[MusicTalker]

Originally posted by Aliens & Rainbows

Miley Did you see Crystal's backhanded comment on Twitter?

Crystal is so cool

I can't wait to see the contestants smirking while she mentors them

[MusicTalker]

Poor Paige

I feel so bad for her right now, I just want to go & hug her

[KarlosVzla]

The climb is tougher than When I Look At You and Miley's not known for lyp-synching. I think she will sing live... im so excited!

[Pon.]

wow, Miley djd a good job

Paige = EPIC!

One oF the "best" performances of this season so far, even "better" than "Smile"

[Bad Wolf]

Can we just skip to the top two, Crystal & Siobhan?

[Pon.]

^
this week, Michael Lynche was way better than Siobhan IMO

[Mickey]

Siobhan is falling into a pattern. Which isn't good. Her surprise notes aren't really surprises anymore...

I thought Crystal sounded silly when the song sped up. I couldn't tell if she was actually saying lyrics or making scat-like noises!

Overall, a poor night.

[INTRA]

Siobhan

[fpppy]

my fav performances of last night were

1. Crystal Bowersox
2. Siobhan
3. Didi Banami
4. Katie Stevens
5. Michael Lynch
6. ALex
7. Casey



My picks to go home are either Paige or Tim

[yankee04]

Who would have thought that Miley was one of the better mentors in recent memory? She actually had good advice about what was wrong with some of the contestants and what they needed to do to improve that.

Go Siobhan!!!!!!!! The only contestant I care about at all. Crystal is the only other worthy competitor (I'm not a fan of Crystal's but anyone can see she has talent). Everyone else shouldn't even be there.

[Reeces]

Last night was a mess, and the sad thing is that it wasn't even Miley's fault, she actually did decently as a mentor. This is how I would rank last night's performances.

01. Crystal - A-
02. Siobhan - B+
03. Lee - B
04. Katie - B-
05. Aaron - B-
06. Didi - C+
07. Casey - C
08. Michael - C
09. Paige - D
10. Tim -
11. Andrew -

I'm hoping Andrew goes home next week, he has gotten so many chances and there is no way he is gonna improve or have a decent performance. I predict the bottom 3 being Andrew, Tim and Paige.

[Яeo.]

They sing songs that no young audience care about. They should sing more "relevant" #1 hits.

[migaruler]

i hope andrew gets eliminated
i cant stand his face & voice

[MusicTalker]

Paige & Tim are the bottom 2. They were by far the worst.

The other spot is open to Andrew, most likely.

[migaruler]

bye bye paige
*cries*

[Evan]

Andrew should be out. He's performed horribly the whole time. I'm sticking with my promise to myself at the beginning of Top 16, I'm so done with Idol now that Paige is out.

[MusicTalker]

Tim is gone next week, most likely.

Paige . What happened, girl?!

Andrew needs to rebound. He has yet to wow me again.

[KarlosVzla]

MILEY CYRUS That performance was undeniably great!

[Matty]

Paige

I'm sorry everyone, the only reason why Tim is still hanging by a thread is because hes got the girl's dialing his number til the 2 hours are up. Now they get to see him in tour, time for him to go. Andrew is annoying me, I want another "Straight Up" remake but no everything else is crappy. Get it together Andrew.

[Fireman25]

why was Katie in the bottom 3 and not Andrew he did horrible! Anyway I agree with the bottom 2 Paige and Tim both suck but Paige so I knew that would be going home.