[Mastamaind]

Godga

Edit: NOT at ATRL giving me a WP for a 'stan name' (Godga ) in this particular thread when it has tone and a different sense of humor and every stan in the forum throwing a 'stan name' once in a while.

Who made this happen? I wanna have a kanversashan with ya

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by DullEnlightenment

We didn't want pics for Britney, Aaliyah or Amy but thanks anyway.

You're all going straight to hell.

Originally posted by like2throw

what makes you so sure?

She wasn't the most acclaimed female artist of the 2000s at all

[shayne]

Originally posted by madonnas

#7



Lady Gaga:
Albums:
The Fame/Monster: Pazz & Jop #31 (8) = 8
Born This Way: Q #30 (3), Rolling Stone #6 (15), Pazz & Jop #30 (8), Slant #3 (17), P = 35

Songs:
Poker Face: NME #21 (8), Pazz & Jop #13 (8), Slant #2 (10) = 26
The Edge of Glory: Q #5 (8), Rolling Stone #7 (10), Pazz & Jop #23 (8), Slant #8 (10) = 36
Paparazzi: Pitchfork #83 (3), NME #9 (10), Pazz & Jop #11 (8), EW #2 (10) = 31
Love Game: Pazz & Jop #90 (3) = 3
Telephone: NME #25 (8), Pitchfork #55 (3), Pazz & Jop #17 (8), Slant #6 (10) = 29
Bad Romance: Pitchfork #39 (5), Rolling Stone #10 (10), Pazz & Jop #7 (10) = 25
Born This Way: Pazz & Jop #26 (5), Slant #5 (10), Spin #29 (5), Guardian #18 (5) = 25
You and I: Rolling Stone #26 (5), Pazz & Jop #46 (5) = 10

Metacritic: 15

TOTAL: 243

not a kesha pic

[DullEnlightenment]

#6

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/A_KFlQKCUAAJ0ab.jpg:large

Rihanna:

Albums:

Songs:
S.O.S.: Pitchfork #95 (3), Rolling Stone #36 (5), Pazz & Jop #19 (8), Slant #1 (15) = 31
Umbrella: CoS #47 (2), Pitchfork #5 (10), Rolling Stone #3 (10), NME #5 (10), Pazz & Jop #2 (10), Slant #1 (15), EW #1 (12) = 69
Don’t Stop the Music: Pitchfork #70 (3) = 3
Shut Up and Drive: Paz & Jop #60 (3) = 3
Disturbia: Rolling Stone #11 (8) = 8
Rude Boy: Pazz & Jop #31 (5), Pitchfork #35 (5) = 10
Only Girl: Pazz & Jop #71 (3) = 3
What’s My Name?: Pitchfork #77 (3), Pazz & Jop #57 (3) = 6
Man Down: Q #13 (5) = 5
We Found Love: Pitchfork #67 (3), NME #26 (5), Pazz & Jop #18 (8), The Guardian #9 (8) = 24
Where Have You Been: Slant #15 (8)= 8
Love the Way You Lie: NME #74 (3), Pazz & Jop #18 (8) = 11
Run This Town: Pazz & Jop #34 (5) = 5
Live Your Life: Pazz & Jop #13 (8), Pitchfork #40 (5) = 13
All of the Lights: Pazz & Jop #54 (3), Slant #1 (15) = 18
Take Care: Slant #1 (15), Pazz & Jop #51 (3) = 18

Metacritic: 12

TOTAL: 247

[Kang.]

Legend.

[alkralkra]

Impressive.

[like2throw]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

You're all going straight to hell.



She wasn't the most acclaimed female artist of the 2000s at all

If you say so, keep in mind shes the only pop artist that scored an 80s with her albums on metacritic (besides robyn and amy)

[Jabril]

Rihanna more acclaimed than Gaga?

[GeezusHaberdash]

SOS being her second most acclaimed song after Umbrella

[JungleDisturbia]

Rihanna coming so far just on singles alone.

[BLaCKPoWeR]

y do ppl sit naked in front of open windows that makes no sense lol ne ways yay con rats rih

[-Alfie-]

Death! I am loving this thread!

[simon]

Originally posted by madonnas

No.

Why not include Destiny's Child with Beyonce? You included features for artists like Rihanna that spiked up their scores.

[madonnas]

If you wre wondering, 65 of her points were from features!

[madonnas]

Originally posted by simon

Why not? You included features for artists like Rihanna that spiked up their scores.

And I did the same with Beyoncé's features. I didn't include No Doubt in Gwen's score either.

[primo.]

[-Alfie-]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

SOS being her second most acclaimed song after Umbrella

Sis, update your tumblr link on your siggy, its not working

[Deemy]

Originally posted by simon

Why not include Destiny's Child with Beyonce? You included features for artists like Rihanna that spiked up their scores.

Its not Destiny's Child feat. Beyonce. And she's already in the top 5. Why the bitching?

[Jabril]

Originally posted by JungleDisturbia

Rihanna coming so far just on singles alone.

Right?

[alkralkra]

Originally posted by HausOfJabril

Rihanna more acclaimed than Gaga?

With seven albums I would hope she has more acclaimed material