[Arith]

Originally posted by Rokker25

No one knew of that song with Claudette Ortiz, it wasn't even a single. Rhythm Nation was HUGE and people instantly realized the choreagraphy when she performed RTA.

Actually, some people knew it existed (I know I did lol). But that doesn't really make the situation of Shakira & Claudette ANYT less copying likie everyone says Bee did Janet. And didn't Beyonce say that was a Janet rtibute because MTV was still black-listing her?

[mig123]

Originally posted by A.S.

Hips Dont Lie (Shakira)= Dance LIke This (Claudette)

claudette is not the owner of the song plus she never constributed in it ...... its wyclef's song ...... and he gave it to shakira >.<

and she turned it into a more than 50 countries #1 HIt


but you cant deny RTA was so janet jackson rhythm nation ...

[Arith]

Originally posted by mig123

claudette is not the owner of the song plus she never constributed in it ...... its wyclef song ...... and he gave it to shakira >.<

and she turned it into a more than 50 countries #1 HIt

You are such a stanning hypocrite, it amazes me :rolleyes

Just because the song was a hit, it doesn't make her any more unoriginal than you claim Beyonce is. The faster you realize that, the better

[A.S.]

Originally posted by mig123

claudette is not the owner of the song plus she never constributed in it ...... its wyclef song ...... and he gave it to shakira >.<

and she turned it into a more than 50 countries #1 HIt


but you cant deny RTA was so janet jackson rhythm nation ...

Like Arith said it doesnt make it any less of a copying situation.

[mig123]

thats like saying beyonce is the owner of "my boo" ft usher because she sang it first .....SIKE

shakira constributed into the song and made it hers........

[A.S.]

Originally posted by mig123

thats like saying beyonce is the owner of "my boo" ft usher because she sang it first .....SIKE

shakira constributed into the song and made it hers........

LMAO no offence but seriously what an idiot! Beyonce never put her vocals on My Boo at all. That other version is not Beyonce!!!

[Arith]

Originally posted by mig123

thats like saying beyonce is the owner of "my boo" ft usher because she sang it first .....SIKE

shakira constributed into the song and made it hers........

Your denial/stanning to the max amazes me sometimes

Just accept that if Beyonce isn't original because she's inspired by someone/something, then Shakira isn't original for jacking Claudette's song

[A.S.]

Also Mig just for future when you wana be annoying ill give you a better example to try and prove ur pointless/crap point. Beyonce recorded Resentment, which was also recorded by the others (including Victoria Beckham).

[mig123]

Dance like this

Writer(s) W. Jean, J. Duplessis, L. Parker, Omar Alfanno
Producer(s) Wyclef Jean, Jerry "Wonda" Duplessis


Hips Dont Lie

Writer(s) W. Jean, J. Duplessis, Shakira, L. Parker, O. Alfanno
Producer(s) Wyclef Jean, Jerry "Wonda" Duplessis, Shakira


too bad miss claudette never got credit......

anyways this thread is a beyonke and her trying to pull rhythm nation ........ she need to stop with her recycling factory

[Brihfl2]

Just downloaded that claudette song, omg hips dont lie is a total rip off, or vice versa, i will never feel the same way about that song

[A.S.]

Originally posted by mig123

Dance like this

Writer(s) W. Jean, J. Duplessis, L. Parker, Omar Alfanno
Producer(s) Wyclef Jean, Jerry "Wonda" Duplessis


Hips Dont Lie

Writer(s) W. Jean, J. Duplessis, Shakira, L. Parker, O. Alfanno
Producer(s) Wyclef Jean, Jerry "Wonda" Duplessis, Shakira


too bad miss claudette never got credit......

anyways this thread is a beyonke and her trying to pull rhythm nation ........ she need to stop with her recycling factory

LMAO are you that freakin stupid? You still dont understand that Shakira went through that same damn recycle factory that people keep claiming Beyonce goes through?

To the person who posted above me, Shakira's song is a rip-off of Dance Like This

[mig123]

umm no..... wyclef gave her the song...... she didnt go around searching for it >.< dont act smart now..


beyonce steals without asking.

[SIMon1120]

i love Beyonce dancing!!!

She has great moves

[Playboy]

Originally posted by A.S.

lmao thanx. It was actually fun just sitting round and watchin music DVDs. The concert renewed my love for Beyonce, that woman can do no wrong, she was on point in every single song especially the ending of Free.

Yes she did... I love that dvd

[A.S.]

Originally posted by The Playboy of R&B

Yes she did... I love that dvd

Tell me bout it... I mean it may seem a bit obsessed but i watched the whole thing about 4 or 5 times this weekend. Yeah I have no life at the moment with end of year exams lol. I never realised how good it was.

[Playboy]

I watch it all the time, when I'm bored. I wonder how she gon top it on her next tour/dvd.

[mig123]

any beyonce fan that has it ?? could please pass it to me

[Arith]

Even if I had it, I wouldn't send it to you

j/k

No; I don't have it. You better ask them hardcore Beyonce stans

[DIARIO]

can someone PM it to me as well?

[mig123]

Originally posted by Urban Advocate

Even if I had it, I wouldn't send it to you

j/k

No; I don't have it. You better ask them hardcore Beyonce stans

behh ive been looking in Dj's forum but no luck the single includes the instrumental ....... im preaty sure one of beyonce fans has it