs next week! We may finally get some good song choices

[Queen Xtina]

All I need is Melanie to stay, the rest can go.