[BlueGangsta]

Cannonball out so early

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Dream

I know I'm very late noticing this but I just remembered "Round Round" wasn't chosen for the Sugababes' six songs It would have been a 10 from me tbh.

I'm glad the MUCH superior "Hole in the Head" was chosen. "Round Round" can't even compare (plus it already undeservedly won the Sugababes singles rate).

[Ace Reject]

Who's here?

[posh]

Perched for The Saturday's demise.

[Superiore]

I'm ready for The Saturdays to own their night!

[Dream]

Am ready

[Doogle]

What About Us and All Fired Up are the only Saturdays songs I truly hated, so they can go and Higher can too.

[Ace Reject]

Oh, that's coming.

BUT FIRST!

5.3

8 - lovesong, Regina George
0 -Maneater

Let's ignore Louise in that graphic. I barely remember how this goes, and that was a common comment from the voters. Superiore called it "well-nourished boredom," while Subomie found it "bland" and reminiscent of "a Whitney Houston b-side." Dead on, and IAM is a big sign as why post-Louise Eternal could not have worked in the US - their style of "R&B" was NOT what American R&B was ****ing with at the time. Trust me, I was there.

[Dream]

I don't even remember how this one goes

[posh]

If any Eternal song had to get kicked early, this should be the one.

[Superiore]

I don't even remember it Bless them!

[Doogle]

I don't remember that one.

[Ace Reject]

What's crazy is them performing this as one of their comeback singles now, when they have JAMS like Just a Step From Heaven in their discography!

NNNNNNN at this next group only having one single left.

5.455

10 - Maneater
2 - TheOnlyOne, Mikal

Subomie found Blame It on the Weatherman, their fourth and final UK number one, to be "surprisingly decent," but Mikal only offered one word: "No." supaspaz, however, really fell for its charms (??!?), calling it "mature and compelling, [with something almost] like pathos here."

I don't remember/try to block out Edele's voice any chance I can get, but do you boo!

[Doogle]

I loved that one

Easily one of my favourites in the whole rate, oop.

[Dream]

Mature and compelling?

[posh]

10 - Maneater

Extremely mediocre and boring song. B*Witched only had one worthy song in this rate and it's going to make it to the top 10.

[Superiore]

Mature, supa?

It was a cute bop and it could've lasted a little longer, though.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by posh

Extremely mediocre and boring song. B*Witched only had one worthy song in this rate and it's going to make it to the top 10.

No it won't. But it did go top ten in the US! So there's comfort there.

Y'all are semi-wrong for this one. Obviously the joys of quality cheese pass you all by.

ATOMIC KITTEN - IT's OK!

5.65

10 - Maneater
2 - PeopleLikeUs, posh

The audacity for PLU to give anything a two considering his favorite group in this rate. It's OK! will never win any prizes for breaking molds or pushing boundaries, but it is a really cute bop! lovesong found it "pretty uninteresting," and a "song that could have been sung by anyone else [without] sound[ing] different."

Yes, that's really true. It's also a marvel how they managed to make one of their originals sound like karaoke! But I gave it an eight, because I've got MEMORIES attached to it. Pretty banging chorus, and the beginning sounds eerily close to Michelle Branch's You Get Me aka the theme song to MTV's Sorority Life. (Or whatever the hell that show was called!)

Coming up: One particular group is doing nothing, cause at least they're doing nothing wrong! (Except getting OUSTED.)

[Ace Reject]

The drama you all have been craving.

5.828

10 - Regina George
1 - posh

If Atomic Kitten really could be any group of three girls that work at a fish and chips shop, then the Saturdays have the look and sound of five Topshop co-workers who get together on weekends to 'harmonize.' After six years, there really is no defining ethos to anything they do. Now I've had all this time to get used to their basicness, but apparently you all hadn't - which is reflected in their score here. lovesong sighed that "once again [The Sats showed up with] a loud, generic, dancey song," while posh hated it so much that he didn't bother to comment. BlueTimberwolf offered some advice, though: "It would [be] better with less autotone." When your group is home to Mollie King and Frankie Sanford, two of the most personality-deficient 'vocalists' to pick up mics, it doesn't seem like that would be in the cards.

Still gave it an eight though!

[Subomie]

I proudly gave It's OK a big fat 0.