I just want idol to have a certified successful winner before they go out
Me too this year and next year. Even PP's second album (130K so far and 350-450K lead single) didn't sell well tho... So from s10 beyond, only Scotty broke out. Phillip's will be measure by the sales of his third era
Nick is so bland as a performer. Hes so stiff on that stage for the amount of experience he has with his band; I'd expect him to be a better performer but I think Clark just has more charisma and marketability factor. I can see Clark having some moderate success unlike Nick. He'd be loved by the critics I think as well.