[MusicTalker]

Jennifer Lopez - 9. Yes, I gave her a higher basic rating than Keri Hilson. Keri has a better voice. Jennifer never travels outside of a certain box. She does whatever is the latest trend. Her vocals are limited & her albums bland. I only like two-three songs from her, almost all from LOVE? (which is a weak album with a couple highlights). And she was definently inspired by other popstars for LOVE?.

[staracademy1990]

Originally posted by bigpimpdaddy

Christina A next plz

J-lo - 6

Christina Aguilera: 5.86

[BPD]

Originally posted by staracademy1990

I cant at those results... Xtina is not basic

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Jennifer Lopez - 9. Yes, I gave her a higher basic rating than Keri Hilson. Keri has a better voice. Jennifer never travels outside of a certain box. She does whatever is the latest trend. Her vocals are limited & her albums bland. I only like two-three songs from her, almost all from LOVE? (which is a weak album with a couple highlights). And she was definently inspired by other popstars for LOVE?.

What about being a fashion icon, or an actual movie star?

[Ace Reject]

8.75. Never recorded anything that wasn't kinda mediocre. Six albums in and not one ounce of critical acclaim; nor a signature song. One of the worst voices to ever be rewarded a record contract.

But I bump to some of her ****!

[staracademy1990]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Jennifer Lopez - 9. Yes, I gave her a higher basic rating than Keri Hilson. Keri has a better voice. Jennifer never travels outside of a certain box. She does whatever is the latest trend. Her vocals are limited & her albums bland. I only like two-three songs from her, almost all from LOVE? (which is a weak album with a couple highlights). And she was definently inspired by other popstars for LOVE?.

She's much more than just a singer though, I don't see how some can say she's basic. When she has dominated every single category she's worked in (whether singing, acting, designing, judging etc..)

[£100]

Oh and 8 for Ms Lopez

[MusicTalker]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

What about being a fashion icon, or an actual movie star?

This thread is about her music career, not her other things.

I dislike when people are discussing her music, & one of the defenses is "she's done so much in music & television anyway, she's a fashion icon too..." etc. Sorry Deeds.

What was Avril's overall score btw? I hope it wasn't higher than a 5.

[Chris191]

10 to JLo

[LightandDarkness]

I don't know, JLo pretty much started the whole celeb perfume trend. She was also, one of the first celebrities from this generation against her contemporaries to have a career in all aspects: Singing, Acting, and having a brand.

[MrCookiepants]

She's had respectable singing and acting careers spanning over a decade. She's one of the most iconic beauties of our time.

Yet somehow she's still pretty basic. 7.

[TakeItOff!]

This thread...

I give JLo an 8.

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

This thread is about her music career, not her other things.

.

Since when?

Avirl got a 6. You know people are Jealous of the Songwriter of our Generation :alecz:

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by staracademy1990

She's much more than just a singer though, I don't see how some can say she's basic. When she has dominated every single category she's worked in (whether singing, acting, designing, judging etc..)

She's never dominated anything. She has no Oscar, or an Oscar nomination; she's never been the highest paid actress in Hollywood; she's only had ONE film gross more than 100 million with her as a headliner.

Julia Roberts, Sandra Bullock, Reese Witherspoon - those are women who have DOMINATED.

Jenny Lo has remained consistently mediocre in all of her endeavors, which also explains the failed clothing line(s), reality TV shows, producing efforts, etc and so forth.

But this thread is about her as a "musician" only. Keep it on topic!

[Fadicuss]

4.

I liked her a lot in her debuts.

If You Had My Love, My Love Don't Cost A Thing, Jenny From The Block, Waiting for Tonight, Play, Ain't It Funny (gipsy version), I'm Glad >>>>>

Now, her songs are kinda meh. But, still, I can't forget her old songs.

[BPD]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

Since when?

Avirl got a 6. You know people are Jealous of the Songwriter of our Generation :alecz:

Only a 6? She deserved a higher ranking

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by bigpimpdaddy

Only a 6? She deserved a higher ranking

Is this report worthy?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

Is this report worthy?

6.82 is closer to 7 than 6.

[YoYo]

8.

she has several good songs (waiting for tonight, Aint it funny) and has a good fashion sense but that's it. Her albums are very sloppy and poorly crafted.

[Entity]

WTF do you mean by 'basicness'. What are we rating?