[Ozzy8923]

Hmm.. I expected #1.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Candy Shop: Rolling Stone #93 (3) = 3
Beat Goes On: Slant #2 (10) = 10

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

[ECNEICSNOC]

Of course you would use a flattering (80s) picture of Madonna.

[YSL]

That flawless picture of Madonna though. Her image used to be so amazing.

[alkralkra]

Originally posted by Jameson Teqkilla

Is Joanna Newsom gonna win?

Even if she counted, she would have nothing on the Queen Polly so...

[YourMadGesty]

If Mariah beats out Madonna....

[Deemy]

Ashanti should have been in this. Im sure she would have easily made Top 20. Go look for her receipts.

[ECNEICSNOC]

Originally posted by YourMadGesty

If Mariah beats out Madonna....

madges already said he forgot about Mariah while compiling the list.

[DullEnlightenment]

#4



Robyn:

Albums:
Robyn: Pitchfork #39 (8), Q #37 (3), Pazz & Jop #80 (8), Slant #2 (17), EW #2 (10) = 46
Body Talk: Pitchfork #15 (10), Rolling Stone #14 (10), NME #65 (8), Pazz & Jop #13 (10), Slant #2 (17), Spin #10 (15), EW #3 (10) = 80
=126

Songs:
Be Mine!: Pitchfork #21 (8)
Cobrastyle: Rolling Stone #61 (3)
With Every Heartbeat: Pitchfork #57 (3), Pazz & Jop #90 (3), Slant #14 (8) = 14
The girl and the Robot: Pitchfork #68 (3) = 3
Dancing On My Own: Pitchfork #4 (10), Rolling Stone #26 (5), NME #42 (5), Pazz & Jop #3 (10), Slant #1 (15) = 45
Cry When you Get Older: Spin #8 (10)
Hang With Me: Pazz & Jop #84 (3)
Call Your Girlfriend: Pazz & Jop #20 (8), Slant #6 (10) = 18
Indestructible: Slant #7 (10)
Dream On: Pitchfork #161 (3)

Metacritic: 58

TOTAL: 301

[like2throw]

Originally posted by YourMadGesty

If Mariah beats out Madonna....

she wont

[madonnas]

i said it before, I forGOT mariah, I did my research and she has 54 points though.

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Originally posted by madonnas

That bitch didn't have a hit!

O I missed that that was a qualifier. She would scalp if she did tho!

[Kang.]

Question does WAY count as a "hit" for Janelle Monae?

[Stephen]

Robyn

Originally posted by Muggwa

Question does WAY count as a "hit" for Janelle Monae?

It should. Janelle easily ***** on everyone listed so far even without it though

[fortheloveofmusic]

Village Voice Tracks Of 2009


1. Jay-Z (ft. Alicia Keys) - Empire State of Mind - Roc Nation
95. Alicia Keys - Try Sleeping With a Broken Heart - J

I expect to see Keys in the Top 2

[simon]

NOT her AGAIN!

[like2throw]

Originally posted by DullEnlightenment

#4



Robyn:

Albums:
Robyn: Pitchfork #39 (8), Q #37 (3), Pazz & Jop #80 (8), Slant #2 (17), EW #2 (10) = 46
Body Talk: Pitchfork #15 (10), Rolling Stone #14 (10), NME #65 (8), Pazz & Jop #13 (10), Slant #2 (17), Spin #10 (15), EW #3 (10) = 80
=126

Songs:
Be Mine!: Pitchfork #21 (8)
Cobrastyle: Rolling Stone #61 (3)
With Every Heartbeat: Pitchfork #57 (3), Pazz & Jop #90 (3), Slant #14 (8) = 14
The girl and the Robot: Pitchfork #68 (3) = 3
Dancing On My Own: Pitchfork #4 (10), Rolling Stone #26 (5), NME #42 (5), Pazz & Jop #3 (10), Slant #1 (15) = 45
Cry When you Get Older: Spin #8 (10)
Hang With Me: Pazz & Jop #84 (3)
Call Your Girlfriend: Pazz & Jop #20 (8), Slant #6 (10) = 18
Indestructible: Slant #7 (10)
Dream On: Pitchfork #161 (3)

Metacritic: 58

TOTAL: 301

who the hell is that? That aint robyn lol

[Ozzy8923]

Hold Up! Mariah in the Top 4?

What kind of parallel universe.?

[alkralkra]

Beyoncé top three. Not that I expected nothing less.

[Deemy]

The Swedish Robyn