[JM4ever]

Originally posted by Quiqui4eva

Taylor Hicks?

His first album is kind of a hit.

[Jeiboy]

Originally posted by Auren

I'll make sure to remember this thread (and the new one in Base) if Jessica flops.

But Phillip will flop harder in the long run...

[JM4ever]

Originally posted by ABEL

Who did Jessica loose to again? I forgot his name already.

I dunno gurl. His name sounds like some cigarette brand.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Blu Jays unite!

To all Jessica supporters we can all talk here for her debut album!

[jj99]

Both Jessica and Skyler will Outsell Phillip...

[Right Now]

Why are Jessica fans so pressed though? If you have faith in her, the winner shouldn't matter.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by JM4ever

I dunno gurl. His name sounds like some cigarette brand.

also
isnt it a light bulb brand?

[fortheloveofmusic]

JASNDJDSANSDANJADDJNJDN I MADE THE JLO CHEAP GIF LMAOOOOOO

[Cap10Planet]

There's no telling.

I remember EVERYONE (as in most pundits and messageboard posters) was rooting for Bo Bice to beat Carrie Underwood. Carrie won, sold millions and won Grammys. Where is Bo Bice? Sometimes America does get it right.

[Wepamiso]

Originally posted by jj99

Both Jessica and Skyler will Outsell Phillip...

I agree, Skyler will be the next Taylor Swift in terms of success

[Navin]

You guys are living in an alternate universe if you think Jessica has nay chance at success.
Shes going to be exactly like Pia is now, forgotten.

Philip won't be a smash or anything but atleast we'll get some quality from his as opposed to cheesy pop ballads from 2000.

[Shy Boy]

Phillip will sell more albums but Jessica's singles will do better. Triple A and AC are the only formats that will touch his music. With the right music Jessica can have some Top 40/Rhythmic hits.

[Benzene]

Yep, Jessica is definitely gonna outsell Phillip, just like Haley and Lauren outsold Scotty.

[Witness]

I don't have faith in any of them to do well. Phillip might push 200k, way more than he would've done without the win. That could in all likelihood be the best result of this season. Maybe Skylar can do a little better than that. I dunno.

[LightandDarkness]

You guys are insane, if you think American Idol is done! The show still brings in over 17 million viewers weekly in its (11th season).

[Matty]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

I agree with about 2 more years. I have tried to watch the show recently & can not get through it anymore. It seems empty. Whether my current perception is a result of me growing up or the show itself becoming worse & worse is up for debate.

I mean I watched like 25% of this season. I really could care less who won and who lost, I was mad that Skylar got eliminated, she was my fav. Usually my favs always win or become runner-up's except Skylar so you can tell that was a ****** a season. Haha just kidding, the logic was off. But yeah there will be more seasons but it's just going down hill and fast.

[Parks]

Originally posted by berberocka

But Phillip will flop harder in the long run...

Phillip might very well flop, but it's hilarious seeing all of you with your crystal balls calling Jessica a legend, a superstar, etc. We'll see what happens.

[Heels Over Head]

[Rabid Anarchist]

Lemme just tell y'all now: NEITHER Phillip NOR Jessica will be successful. At all.

Remember when David A. lost? How everyone said he'd sell more than David C.? And Pia? And Haley? And Lauren? And Crystal? Face it: AI just isn't the career making force it once was.

At least, at the end of the day, even with his lack of success, I think Phillip will make good music. A nice indie folk record, and I'm totally here for that. He isn't your average WGWG. Jess, on the other hand, is your average dime-a-dozen belter.

[supertiffany]

Nick Jonas ‏@nickjnoas
BUT JESSICA IS THE REAL WINNER GUYS. IF AMERICAN IDOL WAS ACTUALLY BASED ON VOICE, SHE WOULD'VE WON.