This was my rate (In Bold the ones that didn't make it) :
It (pennywise the clown)
Freddy Krueger
Samara Morgan ("The Ring" movies)
Death (final destination series)
Mary Shaw ("Dead Silence" movie)
Jason Voorhees
Chucky
Michael Myers
Ghostface (Scream)
The killers from the movie "Wrong Turn"
Leatherface (texas chainsaw massacre)
Leprechaun
Alien
Predator
Jigsaw ("Saw" movies)
Ben Willis ("I Know What You Did Last Summer" movies)
Almost all of my killers made it.