[Dylan']

Originally posted by Ray Bass

I'll send them before but you have a deal

VOTE FOR AWARDS
only the lovely Nicole did so far.

[Dylan']

Ray is in...HW comes first then Results.....but Ray just broke my heart and murdered one of you with rates.

[Dylan']

Hello guys! I have your results here with me now!
First....each judge judged in a different way.
So i will post each Judge's Rates Separately.
Now make sure you read this:
Whoever Gets Immunity This Round Gets To GIVE another contestant immunity as well meaning the remaining members have a 25% chance of leaving
Also no automatic vote will go towards the last place contestant.


Now Here are the results!

ethan:

Miley Cyrus - Pernament December

DillonATRL - 9 - This is the most overrated song by her fans but I do like it! It sounds outdated now but if Hollywood had actually treated her like they did Selena and Demi with their lastest eras I think she would have done well...but this album was just too much too soon I guess You picked one of the best ones of CBT so nice choice Ethan.

Aly & AJ - Speak For Myself

DillonATRL - 7.5 - Ethan...the thing this song has going for it is the whole self empowerment bandwagon so I guess I can see WHERE you were coming from....but it wouldn't have smashed or done top 40 if released back when they were relevant. If I Could Have You Back or Like It or Leave It would have been a better choice...I'm not sure where Chemicals React peaked but that song was

medosuxx:

Emily Osment - Lovesick

DillonATRL - 8.5 - You hit my soft spot...I really LOVE Emily! Her album was solid and she just does her own thing which I like. I think this song could have killed the Dance Charts with a proper release by her. and done well if Ke$ha had done the song so good choice medo.

Miley Cyrus - Robot

DillonATRL - 10 - YES YES YES!! Even though Overprotected by Britney flopped...I could have seen this being huge! even if it was Miley herself who released it! One of my fave choices medo.

theREALslimSHADY:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart

DillonATRL - 9 - Yet another choice from CBT...This song always lacked some sort of "oomph" for me but once again if Hollywood had given it a proper release it could have had a good run on the charts! Poor Miley

Hilary Duff - Stranger

DillonATRL - 10 - This song gets so much praise here I almost get annoyed. But I'm really surprised that you were the only one to submit it. since it's raved about My 2nd favorite entry...although it was as original as submitting Firework for Self Empowerment Anthem round still nice choice! The video is as well!

TimmyInTheWell:

Ariana Grande - Put Your Hearts Up

DillonATRL - 5 - Even Ariana's fans do not like this song Timmy They autotuned Ariana wheb she doesn't need it AT ALL. Plus it was just so cliche Not a smart choice Timmy.

Demi Lovato - Solo

DillonATRL - 5.5 - Ok so yes I like this song Timmy but it would not SMASH ever...I'm really disappointed because you are the most Disney out of the contestants left...Remember December would have been a MUCH better choice! Sorry Timmy..

rihannabiggestfan:

Miley Cyrus - Liberty Walk

DillonATRL - 10 - YASSS! This song has that whole "stand up" feel going on and I liked that you included the whole which artist you would have wanted to sing it although it's a bit immature for GaGa...but i get what u were saying. Great choice David.

Demi Lovato - Get Back

DillonATRL - 6.5 - it does kinda sound like Katy Perry's OOTB sound...but I just don't see this smashing...although I'm listening to it right now and it is just not the best choice though David.

borntodie:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart

DillonATRL - 9 - Basically in a nutshell the same thing I said to slinSHADY...it lacks somethinfg musically but Miley got screwed over so bad that era. Nice choice Anna! Your next choice thoigh

Lindsay Lohan - Rumors

DillonATRL - 10 - OMG YES YES YES I FRICKIN LOVE YOU FOR THIS!!! HANDS DOWN THE BEST CHOICE. Lindsay's whole discography is so underrated it hurts. Rumors is one of the most underrated pop tracks ever imo. She delivered well in the video....had it all going for her with this....only thing is....she's Lindsay Lohan amazing entry Anna! oh and Ray is a ****ing punk ass bitch for his rate

ethan:

Miley Cyrus - Permanent December: 10/10: If this song had been released, it would have SMASHED so hard it would be up there with Party In the USA and The Climb. I'll never forgive Hollywood Records for screwing her over. Actually, Ke$ha could have easily sung this and it would have smashed.

Aly & AJ - Speak For Myself: 10/10: This song would have done really well for Avril Lavigne or Kelly Clarkson. I think even Katy Perry could pull this off. This is a good song and it definitely would have done well.

Overall: 10/10: Both choices are stellar and great, and both would have smashed if released by major pop stars.[/QUOTE]

medosuxx:

Emily Osment - Lovesick: 7/10: Well, this song probably wouldn't have done well no matter who sung it. Maybe Top 40 or Top 30 if sung by Ke$ha or Jessie J maybe. But I can't imagine any pop star singing this. Sorry

Miley Cyrus - Robot: 10/10: Avril Lavigne or P!nk could have made this a hit. The attitude of this song specifically fits them out of all the popstars. Miley's vocal range also fits them. So seeing either of them make this a hit would have been awesome.

Overall: 8.5: Robot has more flavor to be a hit than Lovesick so that's why you get an 8.

theRealSlimShady:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart: 10/10: Britney Spears, Rihanna, & Ke$ha could easily pull this off and make it a hit. It's club banger material and very dark. Would have been a sure fire #1 hit for Britney or Rih, and probably Top 3 for Ke$ha.
Hilary Duff - Stranger: 10/10: I feel like Britney could pull this off, but at the same time, so could Kelly Clarkson. The lyrics of Stranger are just fit for an Unusual You/Inside Out type of Britney song and for Kelly it could fit under the whole Already Gone/Dark Side/Behind These Hazel Eyes type of song. So this being AT LEAST a Top 10 would have been in the bag!

Overall: 10/10 Great job.

rihannabiggestfan:

Miley Cyrus - Liberty Walk: 8/10: Beyonce could have done this song and it would have worked, and Rihanna could have done this for controversy but otherwise, I feel like Miley deserved to have this song

Demi Lovato - Get Back: 1/10: The thing about the album Don't Forget is that it ages badly. Demi was 16 here, and well, this album is just too young for any of the major popstars. I rarely listen to the album anymore because her next two albums are more mature. This is just pure teen pop and it wouldn't fit anyone. Heck, it was a terrible single choice for even Demi.

Overall: 4.5: You could have done way better.

TimmyIntheWell:

Ariana Grande - Put Your Hearts Up: 6/10: I really can't see any popstar doing this song. Kelly Clarkson might be a longshot, but it sounds like a song she would do. Otherwise, bad choice. You

Demi Lovato - Solo: 1/10: None of the pop star girls could pull this off. Ever.

Overall: 3.5: Timmy, how did you get this far when you're choices have been so crappy these last few rounds? Drew was more consistent than you!

borntodie:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart: 10/10: Well, I'm not gonna repeat myself but this would have worked for major pop girls so good job
Lindsay Lohan - Rumors: 10/10: YES! Britney Spears should have done this and it would have smashed for sure. Actually, she should have recorded it for Blackout and then it would have been more epic than Piece Of Me.

Overall: 10. Good job

ethan:

Miley Cyrus - Pernament December
Aly & AJ - Speak For Myself

Alexz - 10 - 2 amazing songs, specially Speak for Myself, it's my favorite from Aly and Aj's debut album, I can totally see Katy releasing and smashing with this song on the OOTB era.

Permanent December is so catchy and infectious, radio would have definitely played the **** out of this song if released by a major popstar.

medosuxx:

Emily Osment - Lovesick
Miley Cyrus - Robot

Alexz - 9 - (I'm so pressed that Emily didn't smash, Lovesick is sick, amazing, she's so underrated.) Anyway, great choices, I can totally see Lovesick slaying, tho I'm not so sure about Robot, it's a great song but I don't know if GP would understand or digest this song, I think it would have the same fate as Marry The Night ().

theREALslimSHADY:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart
Hilary Duff - Stranger

Alexz - 9.5 - You can totally see the influence of Gaga in WOMH, with that being said, I can totally see Mother Monster singing this song (TFM era), and having similar success as Telephone.

Stranger is an amazing song, and while I don't see it smashing and selling like crazy, It could totally give a major pop star (maybe Rihanna) a top 15/10 hit.

TimmyInTheWell:

Ariana Grande - Put Your Hearts Up
Demi Lovato - Solo

Alexz - 8.5 - I love PYHU but I don't see it smashing or doing anything for any major popstar (maybe Gaga if she changes the title to "Put Your Paws Up" ), except for Ariana, 'cuz it has her style and sweet personality all over it.

Solo is a great song, Demi's narrative writing style on this song gives me Taylor's "We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together" teas, so maybe this song would have smashed if released by Ms Swift.

rihannabiggestfan:

Miley Cyrus - Liberty Walk
Demi Lovato - Get Back

Alexz - 9 - Liberty Walk is my favorite song from Miley, it's an amazing empowerment song, I can see it being a top 20/15 hit if released by Gaga (BTW era).

I have learn to appreciate Get Back, but it's definitely not Demi's best, and I can't really see it smashing with vocals from another popstar, I can see this song as an album filler on OOTB.

borntodie:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart
Lindsay Lohan - Rumors

Alexz - 9.5 - You can totally see the influence of Gaga in WOMH, with that being said, I can totally see Mother Monster singing this song (TFM era), and having similar success as Telephone.

(I was so obsessed with Rumors and Lindsay back in 2004/2005, I was such a stan ,)

Rumors did great despite peaking low at HOT 100, and while it has a great appeal to mainstream radio, I can't really see any popstar matching or surpassing Lindsay's success.

ethan

Miley Cyrus - Pernament December

Ray Bass: 9. “I actually like the radio-friendly beat that hops all over the track, and maybe if the chorus was indeed sung by an actual female Pop superstar like Katy, and with some re-work being done here and there, this could be a hit.”

Aly & AJ - Speak For Myself

Ray Bass: 5. “I always remembered them as the sisters that starred in Cowbelles. , and Potential Breakup Song is awesome! But this song feels kinda flat and uninspired from the beginning. It even sounds generic and a whole lot like any other song made by any other Disney star to fill up an album.”

medosuxx:

Emily Osment – Lovesick

Ray Bass: 7. “I had NO idea Emily Osment had a singing career! The beat is pumping and the song is obviously aimed for us to party! I can imagine Nicole Scherzinger or Havana Brown pulling off a song like this, but I still feel it kinda weak. .”

Miley Cyrus – Robot

Ray Bass: 9. “The anticipation to the chorus actually had me hooked, and I did heard CBT, and this is one of the best songs on there… the chorus is not that flat, and I could see this be a hit with some work being done to the song. Nice entry.”

theREALslimSHADY:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart

Ray Bass: 3. “Such a flat song and weak hook. The chorus is not even pumping, the lyrics are really average, I can’t ge tinto this song at all. I can’t imagine no Pop star pulling this songo ut and making it a hit.”

Hilary Duff – Stranger

Ray Bass: 10 “There’s a kindness in your eyeeeeeees.. the way you look at me is just not right! Perfect song, awesome lyrics, the verses slay and the chorus is one to sing along and be remembered. Britney could’ve pulled this song in a blink! Great job on this one TRSS!”

TimmyInTheWell:

Ariana Grande - Put Your Hearts Up

Ray Bass: 10. “I loved this song! Never heard of this girl before, but she’s actually pretty and the song is nice… she has a real nice and soothing voice! The song’s structure is awesome and I definitely thing this song could be a hit for another major superstar… Great job Timmy! ”

Demi Lovato – Solo

Ray Bass: 5.5. “Early Demi has this rock-pop style that makes her sound way too Teen-sounding. Like, you might say Avril, Pink and Kelly have this style, but their sound sounds way more mature than Demi’s, who in fact did showed her growth as an artist when Unbroken once released. But I have a hard time imagining this being a hit.”

rihannabiggestfan:

Miley Cyrus - Liberty Walk

Ray Bass: 5. “I had a hard time imagining other artist sing this because it really seems the song was meant for Miley, but even if Liberty Walk was sung by someone else, the song screams ALBUM TRACK, and I would rather have it like this, and not as a single that would flop on Top 40 radio.”

Demi Lovato - Get Back

Ray Bass: 3.5. “Waaaaay too much of a teen-pop song for this actually being successful at any given sense, specially in Top 40 radio. I can’t see Britney, Rihanna, Katy… no one singing this song other than another Disney star. The actual teen-pop songs that work on Top 40 radio and the US market are songs with the CMM beat-progression, but this to be honest would flop big time if released by a major superstar.”

borntodie:

Miley Cyrus - Who Owns My Heart

Ray Bass: 3. “Such a flat song and weak hook. The chorus is not even pumping, the lyrics are really average, I can’t ge tinto this song at all. I can’t imagine no Pop star pulling this songo ut and making it a hit.”

Lindsay Lohan – Rumors

Ray Bass: 2. “I seriously can’t see this working at any level. Weak verses, and the chorus sucks in every level, to be honest, no Rihanna could save this. LiLo did have star power when this song was released, but Rumors wasn’t the right song for her to have a successful music career.”

Leaderboard:

1.theREALslimSHADY: 8.875 IMMUNE + PICK 1 OTHER PERSON FOR IMMUNITY
2.ethan: 8.8125
3medosuxx: 8.6875
4.borntodie: 8
5.rihannabiggestfan: 6.5 IMMUNE BY SLIMSHADY
6.TimmyInTheWell: 6.25 NO PENALTY

OK guys! Here is how you have to vote...once slimSHADY decides who he is giving immunity...THEN you vote. You all have a 25% chance of leaving then

[Four]

Congrats to theREALslimSHADY!



But I'm so disappointed, Guilty Pleasure is a masterpiece and yet NO ONE picked a song from that album. Shame y'all.

[Dylan']

Originally posted by Four

Congrats to theREALslimSHADY!



But I'm so disappointed, Guilty Pleasure is a masterpiece and yet NO ONE picked a song from that album. Shame y'all.

IKR
It's bad when the first single is the almost worst track on the album...but oh so good

[MusicLoverDude]

Yay for Slim

[Dylan']

Originally posted by MusicLoverDude

Yay for Slim

so isn't Guilty Pleasure an underrated masterpiece?
Let's talk....Overrated

[theREALslimSHADY]

i gotz the immunityzzz?!?!?!?!

finally!!!

and i get to give it to someone else??!! i m really confused between two ppl!!

[Four]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

so isn't Guilty Pleasure an underrated masterpiece?
Let's talk....Overrated

Overrated is SO underrated.

Acting Out, What If, Hair, Hot Mess, Masquerade, Time's Up are my favorites.

[Dylan']

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

i gotz the immunityzzz?!?!?!?!

finally!!!

and i get to give it to someone else??!! i m really confused between two ppl!!

yes you and another contestant will have immunity.

post your decision on the thread!

[theREALslimSHADY]

and ray's 3 screwed my dcore.. 9.5, 10, 9.5, 6.5!!

but again .. did better than i expected i would!!

[Dylan']

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

and ray's 3 screwed my dcore.. 9.5, 10, 9.5, 6.5!!

but again .. did better than i expected i would!!

wellllll considering he gave Ariana Put Your Hearts Up a 10 and Rumors a 2.... i'm heartbroken.

[Dylan']

Originally posted by Four

Overrated is SO underrated.

Acting Out, What If, Hair, Hot Mess, Masquerade, Time's Up are my favorites.

Hot Mess....nothing sounds like that song

[ethan]

Nice job slimshady! We went from the bottom two a couple rounds ago to the top 2 this round

On another note, I was so close! Which is SHOCKING! Thank you guys so much for your ratings! I was TOTALLY picturing Speak for Myself for [OOTB] Katy or Kelly!

[ethan]

Originally posted by Four

Overrated is SO underrated.

Acting Out, What If, Hair, Hot Mess, Masquerade, Time's Up are my favorites.

Acting out is amazing!

[Dylan']

Well guys try to keep this active...I gotta go to bed...I was supposed to be in bed...and done with homework i guess that's what ssr is for. bye!!!

[ethan]

Thanks for posting results tonight Dillon!

[theREALslimSHADY]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

yes you and another contestant will have immunity.

post your decision on the thread!

Originally posted by DillonATRL

wellllll considering he gave Ariana Put Your Hearts Up a 10 and Rumors a 2.... i'm heartbroken.

i will post in a couple minutes!!

and yeah but we dhould be easy on ray! he probably heard most of the songs for the first time!

[theREALslimSHADY]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

Well guys try to keep this active...I gotta go to bed...I was supposed to be in bed...and done with homework i guess that's what ssr is for. bye!!!

awwh... thanx for the results .. we know how busy you are!!

this is still my favourite place on atrl..!!

[theREALslimSHADY]

Originally posted by ethan

Nice job slimshady! We went from the bottom two a couple rounds ago to the top 2 this round

On another note, I was so close! Which is SHOCKING! Thank you guys so much for your ratings! I was TOTALLY picturing Speak for Myself for [OOTB] Katy or Kelly!

i remember that .. it was during the know your judges rounds!!

but we came back to slay as usual!