TASK 3:
Promotional & Smear Ads
Scores ReceivedTARGET -O- [+2] to WAL*MART [+3]
foxaylove: Target defeats Walmart. 154-151
SiXo: Walmart defeats Target. 145-140.
Fireman25: Walmart defeats Target. 143-127
Matty: Walmart defeats Target. 155-135
Public Votes: Target defeats Walmart. 19-13
GOOGLE [+5] to YAHOO! [+0]
foxaylove: Google defeats Yahoo. 191-158
SiXo: Google defeats Yahoo. 188-128
Fireman25: Google defeats Yahoo. 155-139
Matty: Google defeats Yahoo. 140-130
Public Votes: Google defeats Yahoo. 42-08
.i.APPLE [+4] to MICROSOFT [+1]
foxaylove: Apple defeats Microsoft. 160-146
SiXo: Apple defeats Microsoft. 164-160
Fireman25: Apple defeats Microsoft. 156-133
Matty: Apple defeats Microsoft. 145-125
Public Votes: Microsoft defeats Yahoo. 27-20
BURGER KING [+3] to McDONALDs [+2]
foxaylove: Burger King defeats McDonalds. 174-166
SiXo: Burger King defeats McDonalds. 164-160
Fireman25: McDonalds defeats Burger King. 152-141
Matty: Burger King defeats McDonalds. 145-140
Public Votes: McDonalds defeats Burger King. 25-19
(Nintendo) [+2] to PlayStation [+3]
foxaylove: Playstation defeats Nintendo. 176-173
SiXo: Nintendo defeats Playstation. 186-174
Fireman25: Playstation defeats Nintendo. 190-138
Matty: Playstation defeats Nintendo. 170-145
Public Votes: Nintendo defeats Playstation. 54-53
COKE [+0] to PEPSI [+5]
foxaylove: PepsiCo defeats Coca-Cola. 167-142
SiXo: PepsiCo defeats Coca-Cola. 165-104
Fireman25: PepsiCo defeats Coca-Cola. 176-138
Matty: PepsiCo defeats Coca-Cola. 175-135
Public Votes: PepsiCo defeats Coca-Cola. 48-36
HONDA [+3] to TOYOTA [+2]
foxaylove: Toyota defeats Honda. 175-167
SiXo: Honda defeats Toyota. 176-149
Fireman25: Honda defeats Toyota. 200-116
Matty: Honda defeats Toyota. 180-125
Public Votes: Toyota defeats Honda. 17-07 (Unofficial)
KT&T: Congratulations #GetAlong (Walmart & PepsiCo), ReginaGeorge (Google), fiercE (Apple), Dancehall Queen (Burger King), futurelove92 (Playstation), and Igor (Honda)!!
JUDGES' SCORES in Primary Sources:
foxaylove
Quote:
|
Originally posted by foxaylove
Target:
Main Company Slogan- 40/50
Main Company Report- 35/50
Competitor Company slogan- 37.5/50
Competitor Company Report- 41/50
Total = 153.5
WAL*MART:
Main Company Slogan- 30/50
Main Company Report- 45/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 36/50
Total = 151
Regina:
Main Company Slogan- 47/50
Main Company Report- 44/50
Competitor Company slogan- 50/50
Competitor Company Report- 50/50
Total = 191/200
TheGeoKing:
Main Company Slogan- 38/50
Main Company Report- 40/50
Competitor Company slogan- 41/50
Competitor Company Report- 39/50
Total: 158/200
REGINA SLLLLLLLLAYYYYYEDDD!!!!
Fierce:
Main Company Slogan- 40/50
Main Company Report- 39/50
Competitor Company slogan- 45/50
Competitor Company Report- 40/50
Total: 164/200
RAWREMYRO
Main Company Slogan- 40/50
Main Company Report- 40/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 40/50
Total: 160/200
Dancehallqueen:
Main Company Slogan- 42/50
Main Company Report- 47/50
Competitor Company slogan- 41/50
Competitor Company Report- 44/50
Total: 174/200
Owl
Main Company Slogan- 39/50
Main Company Report- 44/50
Competitor Company slogan- 45/50
Competitor Company Report- 38/50
Total: 166/200
Igor
Company
Slogan: 44/50
Report: 41/50
Competitor
Slogan: 48/50 (AMAZING SLOGAN)
Report: 40/50
Total: 173/200
Futureluv92
Company
Slogan: 47/50
Report: 45/50
Competitor
Slogan: 42/50
Report: 42/50
Total: 176/200
J
Company
Slogan: 32/50
Report: 35/50
Competitor
Slogan: 40/50 "I am assuming they are insinuating that Pepsi is a flop like Nicole's cd was?...Gave me chuckles.
Report: 35/50
Total: 142/200
#Getalong1
Company
Slogan: 39/50
Report: 44/50
Competitor
Slogan: 40/50
Report: 44/50
Total: 167/200
Igor
Company
Slogan: 40/50
Report: 41/50
Competitor
Slogan: 46/50
Report: 40/50
Total: 167
futureluv92
Company
Slogan: 40/50
Report: 45/50
Competitor
Slogan: 40/50
Report: 50/50 YOU NAILED IT WITH THIS!
Total: 175/200
|
Matty
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Matty
Deuces:
Target (Slogan) = 40/50
Target (Description) = 25/50
Walmart (Slogan) = 40/50
Walmart (Description) = 30/50
TOTAL: 135/200
For the slogans I would’ve loved to see them more hitting to make an impact without being too long. As for the descriptions, I would’ve loved to see more stats to prove your point on both arguments.
Get Along:
Walmart (Slogan) = 35/50
Walmart (Description) = 50/50
Target (Slogan) = 30/50
Target (Description) = 40/50
TOTAL: 155/200
For the slogans, they were too long and the one your defending had some flamebait and that’s not cool. As for the descriptions, you’re defending one was perfect but your opponent descriptions lacked proof and stats.
Regina:
Google (Slogan) = 40/50
Google (Description) = 30/50
Yahoo (Slogan) = 35/50
Yahoo (Description) = 35/50
TOTAL: 140/200
For the slogans I thought they were clever but lacked a little something extra. As for the descriptions, I would’ve loved to see more stats to prove your point on both arguments.
Geo:
Yahoo (Slogan) = 30/50
Yahoo (Description) = 30/50
Google (Slogan) = 35/50
Google (Description) = 35/50
TOTAL: 130/200
For the slogans I thought they could have been better. As for the descriptions, I wish you would’ve used more stats but the google proof was a nice touch.
Fierce:
Apple (Slogan) = 40/50
Apple (Description) = 50/50
Microsoft (Slogan) = 25/50
Microsoft (Description) = 30/50
TOTAL: 145/200
For the slogans I wish you mentioned what you were defending and arguing better. As for the descriptions, Apple was great but Microsoft left me confused.
Rawr:
Microsoft (Slogan) = 25/50
Microsoft (Description) = 30/50
Apple (Slogan) = 40/50
Apple (Description) = 30/50
TOTAL: 125/200
For the slogans they could’ve been better. With your Microsoft slogan, I thought you were about to defend Covergirl products. As for the descriptions, I wish you had more stats to back up what you said.
Dancehall:
BK (Slogan) = 35/50
BK (Description) = 45/50
MD (Slogan) = 30/50
MD (Description) = 35/50
TOTAL: 145/200
For the slogans, I wish they were more hitting and shorter. As for the descriptions, I wish you had stats to back up what you said. For your BK description I like that you used some of the words that BK actually uses in their commercials.
Owl:
MD (Slogan) = 35/50
MD (Description) = 40/50
BK (Slogan) = 35/50
BK (Description) = 30/50
TOTAL: 140/200
For the slogans, I wish they were shorter and without the nicknames. As for the descriptions, I wish you had more stats for MD and against BK.
Igor:
Nintendo (Slogan) = 30/50
Nintendo (Description) = 40/50
Playstation (Slogan) = 40/50
Playstation (Description) = 35/50
TOTAL: 145/200
For the slogans, I wish they were shorter and more to the point. As for the descriptions, you gave more info against Playstation than you did for praising Nintendo.
FL:
Playstation (Slogan) = 50/50
Playstation (Description) = 40/50
Nintendo (Slogan) = 40/50
Nintendo (Description) = 40/50
TOTAL: 170/200
For the slogans, your playstation one was really good! As for the descriptions, I liked for Nintendo you still talked about Playstation to get people sidetracked about Nintendo. That could also be a bad thing though so be careful on that.
J:
CC (Slogan) = 35/50
CC (Description) = 30/50
Pepsi (Slogan) = 35/50
Pepsi (Description) = 35/50
TOTAL: 135/200
For the slogans, I wish they were better, although, I did like for your Pepsi slogan you tied it in to your description. As for the descriptions, I wanted more stats, but I liked the personal touch.
GetAlong:
Pepsi (Slogan) = 50/50
Pepsi (Description) = 40/50
CC (Slogan) = 45/50
CC (Description) = 40/50
TOTAL: 175/200
For the slogans, I enjoyed them and the CC one got my attention. As for the descriptions, more stats would’ve been nice but I also like how they intertwined in a sense.
Igor:
Honda (Slogan) = 45/50
Honda (Description) = 45/50
Toyota (Slogan) = 45/50
Toyota (Description) = 45/50
TOTAL: 180/200
Not much to say, this was actually really well done.
FL:
Toyota (Slogan) = 35/50
Toyota (Description) = 25/50
Honda (Slogan) = 35/50
Honda (Description) = 30/40
TOTAL: 125/200
For the slogans, I feel they could’ve been better. As for the descriptions, something about each of them seemed like they were copied and pasted and just little words changed.
|
SiXo
Quote:
|
Originally posted by SiXo
TARGET vs. WALMART
TARGET
Main Company Slogan- 45/50
Main Company Report- 20/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 35/50
Total = 140
WALMART
Main Company Slogan- 25/50
Main Company Report- 50/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 30/50
Total = 145
GOOGLE vs. YAHOO
GOOGLE
Main Company Slogan- 46/50
Main Company Report- 45/50
Competitor Company slogan- 50/50
Competitor Company Report- 47/50
Total = 188
YAHOO
Main Company Slogan- 15/50
Main Company Report- 38/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 35/50
|
Total = 128
Quote:
|
Originally posted by SiXo
APPLE
Main Company Slogan- 50/50
Main Company Report- 40/50
Competitor Company slogan- 50/50
Competitor Company Report- 20/50
Total = 160
MICROSOFT
Main Company Slogan- 30/50
Main Company Report- 40/50
Competitor Company slogan- 30/50
Competitor Company Report- 46/50
Total = 146
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by SiXo
BURGER KING
Main Company Slogan- 21/50
Main Company Report- 48/50
Competitor Company slogan- 45/50
Competitor Company Report- 50/50
Total = 164
McDONALD
Main Company Slogan- 50/50
Main Company Report- 43/50
Competitor Company slogan- 37/50
Competitor Company Report- 30/50
Total = 160
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by SiXo
Nintendo
Main Company Slogan- 48/50
Main Company Report- 48/50
Competitor Company slogan- 50/50
Competitor Company Report- 40/50
Total = 186
PlayStation
Main Company Slogan- 50/50
Main Company Report- 49/50
Competitor Company slogan- 30/50
Competitor Company Report- 45/50
Total = 174
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by SiXo
COKE
Main Company Slogan- 20/50
Main Company Report- 20/50
Competitor Company slogan- 26/50
Competitor Company Report- 38/50
Total = 104
PEPSI
Main Company Slogan- 39/50
Main Company Report- 40/50
Competitor Company slogan- 40/50
Competitor Company Report- 46/50
Total = 165
HONDA
Main Company Slogan- 40/50
Main Company Report- 45/50
Competitor Company slogan- 50/50
Competitor Company Report- 41/50
Total = 176
TOYOTA
Main Company Slogan- 46/50
Main Company Report- 45/50
Competitor Company slogan- 30/50
Competitor Company Report- 28/50
Total = 149
|
Fireman25
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Fireman25
Target:
DEUCES VENDETTA Slogan- 38/50
DEUCES VENDETTA Report- 22/50
I felt like the report was a bit short. It did not "wow" me. However, the slogan was better than the report.
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Slogan 12/50
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Report-45 /50
The slogan was WAY too long but the report was well written.
WAL*MART:
DEUCES VENDETTA Slogan- 34/50
DEUCES VENDETTA Report- 33/50
The slogan was a bit long, but creative. The report was mediocre.
#GETALONG MERIDIAN- 36/50
#GETALONG MERIDIANReport- 50/50
The slogan would have been perfect without the Lady Gaga line. To me it kinda ruined it for me. But the report was flawless.
127
143
Google:
REGINAGEORGE VENDETTA Slogan- 50/50
REGINAGEORGE VENDETTA Report- 50/50
The slogan was creative and the report was well written
THEGEOKING MERIDIAN Slogan 16/50
THEGEOKING MERIDIAN Report-23 /50
I wasn't feeling the slogan. It did not work for me and could have provided more reasons on your report. I felt like the report was rushed.
Yahoo:
REGINAGEORGE VENDETTA Slogan- 21/50
REGINAGEORGE VENDETTA Report- 34/50
Your slogan was weak but you provided good reasons for your report.
THEGEOKING MERIDIAN- 50/50
THEGEOKING MERIDIAN- 50/50
Everything was perfect. The slogan was simple, yet it was straight to the point and you provided a lot of imformation in your report.
155
139
Apple:
FIERCE VENDETTA Slogan- 50/50
FIERCE VENDETTA Report- 50/50
Well written report and the slogan is the best I've seen so far.
RAWREMYRO MERIDIAN Slogan 38/50
RAWREMYRO MERIDIAN Report-32/50
I wish you would have exlplained more of your reasons about Apple in your report. The slogan was okay.
Microsoft:
FIERCE VENDETTA Slogan- 45/50
FIERCE VENDETTA Report- 11/50
I liked the slogan but I your report was weak.
RAWREMYRO MERIDIAN - 40/50
RAWREMYRO MERIDIAN - 23/50
The "attention *****s" in your slogan kinda ruined it. I wish you could have added more to your report.
156
133
Mcdonalds:
DANCEHALL QUEEN Slogan- 40/50
DANCEHALL QUEEN Report- 50/50
Your slogan would have been great if it wasn't for "McProletariat" and I really liked your report.
OWL MERIDIAN Slogan 40/50
OWL MERIDIAN Report-50/50
Your slogan would have been great without the "Mickey Godamn D's". It made it look "too busy" The report was well written.
Burger King:
DANCEHALL QUEEN Slogan- 12/50
DANCEHALL QUEEN Report- 39/50
Your slogan was way over the top lol and your report was good. You had good reasons.
OWL MERIDIAN - 12/50
OWL MERIDIAN - 50/50
Just like Dancehall Queen, your slogan was over the top as well but great report.
141
152
I will PM you the last 3 reports tomorrow night.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Fireman25
Nintendo:
IGOR VENDETTA PRESENTS Slogan- 38/50
IGOR VENDETTA PRESENTS Report-30/50
The slogan was solid. But on your report, you only listed one example on why Nintendo is better.
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Slogan - 50/50
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Report- 40/50
Great slogan! and your report was reasonable.
PlayStation:
IGOR VENDETTA PRESENTS Slogan-20/50
IGOR VENDETTA PRESENTS Report- 50/50
I wasn't feeling your slogan but I loved your report. It was fully detailed.
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Slogan-50/50
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Report- 50/50
Good job! everything was great!
138
190
Coke:
J可愛い VENDETTA Slogan- 38/50
J可愛い VENDETTA Report-45/50
Your slogan is funny, but it's not a strong slogana and your report was good but I took points off because you misspelled "exist"
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Slogan - 50/50
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Report- 50/50
You provided a great slogan and a great report.
Pepsi:
J可愛い VENDETTA Slogan-20/50
J可愛い VENDETTA Report- 35/50
Your slogan wasn't that good and your report was fair.
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Slogan-40/50
#GETALONG MERIDIAN Report- 36/50
Your slogan was good but it was plain though. I wish you could have provided more details on your report.
138
176
Honda:
IGOR VENDETTA Slogan- 50/50
IGOR VENDETTA Report-50/50
Good job! You've provided a fully detailed report and the slogan was good.
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Slogan -20 /50
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Report- 30/50
I don' get why you had your report in 1st person. That is the one thing that I caught in your report that kinda ruined the report. The slogan was weak.
Toyota:
IGOR VENDETTA Slogan-50/50
IGOR VENDETTA Report- 50/50
Again great report and slogan.
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Slogan-30/50
FUTURELOVE92 MERIDIAN Report- 36/50
Your sloganw as too long and this report was a bit better than the last one.
200
116
|
Anyway, congrats FutureLove. 
